Maybe this belongs in PM, but...
iamkris said:
steel cased ammo will shred the insides of your gun. They say that it is so dirty that within 2 rounds, the rifle will be reduced to a gummy mess that only a 3 week solvent soak will take care of...
He called *those* claims poppycock. When Badger chimed in, it appeared to me that we were logically down to the "hey, MY experience is different" stage. Badger stated his opinion and why he has it.
Don't sound like no callin' nobuddy a liar, but maybe I'm thick-skinned when another's statements are challenged (yeah, it wasn't me getting contradicted).
Seems like everyone is forgetting the factor of "the batch _I_ shot from X rifle". Betcha some lots really are worse than others, and some finely accurate rifles (with match bullets, capable of less than 1 MOA all day long) won't fling one batch of Wolf into less than a 4-inch group...while another equally accurate rifle will shoot the same batch of Wolf to its apparent accuracy limit of 2.5 MOA.
Reminds me of the howls I got last year when posting a range report where the S&W Sigma was one of only two or three guns that didn't have a jam of some sort.
Different from YOUR experience does NOT mean that it didn't happen for the other shooter. Sheesh!
The original post was a classic "straw man" argument. Overstate the opposition's position to the point of being ridiculous, then knock the weak argument over with a feather. Don't fall for it.