97 yo woman handcuffed for unpaid parking ticket

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stebalo

Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2004
Messages
312
Location
Texas
Associated Press


Texas Woman, 97, Cuffed on Ticket Charge


HIGHLAND PARK, Texas (AP) - A 97-year-old woman was handcuffed and taken to jail in a squad car for failing to pay a traffic ticket, but her son is questioning police officers' treatment of the former teacher.

Harriette "Dolly" Kelton had an outstanding warrant for failing to pay a traffic ticket when Highland Park police stopped her last week for having an expired registration and inspection sticker.

Kelton, who has lived in the northern Dallas suburb for at least 60 years, is a former teacher at The Hockaday School. She was in police custody for about two hours before her attorney arrived and was released on her own recognizance.

"A warrant begins with the words 'you are hereby commanded to arrest,' " Detective Randy Millican, Highland Park's public information officer, told The Dallas Morning News in Wednesday's editions. ``How do you decide who do you arrest and who you don't? How about at age 90 but not at 91 and up? How about between 17 and 20?''

Kelton's sons, a judge and a doctor, said she lives alone, cooks her own meals, goes out to lunch regularly and is involved in the community. She has good eyesight, they said.

"Our real beef with this is that no real judgment was displayed or actually carried out in this incident," said Dr. Phil Kelton Jr., a plastic reconstructive surgeon with Baylor University Medical Center.

"All of our enthusiasm should be tempered with judgment, and therein lies my problem with this and basically Mother's problem with it, too," he said.

State District Judge David Kelton said that it would be inappropriate for him to discuss the arrest.
 
From the situation described in the article, the judge's only response should be: "BWWWAAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
AHAHAHAHAHAAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHHAAHHHAHAHAHHAAHAAHAAHAA
AHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHHAHAHAHAAHHAHHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAHHHAHAH
HAHAHAHAHAHHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAHAAHAHHAHA. Case dismissed. HAAHHAAHAHHHAH............"


And a prompt beating with a Cluebatâ„¢ for the officer in charge.
cluebat.gif
 
I can't believe the actions of the arresting officers? Why was there no strip search? Don't they know that grandmas carry all sorts of menacing weapons, like hairspray, hairpins, etc?

If I were there, I would have maced the crap out of her, in order to insure my safety. After all, like Goglo said, cops going home at the end of their shift is the most important thing.:evil:
 
Don't mess with Tejas, grandma!!! They're a tough lot down there.:uhoh:

Meanwhile at the law office of Jasper Longstreet Lee:

"Mr. Lee, collect call from the county jug on Line 3. It's Dolly Kelton."

"Oh, no, not another fight in the buffet line!":D

Can't they just send out a bill?:confused: She would probably pay it the next day, in person!:D
 
I don't understand the outrage. She was issued a ticket and didn't pay the fine and still hadn't renewed her registration. So, a warrant was issued for her. The cop noticed she had a warrant out and arrested her.

Should she get a free pass because she's old? Are you advocating that once one reaches a specific age, he no longer has to follow the law? This is a non-story and we wouldn't hear anything about it if she was younger.
 
I don't understand the outrage. She was issued a ticket and didn't pay the fine and still hadn't renewed her registration. So, a warrant was issued for her. The cop noticed she had a warrant out and arrested her.

I have no problems with her arrest, but I doubt this was necessary:
A 97-year-old woman was handcuffed

I seriously doubt that handcuffing grandma was needed to insure the safety of the arresting officers.
 
Should she get a free pass because she's old?

An emphatic yes. There used to be a thing called respect for one's elder. Older people are forgetful, feeble and usually poor. She's probably had a hard life and deserves a break just for making it that far. 97 yr old people do not need to be restrained, it's an insult to them and a smear on the face of law enforcement.

I bet that cop's proud. He restrained her all by himself, no backup needed.:rolleyes:

Respect for elders should transcend enforcement commands. The older they are, the more respect and breaks they should get, barring special circumstances.


The cop should be flogged in the town square.
 
She's probably had a hard life and deserves a break just

If she's truly had a hard life should wouldn't make it to 97!

That officer was following a judges order--the last time I checked that was contempt and would land you in a cell with a nice fine as well...

At what age should citizens be able to ignore the law?

Which laws are OK for seniors to ignore but need to be enforced on the young'uns?

The cop should be flogged in the town square
:rolleyes:
 
Odd, when I got picked up on a bench warrant for an unpaid $12 ticket some 15-odd years ago, they wouldn't handcuff me, even though I asked 'em to. (I thought it would add to the whole "Being carted off to the pokey" ambiance of the experience. They said it would just make my wrists sore on the 30-minute drive to the county hole. :uhoh: ) They also recommended that I go 'head and smoke a cigarette before we left, as I wouldn't be able to take any into the jail with me; nice of 'em, really. I guess officer survival wasn't as high on the list of priorities in those halcyon days... :scrutiny:
 
Harry, Cannibal, I understand that the Sheriff was doing what he had been ordered to do, but the Southern practice of arresting people for infractions is moronic (even though thanks to that Tejas case couple years ago, it is just fine with the Supremes). Best to change the law and handle this administratively as we do in Yankeeland.

Free up the po-po from hauling in "Ma Barker", aka Tamara, and save the police from embarrassments such as this. I know, I know, that would make too much sense.:D
 
At what age should citizens be able to ignore the law?

Compassionate discretion friend. We're not talking an old murder warrant, we're talking a registration ticket.

Contempt of court eh? So the officer's carrer takes precedence over respect for one's elders? Good one. Good thing the oldster didn't try to put the young punk in his place, or he'd of had to taser her.:rolleyes:

I'd laugh at a judge and tell him it was worth it if he charged me with contempt for not bringing in 97 yr old on a registration ticket.

So basically, what you're saying is that it's against the law for officers to think for themselves? I suspected as much.
 
I'm normally the first to jump in and complain when the cops mistreat someone... but it really doesn't sound like anyone was jacked here. Lady broke the law, got picked up for another infraction, and when they saw the warrant, they arrested. Sounds like it was fine.


I just don't see it.

James
 
I think we should think about this case like she was our Grandma or Mother. I can see the officer taking the women down to jail, but I can't see why she needs to cuffed!!! I am sure that is the department policy, but LEO need to use a little discretion. She doesn't need to be treated as a dangerous felon who just raped and killed someone.
 
A long time ago, under circumstances that wouldn't be particularly interesting to you, gentle readers, I was involved in a physical altercation with several police officers. In pretty short order, they put me on the ground and cuffed me. I remained cuffed for the best part of an hour before I was released (I was never formally arrested nor charged). I'm here to tell you that handcuffs aren't comfortable. In fact, after a while they just plain hurt. I was a strapping young man at the time, so the officers could legitimately make a case that I needed cuffed for their safety and, ultimately, mine.
Now, any uniform that felt the need to cuff a 97 year old lady an arrest for a Mickey Moose charge like this needs to find himself another job ASAP. Right after his public flogging. The man clearly has no judgement or any sense of propriety. If I, or one of the other deputies, were to do something like this, The Sheriff His Own Self would leave that deputy completely assless (and badgeless) for the bad judgement displayed and for the bad publicity it would bring the Sheriff's Office.
 
The officer could have just as easily had the woman to follow him to the police station. In my opinion just putting hand cuffs on the woman was excessive force. You can bet Judge Kelton made some phone calls over this.
 
I guess I can see why someone might get upset over her being handcuffed (they were placed in front though). But none of this would have happened if she paid the original ticket and renewed her registration.

Who's fault is it that she didn't renew her registration the first time? It's her fault. How about paying the ticket and renewing her registration after being told to do so? It's her fault. Due to her indiscretions, a warrant was issued for her arrest.

Should she have been arrested? Yes. Should she have been handcuffed? That's debatable.

It seems like those arguing that she shouldn't have been arrested want the elderly to become "elite citizens" once they reach a certain age. Farmer's markets beware if something like this ever happens. If it's proper to base laws on age, why not race, sex, BMI, et cetera.
 
Cannibal, well, you can stop at "should she have been arrested.":D

The answer, as long as we are talking what ought to be, SHOULD be no. It's just an infraction.

Eliminate this silly provision where one may be arrested for infractions down there and substitute administrative sanctions instead, e.g. suspension of operator's license. Dealing with the BMV/DMV can be far harsher sanction than a night in the county jug, at least where I am.:D

Ma "Tamara" Barker: "Ummm, what are you in for""

Bobbi Jo Jean: "Burned down my boyfriend's trailer. How about you?"

Ma "Tamara" Barker: "Parking ticket. [silence as everyone in holding pen scoots away]":D
 
Handcuffing an older person like that is stupid in the extreme. What if she lost her balance and could not grab something and fell. Good possibility of broken bone/s, possibly a broken hip. At her age of 97, that is quite likely.

And, in many cases, for person that old, a broken hip is a death sentence at the max. And long rehab, lots of pain, and a long recuperation at the minimum.

Really stupid LEO.
 
If he put the cuffs on in the front I guess I would be willing to cut the officer a little slack. Still seems kind of stupid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top