Over the years I have been on the look out for a quality 22 that is light and easy to haul around the back country. Not having owned many of the rifles mentioned here I am speaking from my experience.
My least favorite 22 so far was the Marlin PPS (Papoose) which is the one that breaks down and fits into the stock. It could have been a bad production day or the design is not well executed either way there was no consistancy in shot placement and from day one I was not able to feed an entire magazine without malfunctions, bummer.
Next up for bid is my OLD tube fed bolt action 22 which is able to feed 22/long/short all in the same tube back to back without thinking twice but when the round count hits the big goose egg it takes a little more time to get back in action.
Now for my crown jewel... the ever popular 10/22 rifle. I went this route because of the after market available for it. Barrel, stock, scope, trigger kit and other tweeks have turned my "everymans rifle" into mine.
Bottom line, do you want to leave the thing in stock out of the box condition or do you want to pimp your piece? I like to have fun tuning so thats what I did. High cap mags are all over the market along with loaders, bi-pods, lights etc etc, the list is long.
Figure out what you want to do then there are some things to think about...
Semi auto vs manual action (bolt/pump/lever)
-Semi auto is faster to get back on target after merely putting in a fresh mag but will gum up faster needing more maintenance cleaning wise, manual actions will continue plugging away even when fouled (to a point) but still need cleaning just not as much.
Purchase price (you only buy quality once)
Speed of reload (mag vs tube feed)
Parts (price and availability)
Accesories (to pimp or not to pimp)
High capacity mags (mostly the relm of auto loaders but 22 goes fast, think about finding something that takes high caps for that reason or you will be loading more than shooting defeating the purpose of trigger time)
Accuracy (duh!)