.308 win sizing problem

Status
Not open for further replies.
Innovative, on the other forum someone asked you a question, is it safe for me to assume you have a rapport with this person? You did not answer his question, instead you told him "There's no need to worry about locating the datum line"

Again is it safe for me to assume you do not know the answer or do you think he does not need to know?

F. Guffey
 
fguffey ......

I have no idea what "other" forum are you talking about.

Our Digital Headspace Gauge doesn't require locating the exact datum line, because the shoulder angle is exactly the same on your fired case as it is in your chamber itself. After our gauge is zeroed on a fired case, it measures one of your resized cases, and what gets displayed is the actual chamber clearance that YOUR handloads have in YOUR particular chamber.

It's obvious that constant arguing is enjoyable to you. You must have too much idle time on your hands. I'm replying to contribute helpful information to fellow shooters by describing our NEW method of measuring chamber clearance (at the shoulder).

- Innovative
 
Larry,

I've got a question, but first I want to say thank you. I use your collet resizing die and it's saved me hundreds of pieces of .300 Win Mag brass over the years I've had it. I shoot a Browning BAR .300 Win Mag, so my problem was magnified with the semi-auto. Thank you!

Now to my question. I see in the diagram above from Woods that the datum line is in the middle of the shoulder. Does your DHG measure off of this line for every caliber? My assumption is that it's measuring a relative headspace, off of the fired case, is that correct?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Chances are, when we meet intelligent life forms in outer space, they're going to be descended from predators."
- Michio Kaku


Innovative
Junior Member





USA
62 Posts
Posted - Dec 05 2009 : 14:14:32
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ten2six .....

There's no need to worry about locating the datum line, because the shoulder angle of a fireformed case is exactly the same angle as your chamber. Our Digital Headspace Gauge compares one of your fireformed cases to one of your resized cases, and displays the difference. That difference is your chamber clearance. You just need to know how much chamber clearance you have (at the shoulder), and our Digital Headspace Gauge tells you exactly that. I hope this helps.

- Innovative

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
fguffey .....

The answer to your question is no. Here's why . . . . There's no reason to find an exact measured location (datum line) on the shoulder. With my method, it's meaningless because both shoulder angles are the same. Our Digital Headspace Gauge is zeroed (calibrated) on one of your fired cases before inserting your resized case. When your resized case gets measured, the difference of those cases is then displayed. That represents the exact chamber clearance at the shoulder.

In other words . . . . if you take your measurements right on the datum line you'll get the exact same result. Just take your reading somewhere near center on the shoulder. Why spend extra time locating the datum line?

- Innovative
 
Ye Gods! For those of you who want to spend money on a device that measures something akin to cartridge headspace ( for lack of a better term), you can go 2 basic ways. Buy Innovatives tool or get something like the Stony Point ogive checker. Then, if you want to check the envelope of your cartridge you get a cartridge case gage a la Wilson. If you want to really be thorough, also get a set of headspace gages. Or, you can get all 3 for about $180. (guess).
 
Steve .....

For half that price our Digital Headspace Gauge can measure headspace AND measure bullet "jump" to the rifling. But there are always cheaper methods. Each to his own ....

- Innovative
 
Innovative..... For half that price... blah, blah, blah. I understand wanting to promote a product you feel to be superior to any other. But you'd get a little more sympathy were you to embrace the concept of using said tool with "cheaper methods". Your tool does not address;
banana cases
out of square heads
buggered extraction grooves
out of square necks
etc.
All of these and more could prevent a round from chambering properly. And some, if not addressed properly, due to the potentially erroneous reading your tool provides, could cause either short or long shoulder locations. Why not use a case gage AND your tool? If promoted this way, I'd certainly be more inclined.
 
steve .....

You forgot to mention that it won't bake cookies ..... it won't do that either.

I've used the Digital Headspace Gauge for years, and I just thought I'd make it available to all shooters. For years I've had shooters send me their cases for problem identification, and I can always identify the problem using this gauge. This may not be the tool for you, but as of this month there are now over 100 more shooters using them.

- Innovative
 
Last edited:
Innovative, You are welcome, I found the other forum for you, and thank you for the 'no' your rational for 'no' ends with "Why spend extra time locating the datum line? Means you do not know where it is or how to find it, anyone in a machine shop surrounded with equipment and tools and makes a comparator called a head space gage should be able to answer the question. If I designed, manufactured and sold a gage called 'head space gage' because no one can find the datum I would say I designed the gage because no one can find the datum, then I would repeat myself and again say the datum is nice to know and takes up a lot of space on the internet. for me I make up 'DATUMS' out of anything, 'DATUMS' do not hang me up, as to finding a datum? You can not make a head space gage without knowing where it is located, a head space gage can not be measured without the DATUM.



DATUM is the heart of the head space gage, when using a comparator on the shoulder of a case the shoulder is a CONE with varying diameters for the length of the neck, that is the reason I make up DATUMS, all that is required is I must use the same DATUMS when comparing the difference in length of one case to another., length is hot a factor, only the difference in length (standing that would be height) would be read.



Again, I want to carry one measurement from the chamber to the press back to the chamber, when I form a case to the chamber, it becomes the standard, a collector of Mausers in Northern Alabama surrounded with gun smith could not find a tool or smith that would check his rifles for head space, I made him a set of head space gages for the 8mm57 chamber from .000 (.005 short chambered) to .024 thousands over the length of a minimum length case, the problem? Some of his chambers were .318 (88 Commission), the rest were .323 (1905 and later) short story I made the gages in .318, one set of gages fit all of his 8mm57 Mausers, he called and said he was pleased with the results but was curious as to what to do with the rifle (88 Commission) that chambered the +.024 gage. he hung it on the wall.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7.92x57mm_I

F. Guffey
 
fguffey .....

Perhaps you are just hungup on the name of our gauge. It could have been more correctly called a Chamber Clearance For Your Handloads Gauge.
Instead of using a predetermined datum line, this NEW technique uses a designated datum line that is determined when you calbrate on a fireformed case. I don't plan to rename it, but does this help?

- Innovative
 
head space, no one that knows what is is has trouble finding it.

Perhaps I did not think you knew the difference between a comparator and a head space gage. I found a tool that was not related to reloading, $2.00, 70 years old, someone with me at the gun show asked me why I needed another tool, he said he knew I had at least 3 that were similar, both metric and standard, I said DATUMS.



A collector, smith, resource person, machinist, participant on another forum involved in a thread on datum and head space called me, basically he ask "HOW", I ask him if he was standing in front of the mill, drill press or lathe, he said he had all three, does it make a difference? My reply was that it did not make a difference to me because it can be done on all three, but as for me I make them (datum) up. Jim Tarelton is sharp, it did not take long to explain, I finished, he said "I be Damn", I then told him to go to one of his tool boxes and remove a tool (I did not ask him if he had the tool, he is a machinist, I knew he had the tool), he then said "OK, now what?", I said "think about it" and again he said "I be Damn".



I should not have had to provoke you to speak, never in all the time I have participated on any forum that you have been on do I remember you acknowledging there were other participants, in all these years I have not agreed with you but said nothing, going back to your collet die for magnums, RCBS made dies before the Internet called BAR dies for auto loaders, I have three sets, 300 Win Mag, 30/06 and 270, the M1 Garand chamber is larger than the chamber for the M1917 Enfield or 03, a different reamer was used on the Garand. When Browning made the BAR, the clearance was made into the die. As, I believe it was, Bart B. said he would cut the top and bottom of a magnum die off and call it a a body die before he would pay the kind of money you were asking for the die.



NEW technology? again the tool was 70 years old, because of age and neglect it was not easy to read, I did not design the tool, I found another use for the tool because those kind of things do not lock me up.



Starts with 'hung up' and finishes with "Does this help?" For satisfying a curiosity, your tool is expensive, as has been stated a Wilson case gage can duplicate case comparison measurements, go, no-go, and with a straight edge and the 'companion gage' to the press, the feeler gage, height gage, depth gage and dial caliper, the Wilson case gage can measure and compare case length from the shoulder to the head of the case in thousands. Datum? New technology? The Wilson gage does not use a datum, cases inserted in the gage seat on in the shoulder, if someone can measure case protrusion they can measure the effect the chamber has on the length of the case after it is fired, and if the case was measured before firing the difference in the two measurements indicates the effect head space had on the fired case. With one exception, the Wilson is free standing, stand alone gage, the minimum length on the cage is = full length sized, commercial length, max, length of the gage is less than .005 or shorter than the length of the perfect go-gage length chamber.



Instructions on the use of the Wilson gage may not have included the instructions in the beginning, the instructions are available now but according to Innovative the Wilson case gage only gives ball park figures.



The Wilson measures from the shoulder back to the head of the case and from the shoulder of the case forward to the mouth of the case.

The Wilson case gage determines the effect sizing has on the case, the Wilson case gage determines if the case is not sized enough, or as I said, if head space is know first the measurment can be transfered from the chamber to the press, die and shell holder and back to the chamber, the Wilson case gage is relitive to the chamber, sized case and fired case.

F, Guffey
 
fguffey ....

You must be a much faster typist than I am. Ha Ha I'd really like to talk to you sometime about several different reloading theories. Not to be arguementive, but it would be interesting.

I'd agree with you about the relevance of a datum line - if we were discussing the manufacture of reamers, rifle building or manufacturing production ammo . . . . . but trust me, it's not needed when reloading for a specific rifle.

I've read posts from Bart and I can tell he's an experienced reloader. In fact, my first prototype for a belted mag die was exactly what you described. After thorough testing, I found that it was plowing brass straight back against the belt. My collet design moves brass inward only. Since then, almost 3,000 shooters agree that my design works very well. That doesn't take anything away from 'ol Bart.

The Wilson case gauges are good tools. I have several of them. They measure cases within a + and - range of tolerance. However, they don't do what our Digital Headspace Gauge does. Our gauge gives the only measurement you need about chamber clearance (at the shoulder) that YOUR handloads have in YOUR particular chamber.


- Innovative
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top