.357 ccw?

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Agent-J

Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2008
Messages
155
What's available in this setup? I'd really like something in polished nickel/stainless.
 
That's a rather broad queston, Agent. We are talking anything from M27 to M42 and the Colts and the Rugers... Can you be more specific about your ccw requirements?

Mike
 
I carry One or Two of these 2" 357s, 617 Taurus shiny stainless 7 shot 357, SP101 Ruger shiny stainless 5 shot 357, 971 Rossi shiny stainless 6 shot 357, 605 Taurus mat stainless 5 shot 357, and all ways in the pocket a 642 S&W 38+P.
 
I have a S&W Model 60, 2 1/8 inch, stainless steel in .357, that I bought about 11 years ago. Great gun - wife has dibs on it. I also have two Colt Detective Specials (2nd and 3rd generations) that I carry on a regular basis. You can't beat a 2 inch revolver for ease of carry, accuracy and dependability in a small package. I bought the .357 in my Model 60 so it would handle .38 plus P ammo. I personally have never liked the .357 in a 2 inch small frame. More muzzle flip and harder to control for follow-up shots.

Colt - S&W - Ruger - Taurus/Rossi, all make good guns, just depends on what you want and are willing to spend. I would suggest that you go to their web sites or better yet, go to a gun shop and handle a few. The Colts are no longer in production, but can still be found in new condition on Gun Broker and other sites.
 
SP101 from ruger. I found it uncomfortable to shoot until I replaced the grips with one from Hogue. Others are lighter, but you get used to the weight.
durable and reliable
 
I enjoy my S&W 19 2.5". A model 66 would fit your SS preference.
Click to expand...
Daily carry for me, loaded with Win Silver Tips. I carry other guns but always come back to this one.
 
I heard at least 4 inches of barrel needed to get the 357 performance. Any truth to that?
 
I heard at least 4 inches of barrel needed to get the 357 performance. Any truth to that?
Click to expand...

No, it's not true. It might have some application for longer distance hunting shots, but not for SD. Many states have minimum barrel length and calibers for handgun hunting, and this should not be a consideration for thoughtful hunters. Older speer manuals have nice data where they compared actual revolvers (not test barrels) chrono'd velocities down to 2.5" length. The velocity drop was measurable but not huge. The 2.5" were doing on average about 150fps less than the 6.5" S&W 27. So this was like 1400 fps vs. 1250 fps for the best performing powders at SAAMI limits (like 296 or 2400).

I like the 2.5" 19 or 66 for carry - keep one of each on hand. The J frames and small Rugers are just brutal with full .357 loads. The K frame tames them nicely, but it's too large for an ankle gun - but it makes an outstanding IWB or other carry gun.
 
I have a Smith-Wesson 640 two incher. It's the centennial design, with the internal hammer, so it's double action only, but for the intended purpose, it's well suited. Also, if you ever want to carry it in a pocket holster, there's nothing to snag. It's offered in stainless steel. Another great choice is the Ruger sp101. It's offered in both spurred and spurrless hammer, also in stainless. Another good thing -- with quality, durable makes like Smith' and Ruger, if you want to save some cake, you can find either one used and still feel that you are getting a solid gun.
 
Since you have access to the internet go to the Ruger, S&W website, but also checkout Charter Arms, and Taurus (just to be fair I hate Taurus and will never buy one again but other people like them).

Then go to Gunbroker.com and select the Revolver options and in the search field type "357" (leave the "." off) and see what comes up. Colt, Dan Wesson, Smith, Ruger, etc, etc, etc, etc.

Shoot safe.
 
If you're intent on shooting .357 rounds, then the S&W 640 would get my vote. Add a Hogue Monogrip--or the Crimson Trace LG-305--and you've got a "semi-pocketable" carry package.

OTOH, if you really want a pocket carry gun, get the M&P340 with the CT 405 grips. And start on a shooting regimen to get your hand conditioned.

For non-pocket carry, consider any of the S&W K/L frame short-barrel revolvers--the most recent example would be the S&W 386 Night Guard--7 shots, 25 oz.

Jim H.
 
I heard at least 4 inches of barrel needed to get the 357 performance. Any truth to that?
Click to expand...

At least four inches are required to get optimum .357 performance, but shooting .357 from a shorter barrel doesn't turn it into a regular old .38 by any stretch of the imagination. .357 magnum packs a hell of a lot more wallop than .38 special even coming out of the shortest barrels.
 
I carry a S&W Model 13 with a 3 inch barrel. The same gun in stainless is a Model 65. It's a good carry piece if you can find one.

SWM13_001.jpg

ECS
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

D
  • Locked
Polishing a Polished Stainless SAA?
Replies
13
Views
2K
bannockburn
bannockburn
L
  • Locked
NEW Stainless 4" S&W 64 or 686 or USED Nickel 586?
Replies
14
Views
1K
buttrap
B
J
  • Locked
Nickel or Stainless
2
Replies
48
Views
2K
CraigC
CraigC
H
  • Locked
polished stainless or nickel, how to tell?
Replies
13
Views
5K
Gaucho Gringo
G
B
  • Locked
Landed a M66-2 today!
2
Replies
31
Views
1K
captain awesome
captain awesome
Back
Top