I buy Colt automatics and won't have the frame cut for a ramped bbl so that keeps me with the standard Super 38 and 45 ACP.
That makes sense. For a number of years in the 80s and 1990s and later some competitive shooters were overloading their guns way beyond maximun pressure to make major power factor and because the Super works so well in compensated guns. Many blew out the bottom of their cases. One response was to develp fully ramped and supported barrels.
But IMHO, if you don't overload the round you don't need these.
SAMMI sets the maximum pressure for various round. The 38 Super has a maximum pressure of 36,500 psi or 33,000 cup (copper units of pressure). By comparison the 9mm has a max pressure of 35,000 psi and 33,000 cup. The 40 S&W operates at a max 35,000 psi and the 45acp 21,000 psi max. ost loads work well below these maximums and don't need to get close.
The 9mm works at roughly the same pressure as the Super but with less case capacity. This means that the Super can reach higher velocities with the same weight bullets as the 9mm and do it at lower pressures. Which is easier on the gun and increases case life. It also means that the Super is more useful over a wider range of bullet weights.
The Super is slower than the 357 Sig in some bullet weights. But again it's length provides for more options with differing weight bullets and bullet types.
It's easy in the Super to get a 147 gr. bullet to 1200 or 1250 fps from a 5" barrel without signs of over pressure with the right powders.
You can also get a 124 gr. jhp moving at 1300-1350 from a 5" barrel again without reaching maximum pressures.
Personally I like both the 45 and the Super. For me it's not one or the other. In a lightweight Commander though I prefer the lighter recoil of the Super and the 9+1 rounds in the gun.
tipoc