OK I was able to get some numbers today.
Springfield 1911 9mm 5"
Mixed range brass, unknown number of reloads S+B small pistol primers,
charges checked for weight then loaded as thrown from Lee Pro disk on Lee turret.
Outside temp 95 F
RMR FNs loaded 1.08 OAL
RMR HPs Loaded 1.11 OAL
(I normally load the FNs to 1.10 but I had a request to test a bit shorter)
.
RMR 124 gr FN 4.5gr CFE Pistol
999.00
1004.00
995.00
1016.00
1009.00
Average 1004.60
ES 21.00
SD 8.26
PF 124.57
RMR 124 gr HP 4.5 CFE Pistol
988.00
984.00
977.00
960.00
987.00
Average 979.20
ES 28.00
SD 11.56
PF 121.42
(looks like I need to bump this load up at leat .2gr)
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
RMR 124gr FN 4.2gr HP38
1049.00
1027.00
1024.00
1036.00
1031.00
Average 1033.40
ES 25.00
SD 9.81
PF 128.14
RMR 124gr HP 4.2gr HP38
1039.00
1022.00
1020.00
1018.00
1026.00
Average 1025.00
ES 21.00
SD 8.37
PF 127.10
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
RMR 124gr FN 4.5gr BE86
1014.00
1013.00
1022.00
1030.00
1010.00
Average 1017.80
ES 20.00
SD 8.14
PF 126.21
RMR 124gr HP 4.5gr BE86
1025.00
1032.00
1037.00
1020.00
1014.00
Average 1025.60
ES 23.00
SD 9.18
PF 127.17
***Had to think about these #s for a minute, possible the HP rounds were in direct sunlight while the FN rounds were not.
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
RMR 124gr FN 3.7gr Titegroup
1040.00
1042.00
1031.00
1028.00
1020.00
Average 1032.20
ES 22.00
SD 9.01
PF 127.99
RMR 124gr HP 3.7gr Titegroup
1019.00
1037.00
1031.00
1022.00
1017.00
Average 1025.20
ES 20.00
SD 8.50
PF 127.12
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
RMR 124gr FN 4.3gr WSF
1013.00
1017.00
1031.00
1018.00
1014.00
Average 1018.60
ES 18.00
SD 7.23
PF 126.31
RMR 124gr HP 4.3gr WSF
998.00
1001.00
987.00
1002.00
982.00
Average 994.00
ES 20.00
SD 8.97
PF 123.26
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
No test of the FNs whith these charges
RMR 124gr HP 4.8gr Autocomp
1051.00
1064.00
1036.00
1040.00
1029.00
Average 1044.00
ES 35.00
SD 13.73
PF 129.46
RMR 124gr HP 4.8gr CFE Pistol
1049.00
1063.00
1062.00
1079.00
1055.00
Average 1061.60
ES 30.00
SD 11.26
PF 131.64
So I would say the HPs are a little slower than the FNs given the same powder charge. Not a lot but a bit, which is a concern for those people who need to make a PF.
Nothing wrong with this of course, and it is to be expected with different bullets.
Some of these charges are below the recommended start charge for jacketed but I was comparing them to my plated loads.
I was able to shoot a couple targets from 10 yards (someone else was shooting at 10) then we had to pull back to the line at 15 as other people arrived. Most ammo in this round of test was in the shade. On most of my other tests the #s were from ammo that was in the sun. (no shade on permission use only, but it is nice having your own little "private" range where you can shoot from 0 to 25 yards, but you have to get there early to get it)
I am
sure the bullets can do better once
1. I do load work ups for them
2. I am not having a can't hit
day (CHS rears it's ugly head)
Load work up results and re-shoot coming soon.
So try not to laugh to hard everyone, I would hate for anybody to fall out of their chair and hurt themselves. ( I almost didn't post these because I was shooting poorly, but I thought everybody could use a good laugh)
Again, I am sure the bullets can do better, I wasn't shooting my controls well either today. sigh......
10 yards unsupported
I also did a quick test of BE86 at outside temp vs out of my ice chest. #s here
http://www.thehighroad.org/newreply.php?do=newreply&noquote=1&p=9996063