Beam Scale Choice

Which scale should I buy from these four?

  • RCBS Model 505

    Votes: 29 65.9%
  • Redding #2

    Votes: 7 15.9%
  • Lyman Pro 500

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Hornady Model M

    Votes: 7 15.9%

  • Total voters
    44
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

ArchAngelCD

Member.
Joined
Nov 25, 2006
Messages
27,172
Location
Northeast PA, USA
A local store is having a 25% off sale on all their reloading equipment. They have 4 scales in the store and I need a new scale. Of the four listed in the Poll which would you buy. Please don't tell me to buy something other than what's in the Poll because these are the only four they have. They are all good scales and I probably would be happy with any one of them but since I have a choice, why not get a consensus? The Poll will be open for only 5 days because the sale only lasts until Wednesday.
 
RCBS or Redding. Both very good scales. I like the 505 a bit better as far as how it is adjusted. The Reddings tougher for big fingers like mine, as I don't have the touch, (feeling in fingers) or dexterity, I did when I was younger.
 
I voted for RCBS 5-0-5 because I have owned the same one for over 20 years and it never fails to do the job. Just a bit slower then my RCBS (digital) Powder Pro (Walkalong's favorite:evil:)
 
being a truck mechanic has effected my fingers too
Isn't it aggrevating! I too, have worked with my hands all my life, on the job and off. It takes its toll, besides just aging. I would not change it though. I did what I loved to do. Take stuff apart and fix it. I don't do it as much anymore, but I still get out of the office and teach, as well as do it myself when I get to feeling "confined" :)

I should have sent my PACT to the Bushmaster, instead of bouncing it off the kitchen tile. :uhoh:
 
I did not vote since I have used only one of the scales listed. How can a person who has not used all of them make a valid comarison.
I started with a 505 but got a 10-10 in the early 70's. I have used the 10-10 ever since.
 
They are all excellent scales...equally easy to use. Buy the cheapest!

I would suggest, however, that you get some calibration weights to fine-tune whatever you get.
 
TooTaxed,
I agree they are all excellent scales. They are all cheap because they are all on sale. I would probably be happy with any of the four but since all four are available I figured I would tap the vast knowledge contained here and get the one which has an edge.... No??
 
ArchAngelCD,
my point is that none has an edge over ease of operation, speed, or accuracy over the others! All are used in exactly the same manner.

If there is an actual edge, it would be if one of them came with extra gear...for example, a set of check weights (unlikely but highly desirable for fine-tuning)...or has a wider range of weight capacity (possible...you will probably weigh bullets occasionally as well as powder).
 
Since there are more than twice the votes for the RCBS than all the others combined I'll be buying the RCBS 505. Actually, that's the one I was considering in the first place. I just wanted to make sure that one of the others wasn't superior. The only thing that may stop the purchase of the RCBS 505 is the purchase of a RCBS 750. Cabela's has the 750 on sale for $99.99 so I might buy that instead.

I thank everyone who took the time to vote and give their opinion. I do appreciate the help.
 
Cabela's has the 750 on sale for $99.99 so I might buy that instead.
Digital, right? Like Sherriff Bufford T. Justice said, "You can think about it, but donnn't do it" :evil:

Really, go for it, I just don't like digital scales. Lots of folks love them. Just ask The Bushmaster. He swears by his. :)
 
I had a Lyman 500 & replaced it with an RCBS 505. The RCBS works better for me. I know nothing a bout the others.
 
I doubt that many of the beam scales on the market are actually made by the company whose name appears on them. Most likely marketed by, not made by. Too many similarities between the brand names.
 
I doubt that many of the beam scales on the market are actually made by the company whose name appears on them. Most likely marketed by, not made by. Too many similarities between the brand names.
aka108,
Now that's hard to argue with. It happens with all products across the board and I'm sure it's true with loading scales too.
 
Shoney asked:
How can a person who has not used all of them make a valid comparison.

I've used 3 out of 4 (not the Hornady). All 3 work, I personally find the RCBS more ergonomic. and that is why I chose it. Actually, I currently use an RCBS 750 which I replaced my 505 with, but missed a beam scale so I bought a RCBS 1010.
 
paperpuncher49,
Thank you for the information. How well does the RCBS 750 work? I have a cheap Electronic scale I bought from Midway that is now going crazy. It drifts way too much so I don't even use it any more. I would like to get a 750 but I'm a little "gun shy" about Electronic scales at the moment. (not that I'm comparing a RCBS 750 with a $29 cheapie scale)

As a note: I waited too long and all the RCBS 505 scales are gone. Do you think I should buy a 750 or just buy a bigger beam scale like the 1010? I do own a Lee Safety Scale so if I do buy an Electronic scale I would have a backup.
 
My suggestion for you is to buy the scale with the most ergonomic fine adjustment. Most scales are the same in course adjustment, but the fine adjustment is a different story. Of the scales you listed, I have the Redding. The fine adjustment is a piece of stamped spring steel and is a pain in the neck for older eyes and large hands to locate in the correct notch.

I wish I had originally something more along the lines of the Hornady. It's fine adjustment is easily controllable.

Regards,

Dave
 
ArchAngelCD,

The 750 works great, and will run on a 9 volt battery if you want to sit (let's say) at the dining room table to weigh charges rather than where you normally have it set up and plugged in.

It has remained accurate for the 4+ years I have owned it, and I simply turn it on when I want to use it. I do not calibrate it every time as RCBS says to do in the manual. The display shows "0" when turned on, and if I remove the pan, mine reads -69.4 (these are the same readings I get if I go through the calibration steps). At first I was a bit cautious about using the scale this way, but I have tested it several times with check weights after turning it on and not calibrating and found that it was dead on every time. As a result, I trust it much more than when I first bought it, but as with every scale, I still test it every so often. My beam scale remains in the inventory in case of emergency.

However, any scale (including beam scales) can be affected by electric fields. I keep my beam scale covered with an inverted rubbermaid container, and the static electricity that sometimes build up will cause a dramatic change in the beam as I lower the container over the scale. Remove the container and the pointer returns to the same reading as before it is covered. Fluorescent lights can do the same.
 
I have the Redding. The fine adjustment is a piece of stamped spring steel and is a pain in the neck for older eyes and large hands to locate in the correct notch.
That was my point, but more clearly stated in your post, in my first post about the difference in the RCBS and the Redding. AC
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top