An Absolute Beginner's Range Report: Armscor 1911 Practical FS DT

Status
Not open for further replies.

horge

Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2003
Messages
1,134
Location
Philippines
I'm not actually an 'absolute beginner', hehe. I was when I earlier posted my experiences with the Bersa Thunder 380
many months back, and hey, I still shoot like an absolute beginner ...so there. hehe


Range Report and Evaluation
Long bitten by the 1911 bug... I decided on an Armscor Practical Series fullsize 1911 in .45 ACP, in duo-tone, and sourced my unit from 'Starfire', a local gunstore chain. It was approximately US$357 for the Duo-Tone unit, and all handgun purchases here carry a heavy license processing fee of about US$90.

The Armscor Practical comes in a hard black plastic case with eggcrate-foam padding.
armscornib.jpg

Bundled with the pistol were two 8-round magazines, an instruction manual with line drawings, and an AFAD gun-safety pamphlet. 1 year warranty form. No bushing wrench provided (or needed: field stripping was easy). 'Starfire' threw in a 10-pack of XTP's on discount, with the admonition to break the pistol in with FMJ only.

The pistol sports a skeletonized 'combat' hammer, skeleton trigger, upswept beavertail, ambidextrous extended thumb safety, and Novak-style no-snag rear sights. Both rear and front sights are dovetailed into the slide. The Duotone configuration involves a nicely-blued slide with broadly-cut, canted rear and forward traction grooves (aka serrations), plus blued safeties all on a 'stainless steel' frame. It was handsome at first and second glances.

On close inspection, I was disappointed with the unit. The green 'inspection card' indicated fitting and testing just the month prior at the Armscor plant in Marikina, suggesting a very new pistol. Unfortunately, it seems the parts used in assembling this pistol were a mix of old surplus and culls. Many of the non-stainless internals were coated with a veneer of fine rust, particularly the trigger 'stirrup'. The recoil spring guide rod was stripped of blueing. Virtually all of the fine rust came off with oiled rag wipes. It was not some orange-brown grease or preservative. It was rust.
:what:

The 'stainless' frame --apparently the only part bearing a serial number by the way-- is a dull grey-white, frosted finish. Even this 'stainless' steel frame had a spot of rust, right below the thumb-safety detent ball, concealed by the left grip panel. The frame's ramp was not polished --being the same dull finish as the rest of the frame. I am actually unsure if the frame is indeed of stainless steel, or merely plated with a dull chromium alloy.

The slide stop had corrosion breaking out through the blueing. The logo on the slide was actually crooked, and wearing off. This affair seemed to be a baked-on logo and too easy to remove. Note the legs of the 'ARM' in Armscor. Check the slidestop for corrosion:
armscorlogo.jpg


The chromed barrel had very tiny pits and scuffs on both lands and grooves, even after cleaning...
armscorbarrelpits.jpg


I felt the plastic grip panels had too many sharp edges, and frankly, the 'black' of it all appealed little to me and my wife. We went off and bought ourselves some local grips, made of ebonywood ('kamagong'), priced anywhere from 150 to 250 pesos (3 to 5 US dollars) each:
armscorgrips.jpg


It was hard to find 1911 grips that don't have those funky 'gold' medallions set into them. All the grips we got were for the GI configuration, and had to be relieved a bit for the ambi safety. Anyway... here's how the piece looked with wooden grips (screws not tightened yet), and I think it's an improvement.
armscornewgrips.jpg


Stripped and cleaned, lubed and checked, with better-looking and better-feeling grips on... it was off to the range, with a box of Armscor FMJ. The first five magazines were a bonanza of break-in failures, mostly FTF: maybe that ramp was just too nasty at the start, and maybe the mags were themselves stiff... but hey, that's what breaking-in supposedly involves. The trigger was quite nice, but could've used some lightening --but then maybe that was just more fine rust on the trigger 'stirrup', beginning to come loose... hehe. I disliked the ambi safety: those long levers seem to actually get in the way of things. However, they were a standard feature of the model, and thus I had signed up for them.

The pistol shot low, and I learned to cover the target with the front sight. By the ninth magazine, things started settling down, and I ran some quick freehand 'Mozambiques' on a fresh target board at 10-plus meters.
armscorgroups.jpg

Pitted barrel or no, it can shoot.

Ball supposedly does the job of stoppage, and this pistol enjoys a constant diet of ball. There was slight hesitation when it tried feeding the XTP's --but no outright failures. Still I was too fagged out to shoot anymore. The thing weighs a ton after awhile. For all its weight though, the thing pointed rather naturally for me. Amazingly natural point, really.

I think with more breaking in and tweaking, it can be a very servicable weapon.
It is for me, however, perhaps too heavy for quick, real-world defensive transitioning, at least for my small frame. The natural ROF, as dictated by recoil and my muscles, is also sluggish. My wife won't use it: too big and heavy. Thus, our diminutive Bersa Thunder 380 still has pride of place in our defenses. Maybe we just need to get stronger...hehe.

I'm going to have that ramp polished, and the trigger tweaked.
It couldn't hurt to get a new extractor, and that rusted slidestop needs to go.
Waitaminnit --can you hear me talking?
For all my complaints, I want to work on the thing.
If you think about it, my complaints are NOT about function, but form.
There IS something to this pistol....

It's quite possible Armscor sends the good stuff overseas, leaving us Filipino consumers with crap.
It's shootable crap, and for all my whining, I did enjoy blasting away with it towards the end of my session. Weary as I was, I was enjoying how good I was getting. 'Potential' is the very, very broad silver lining to this cloud, and really: tweaking/customizing a 1911 can be half the fun of owning one, right?

After a short break-in, it shot, and shot well.
I expect it to shoot better and better, as it smooths out.
I also expect it to look better and better, as I go on replacing a few things.



hth
:)
 
Last edited:
Very good report. Like your detail. Its pretty established here that the Filipino products aren't known for there high quality, particularly the early offerings, but they've been doing pretty well in the functioning department. And they are priced as such.

Still I was too fagged out to shoot anymore.

(suppressed chuckle) Uh, this may have a slightly different meaning here in the US.
 
:uhoh: :eek: :uhoh: :eek: :uhoh:

Originally posted by hksw
Originally posted by horge
Still I was too fagged out to shoot anymore.
(suppressed chuckle) Uh, this may have a slightly different meaning
here in the US.
Zoiks. Sorry about that...
By 'fagged out' I'd meant 'burnt out', like a faggot of firewood.
(as in, the literary 'flaming faggot' wielded by many a cornered hero)
Some folks colloquialize cigarettes and cigars as 'fags', in
another reference to the combustible common ground.
I'll avoid it in the future.
:)


Thanks for the heads-up, Ron.
Glad to provide, mpthole.

Hopefully the quality of finish is soon to improve, to go along with what they've already got right functionality-wise. Armscor is announcing more upgrades and the introduction new non-1911 pistol models this November. I hope to report (with photos) what they showcase at the next Defense & Sporting Arms Show.
 
Saw one of these at the gun show today for $339 was very tempting. One thing different was they had some kind of extended slide lock lever which I really didn't care for.

--wally.
 
Wally, hi.

Actually, mine should have that extended slide stop thingy.
I was surprised to see a GI-type slide stop on the unit when I first looked it over.

That was a good price you mentioned. If one is willing to put in some time, cleaning and a light smoothing of the ramp are all this needed to function well... I believe these can make for very good tools indeed.

:)
 
That was a good review - I bought one but the slide was blued and you may be right about the good stuff being exported. While it doesn't have the finish of the Colts and higher priced clones, mine hasn't so much as hiccuped on me yet and so far, I've got about 1000 rounds through it.

Mostly, it eats ball ammo but I have put flat point 185s and hollow points through her too. Next, it's time to get a 400 Corbon bbl and take it to the next level.
 
An interesting and honest report. So many people try so hard to defend their choice of a cheap gun that they don't mention the flaws.

Nothing wrong with "fagged out."
Some of us here still speak English instead of Hollywood.
 
Great report, thanks for the honesty. I have the Rock Island Armory 5" GI and love it. I wish we could get those awesome grips here in the US. congrats and good luck. I may even buy another RIA and leave it stock. I got the d.i.y. bug and did some changes. PB150007.jpg
 
Horge, thanks for the review. You might want to consider buying a bunch of those grips and selling them on THR for $25 or so per pair, including postage from the Philippines. You'd make money, and we'd get access to nice grips!
 
pretty nice pistol.

i just picked up a great batch today from a guy selling his brothers gun collection ( he doed of cancer. he wasnt a shooter or hunter, he just liked guns and bought them to have).

i got all of these guns NIB unfired for $1000

1 springfield trophy match 1911 stainless with 10 (yes 10) brand new wilson combat mags

1 stainless ruger competition target MKII with ultra dot red dot sight

1 ruger "hunter" convertable single six stainess with leopold pistol scope

1 ruger 22/45 MKIII blued

1 stainess ruger super single six 22/22M 4 5/8 barrel

1 limited production winchester model 94AE large loop saddle ring ranger in 357

1 set of NIB custom antique genuine elephant ivory grips for 1911 ( going to put these on the trophy match springfield)

1 stainless laminated ruger all weather 22 hornet ( the heavy barreled target barel)

1 stainless ruger 10/22 with laminated stock and butler creek varmint barrel with 2.5x10 leopold

1 ruger M77 MKII stainless laminated 223 with nikko sterling stainless scope

1 savage model 12 stainless in 22-250

and last but not least

1 les baer thunder ranch 1911


bought them all in one bunch right out of the local nickel paper.....
 
lol!

yea, when i get a chance, ill take some pix of everything and post them. took the ruger hunter,ruger MKII competition target, the speingfield,the les baer,the 22 hornet and a couple of others to the range today and shot a few hundred rounds. i hate to say this, but the springfield outshot the TR by far. the first 2 magazines thru the springfield shot about 6" groups at 15 yards or so, but afte those two, the groups shrank smaller and smaller until they got down to about 2" from the sandbag. the TR shot 6" to 10" groups ( put 100 rounds thru it) and it never did shrink in any. the 22 ruger competion target model was an absolute BLAST to shoot. at 15 yards it was shooting sweet neat little 1 hole groups with the ultra dot red dot sight. the single six hunter was a sweetie too. shot both the 22 and mag cylinders. only thing i didnt like to much ( which is typical i guess as i lined the scope up with LR's) was that the magnums shot like 4 inches high and to the left, but shot that consistantly in 5 shot 1 hole groups. a slight tweak of the scope adjustments and its on target, but then the 22LR is off....LOL...


yea, im extremely happy with the whole situation. the guy i bought them all from called me this afternoon and told me that he was going thru his brothers stuff and found a marlin 62 lever action rifle in 30 carbine, a colt M16,a thompson m1927 with a drum mag a remington 788 in 223 , a glock 17, a sako L46 222 magnum, a sako mannlicher rifle ( with the long ass stock) a series 80 stainless 1991 and a small 38 special derringer all in a lane ceder chest in his closet, and asked me if i wanted to buy all of it, including chest. im supposed to go tomorrow after work and check it all out.i already have a glock 17 and a custom sako L46 in regular 222, but after the price i paid for the other stuff, ill check it out, even if i just buy the stuff and resell it. ill let you know how it all works out
 
Yeah, it'll be interesting to hear how much he wants for the rest of it.

Remember, I've got $100 here burning a hole in my pocket I'll give you for the 1911... ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top