Bigdtc
Member
CZ-52....Get Some!
The ones that don't get caught and stay alive have plenty, and they are the ones you really have to worry about. Don't ever let yourself underestimate your adversary.Body armor requires a bit of forethought and not too many criminals have that.
.223's shooting light or middleweight JHP's penetrate less than most handgun JHP's, and have less wounding potential after penetrating even a single wall.I don't fault your reasoning, but the potential use of a rifle also has downsides. The projectiles can usually penetrate most residential wall constructions, with rounds inadvertently zipping through the neighborhood. Unfortunate victims of ND's have been sitting on the opposite side of their home, the bullet passing through multiple walls.
That article has quite a few gelatin tests, and some of the lighter .223 JHP's are dismissed by the author as being not penetrative enough for police duty use (though I think the 55-grain JHP's are ideal for HD)."INTRODUCTION
"Until recently, the 12 gauge shotgun has remained the universally accepted shoulder fired weapon for United States law enforcement use, despite the shotgun's limitations as a general purpose weapon--short effective range, imprecise accuracy, downrange hazard to bystanders, small ammunition capacity, slow reloading, and harsh recoil. While 12 gauge shotguns still have a valid law enforcement role, especially to deliver specialized munitions and possibly in close quarters combat (CQB), recent recognition of the shotgun's significant limitations as a general purpose weapon have prompted many American law enforcement agencies to begin adopting the more versatile semi-automatic carbine for general purpose use.(12) Semi-automatic carbines offer more accuracy, less recoil, greater effective range, faster reloading, and a larger ammunition capacity than the traditional shotgun.
...
"Less well known is that 5.56mm/.223 rifle ammunition is also ideally suited for law enforcement general purpose use in semi-automatic carbines.(5,6). It offers superb accuracy coupled with low recoil, and is far more effective at incapacitating violent aggressors than the pistol cartridges utilized in submachineguns and some semi-automatic carbines.
...
"CONCLUSION
"A 5.56mm/.223 semi-automatic carbine with a minimum of a 14.5" to 16.5" barrel may be the most effective and versatile weapon for use in law enforcement. When used with effective ammunition, the 5.56mm/.223 carbine simultaneously offers both greater effective range and less potential downrange hazard to bystanders than a 12 ga. shotgun, handgun, pistol caliber carbine, or SMG , as well as far greater potential to incapacitate a violent criminal than any handgun, pistol caliber carbine, or SMG.
...
The routine issuing of 5.56mm/.223 semi-automatic carbines for general purpose use to all law enforcement officers would significantly enhance officer safety, increase police effectiveness, and decrease dangers to innocent bystanders in all situations requiring the use of firearms."
The most popular defensive carbine in U.S. homes is undoubtedly the AR-15 platform, which is of course an autoloader. To me, using an autoloader is pretty much a given, though a lever-action in .357 would probably be a pretty decent choice as well.The overall size of rifles give them problems negotiating hallways and bedroom corridors; unless a self loading action, manipulating a bolt or lever to reload can be restricted by the same, and introduce another action that can result in an ineffective weapon.
That's still a good choice, but I don't think that the consensus holds anymore that it is the hands-down best choice for everyone. It is one good choice out of many.Home defense sources consider a 20 ga auto shotgun with No. 4 to be a more ideal choice in long guns.
Quite so.The odds of an intruder are small for most of us, one wearing body armor much smaller. I wouldn't want to get keyed on a single issue in home defense.
I've seen it. III was the highest level they had there I believe, it was in July.(can't say I see much, if any, real armor at shows).
Newton's second law still applies: they aren't taking any more force than your shoulder is taking
He might, or he might keep coming. The whole idea behind current ammunition standards is to force attackers bodies to shut down after being shot so even if your attacker doesn't have the courtesy to know he's been shot and drop over like on tv, they will eventually be forced to. If people with 12ga slug holes through their central mass keep moving and attacking, the shot that didn't even enter their body won't fare any better. The guy wearing body armor and shot with 00 buck might stop, he might not.I'd like to point out that even if a thug is wearing soft body armor that could technically make a pistol or shotgun round nonlethal, it wouldn't bounce harmlessly off. It can still cause massive bruising, break bones, and cause other damage due to the sheer impact forces involved. If you blast a thug in the chest with 00 buck at 15 feet, he's not going to laugh and keep coming at you. It's still going to hurt him, stun him, and knock the breath out of him, giving you time for followup shots.
You are correct. NIJ Level II will stop currently sold non-LEO 5.7x28mm, AFAIK, and Level IIIA will stop any 5.7x28mm ever sold to non-LEO's, per the BATFE.As for the FN five seven or PS90 is the ammo that is widely available for them capable of pentrating a vest? I thought that the ss197s and other widely available rounds couldn't pentrate vests only the SS190
A handgun is used to fight your way to to the rifle you dropped...
Enough said... put .223 or 7.62x39 into the bad guy with the cheap vest and he will sit down very quickly...
I’ve read a few reports on gunfights, both here and in other places.
I’ve never read, heard or saw anyone “fight his way to his rifle” .
Can anyone provide one or two accounts where a person fought his way to his rifle?
Not really. A level IIA vest will give decent protection from slashes and stuff, as well as a variety of blunt trauma (including steering wheels in an auto accident), but a good thrust from a decent blade will go through a vest where the trauma plate is not protecting the material. A broadhead will zip right through. Some broadheads even can create a little hate and discontent with level III without plates.If it can stop a knife...
Newton's second law still applies: they aren't taking any more force than your shoulder is taking. Sure, a bullet concentrates the force but body armor, or even heavy clothing, cushion the blow.