I've had an Alaskan for about 2 months. It has significantly more recoil than my J-frame, 21 oz Model 60 does with .357s. I can shoot the latter until I'm out of ammo. The Alaskan? About 18-24 rounds/hand is my limit. 24 will leave my hand sore for a day or more - that is shooting full power 44 mag loads.
If I had to do it over again, I wouldn't. The gun is accurate. It shoots better than I do. However, the original rubber grips felt like sandpaper going thru my hand with each shot. I replaced them with the old style GP100 grips. Better, but I have small hands and the recoil goes to my thumb, not the web of my hand. I've ordered some Badger grips & will have to see if they help.
But mostly, the frame and cylinder are so big that I don't get much benefit from having a 2.5" barrel. A 4" in a S&W would give me the benefits of a longer barrel with almost no downside...maybe 1 oz heavier, but just as easy to carry on the belt and better ballistics and probably less muzzle jump. If the Badger grips don't help, I'll probably end up selling the Alaskan (at a big loss) and buying a 4/6 inch S&W...:banghead: