DougB
Member
I'm thinking of getting a couple of cap & ball revolvers. I have a percussion rifle I've shot periodically for years, and I have a number of cartridge handguns, but this will be my first experience with black powder handguns. I think I want an 1860 Colt replica (probably Pietta, maybe Uberti - if there's a good reason and it isn't too much more).
For my second, I'm thinking of an 1858 Remington clone with a 5.5" barrel and in stainless (Uberti). I think this would be a handy size to carry and shoot, and being stainless would allow me a little more leeway with regard to cleaning (I know it should still be cleaned soon after shooting, but I'm thinking that waiting a few days wouldn't be a big deal with a stainless gun - especially in my very dry climate).
My biggest concern is that I don't want something totally inauthentic (otherwise, a Ruger would be my top choice). Did Remington make this model with a 5.5" barrel - or were such conversions common? I realize that the originals weren't stainless, but I'm thinking that it might look enough like a well-worn original or maybe a brushed nickel version or one left "in the white" to be acceptible to me. I could go with the more standard longer barreled blued version for greater authenticity, but I think I'd enjoy carrying and shooting the shorter stainless model.
Anyone know if there were original 5.5" versions? Also, I've read that the cylinders are easy to remove, so I might get a spare to use as an old-fashoned speed loader - would this be practical?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts and advice.
Doug
For my second, I'm thinking of an 1858 Remington clone with a 5.5" barrel and in stainless (Uberti). I think this would be a handy size to carry and shoot, and being stainless would allow me a little more leeway with regard to cleaning (I know it should still be cleaned soon after shooting, but I'm thinking that waiting a few days wouldn't be a big deal with a stainless gun - especially in my very dry climate).
My biggest concern is that I don't want something totally inauthentic (otherwise, a Ruger would be my top choice). Did Remington make this model with a 5.5" barrel - or were such conversions common? I realize that the originals weren't stainless, but I'm thinking that it might look enough like a well-worn original or maybe a brushed nickel version or one left "in the white" to be acceptible to me. I could go with the more standard longer barreled blued version for greater authenticity, but I think I'd enjoy carrying and shooting the shorter stainless model.
Anyone know if there were original 5.5" versions? Also, I've read that the cylinders are easy to remove, so I might get a spare to use as an old-fashoned speed loader - would this be practical?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts and advice.
Doug