• You are using the old Black Responsive theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Are Brownings overpriced?

Status
Not open for further replies.

JesseJames

Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2005
Messages
314
Location
CT, it's expensive here
Well, I had a discussion the other day about rifles with one of the guys at work and I mentioned that I might own a Browning some day.
I almost bought one of their BPS shotguns considering that they are loaded and eject shells from the bottom port. I am a lefty. But I bought a used Winchester 1300 because it was such a good deal.
He commented that Brownings are overpriced for what you get. This is a common statement I've been hearing about Brownings for quite some time.
What are your opinions?
 
The BPS is my favorite Pump. I like the solid steel receiver, and the bottom eject. They are well made pumps.

Dobe
 
I'll start by saying I don't own any current production Browning rifles or shotguns, but I have recommended them and have friends that own them. Over priced depends on how you look at it, as a "tool" maybe, but if they were just tools we'd all go buy a Savage and be done with it.

Let's leave aside aethestics for a moment, what you get with a Browning is usually a higher grade of finish than most factory rifles In a similar price range), and a better overall fit and finish. I'm sure people will want to argue that their CZ/Remchester/Ruger/ etc. are equal, sorry, but I've handled and shot many rifles and the Brownings are just better finished on average. Your may occassionally find one of the brands listed with a better piece of wood but it's pretty rare.

In modern hunting rifles I currently have a Ruger 77RSI (tang safety), Dumoulin FN actioned rifle, Weatherby Vanguard Deluxe, BAR Gr. III, BAR Gr. IV, HK SLB2000, and 3 customs on Mauser Actions. Of the guns realtively comparable to a current Browning A-bolt, the Ruger is ok because I like full length stocks, but the fit and finish really don't compare to the Brownings and the wood is not nearly as good. The Dumoulin has an extremely fine blued finish and is put together very well, but the wood is very plain. The HK is again very well fit and finished but with very plain wood. The Weatherby has the normal hgih gloss look but needed some fitting around the barrelled action to get it to shoot well.

So that's one mans opinion, others will probably vary. Some people don't like high gloss finishes on stocks, some people are just in love with whatever brand they happen to own, and some don't like any gun made in Japan.
 
Last edited:
I own brownings,winchesters,CZ,Ruger,Tikka,Sako,remingtons,and so on.I have a few browning A-bolts they are accurate and great fit and finish.IMHO my Tikka and Sako rifles outshine the brownings as far as smooth operation of the bolt.coobie:)
 
Have about 15 Brownings....everything from Hipowers, A-5's, .22's, including a couple of Superposes. Brownings overpriced?.....no, you get what you pay for and more. Fit and finish is far superior to what I've seen on comparable priced guns.

I would say a Winchester 1300 going for more than $150 is overpriced. Fit and finish is sad.
 
The only Brownings I own are Hi Powers, but I have shot several of their guns, such as their lever-actions and a few Citori O/Us. I have handled many more of their guns -- including everything they had at the SHOT show -- and I have nothing but good to say about them.

IMO, you get what you pay for when it comes to guns, and you almost never get what you don't pay for. I have yet to be let down by an FN/Browning product.

Wes
 
I have a Browning BLR 7mag, that I have been very pleased with, and it has surpassed my expectations in the field. I bought it used like new online for $550 and that included a Leupold 4x scope and rings. Looking at other guns comparatively, it boils down to, deals happen if you pay attention. Even new Abolts have been on sale for incredible prices. I owned a BPS and it was extremely well made, but a little too heavy for me. I got my money out of it, when I sold it. I also had a BAR Safari grade 7mag that was absolutely beautiful, reliable and holy cow accurate, but also too heavy for me in the field. I traded it and got its value back. Resale/trade value has been excellent. If people only buy whats available at Walmart, they miss out on some great quality rifles/shotguns elsewhere. I could say no gun should be purchased at Manufacturer's suggested retail, because it usually can be gotten cheaper for the looking. So it depends on what the frame of reference is when looking at prices comparatively. Brownings are IMO very well made.
 
"i own 15 brownings"

"I would say a Winchester 1300 going for more than $150 is overpriced. Fit and finish is sad."

gunsnob:neener:
 
oh, and if you want my opinion. brownings are seriously overpriced.

they are just polished remingtons
 
Colt 45,I do not agree.The browning rifles and shotguns are heads and tails above the remington products,believe me I own and shoot both.coobie:neener:
 
"they are just polished remingtons"

_________________________________________

What an extensive knowledge of firearm engineering.
 
Absolute hogwash.

they are just polished remingtons

I've owned one of just about everything over the last 25 years. I still have several Remington 700 rifles, because they're just so darned utilitarian. However, I've purchased several Remington autoloading rifles, and the only ones I've kept are the Model 8 and 81 versions, the rest I got rid of like a bad habit. They were clunky jammo-matics.

In comparison, I find my Browning Auto 5 and BAR firearms finely-made instruments with excellent fit and finish. Do they cost more than their Remington counterparts? Heck, yes. But the difference is like night and day, an absolute delight to handle, and just plain smooth. This is a 1969 Belgian BAR in .30-06, and it's like a Swiss watch in function and accuracy:

barbenchweaverright2.gif
 
I've got a Feather XS O/U, a BT-99 Max, and a Gold autochucker with the DuraTouch camo...

As far as shotguns, they have the features I want at a price that I believe is affordable. I have no problem buying a shotgun for $2,000 when it looks and performs like $2,000.

I really like their rifles, but they don't offer the chamberings I want in a left-handed bolt action.

Browning has yet to disappoint me...

Ed
 
Take this from an HK guy :D
It's all about the price of membership & seeing the value in what you're purchasing. If you don't see it, then yeah, it's over priced ;)
 
I have a BPS Upland 12 ga with the straight stock & 20" bbl and it works/looks great. I used it for pheasant this past season and was very happy. I have 1 other Browning (Buckmark) and I've noticed the triggers are very smooth from the factory-especially the Buckmark .22.
Fwiw-I also have a Winchester 1300 12 ga that I paid $150 for, and it is every bit worth another $50 imo! Shoots pretty good too.
Best-MC
 
IMHO, Brownings are not overpriced. The price difference between a Browning and one of its lesser competitors will make the difference between a firearm that s just good enough and a firearm that is superb.
 
If they were truly overpriced, they would soon be out of business. Kind of like cars, a bottom of the line Ford or Chevy will get you there but the ride in a luxury car is far more enjoyable.
 
browning makes hunting rifles for the hunter. it works and it looks good to boot. but good looks is the last thing on my list. a remington 870 will do anything a browning will do, except eject from the botom. and it will cost $800 less.

have you ever seen someone break a record with a browning t bolt? they're good guns make no mistake. id rather have a remington or cz or something for most things. hell, for most things id rather use my garand.:D
 
I've heard both good and bad about Browning rifles. I have a BAR in .280 Remington that is very nice. I didn't buy it, mind you, but it's nice enough that I wouldn't consider trading or selling it. It is very accurate for a auto.

Some of the newer A-Bolts are poorly assembled. For similar money, I'd go with a Remington.
 
:rolleyes: Mister COLT .45 you can get an 870 Rem for $800 less than a Browning? Well I guess you can get a check for $291 and a free 870 then, since the msrp for a BPR with back bored chamber and interchangeable chokes is $509. Who pays msrp anyway? Come on.

Read up about the facts on Browning firearms. And yes Remingtons are fine too. I own some Remingtons too, and enjoy them even with the new plastic trigger mech in my 870.
While your at it, check out the msrp on all Browning firearms. They have some pricey ones, but so does Remington, and Browning has some A-bolts that compete directly in same price range with the similar Remington model 700s'.

http://www.browning.com/products/catalog/firearms/detail.asp?value=011B&cat_id=012&type_id=216

http://www.browning.com/products/catalog/firearms/detail.asp?value=001B&cat_id=035&type_id=020
 
Made in Japan. Is that good, or does that mean you expect the gun to cost less? Howas and Weatherby Vanguards cost less, and they're nice rifles. I don't know.

Auto 5: Irrelavant. Hasn't been made for years. Neat-o design, appeals to people who want their guns to be busier than they are, and if you've shot one you know what I mean.:D

BAR: Gold standard. No one will dispute that. Price is low, when you start looking around at the few guns with which it competes.

BT-99: No competition. Sells well. I have one. Simpler design than a NEF Topper, but beautifully finished. Should be possible to compete; Ithaca, are you listening?

BLR: No competition. You want a lever gun that shoots high-powered or magnum rounds, you have to get a BLR. Gloss finish is pretty in the shop, assinine in the field. Otherwise, a NICE gun. The best of old-West handling combined with modern rounds and accuracy. I should have bought one instead of my bolt-action hunting rifle.

A-bolt: Hardly ever see them. They shoot, they feed, they shoot. Howa/Weatherby, Remington, CZ, Savage, et al. make guns that serve just as well, sometimes for far less money. You decide, but if someone says Brownings are overpriced, they're probably talking about their bolt actions.

BPS: Overweight, but the cheapest gun in its class (all-steel, polished blue). Compared to its only competition, a Wingmaster or Ithaca 37, it's not at all expensive, just heavier than the competition (a black mark IMO, but others differ). Hardly ever see them, either.

Gold: Expensive. A good gun, according to its fans. No more expensive than Beretta or Benelli, definitely more than a Remington 11-87. Also a tad heavy. Not a bargain, but not out of line, either.

.22s: No real competition, except for Buckmark pistol, which holds its own. Their guns are unique. They aren't cheap. You like them, or you don't, but it would be hard to say if they're overpriced, or not. The BL-22 has one real competitor, and neither gun is cheap.
 
IMO the A-bolts are not worth the extra $$$. There are a lot of better bolt actions out there that are more accurate and more cost effective.

As for most of their products...If you like fancy...yeah, they look fancy.

But are they over priced? TO EACH THEIR OWN.

I like simple, reliable, accurate. If I get a good value it's a bonus.
That's why my main guns are a M1 Super 90, 870, 10/22, and soon a Tikka T3
All three meet my needs, and justified the purchase. Then again I'm a hunter, and not a shooter/collector.

I repeat, to each their own. The world would really suck if we all like the same (fill in the blank).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top