Benelli M1 Tactical or a Remington 1100 Tactical? Which one would you choose?
- Thread starter Browning
- Start date
- Status
retrieverman
Member
I haven't read all the responses, but I have most and hope I am not parroting someone else.
I don't see how you can go wrong either way, but comparing a Benelli to a Remington is really not an apple/apple comparison due to the gas vs inertia systems. My Dad has shot a Remington 1100 for almost 40 years with no problems, but I bought him a Benelli Super 90 several years ago which has replaced the 1100. He just likes the Benelli better. I have had my Super 90 for 13 years and THOUSANDS of rounds without a hiccup.
Since you already have a 1100, that might be a more sensible choice, but if you like the Benelli, you sure won't go wrong.
I am guessing that SM is not going to give any details as to how he broke 8 Novas, but my BS-ometer is sure went off when I read that. I know too many guys that shoot them and have been very happy with them to believe that one man could tear up 8.
I don't see how you can go wrong either way, but comparing a Benelli to a Remington is really not an apple/apple comparison due to the gas vs inertia systems. My Dad has shot a Remington 1100 for almost 40 years with no problems, but I bought him a Benelli Super 90 several years ago which has replaced the 1100. He just likes the Benelli better. I have had my Super 90 for 13 years and THOUSANDS of rounds without a hiccup.
Since you already have a 1100, that might be a more sensible choice, but if you like the Benelli, you sure won't go wrong.
I am guessing that SM is not going to give any details as to how he broke 8 Novas, but my BS-ometer is sure went off when I read that. I know too many guys that shoot them and have been very happy with them to believe that one man could tear up 8.
Last edited:
Chuck R.
Member
Man what is THR coming to?
I can't believe folks would question the integrity of a member with 18,000 + posts!
But then again..............
Chuck
I can't believe folks would question the integrity of a member with 18,000 + posts!
But then again..............
Chuck
It's entirely possible. Testing guns for a law enforcement agency or other similar activity puts guns through high volume shooting and rough use testing. I believe sm based on his knowledge and previous posts here. He is not one inclined to BS type posts.
My own experience with the Nova shows it not a very robust gun compared to others. I believe it's entirely possible under rigourous testing to have that many not stand up.
In any event the guns being compared here are the M1 and the 1100. To bring the Nova into the debate is like comparing the 870 and the 1100 and they are completely different guns.
KINGMAX
Member
Remington 1100
REMINGTON 1100 - The REMINGTON 1100 & 870 are two proven shotguns year after year. Benelli is a great shotgun, but I have stuck w/ what I know. I have been shooting an old express 870 for several years. Has not let me down.
REMINGTON 1100 - The REMINGTON 1100 & 870 are two proven shotguns year after year. Benelli is a great shotgun, but I have stuck w/ what I know. I have been shooting an old express 870 for several years. Has not let me down.
Can't say for 1100,but am a former M1 owner. The Benelli is an absolute animal, ate everything I fed it and is super simple/easy to takedown and clean. With their used prices declining, one day I will own another. Good luck. Nickels
Condition Plaid
Member
It's from DMW. Dave's Metal Works.
marley
Member
boomstik45
Member
I've handled both and like both. For the money, I'd rather have the Remington. I don't shoot skeet, trap, or any 3-gun competitions. My focus is on defense, be it the 2 or 4 legged critter type. So all this speed and time stuff is different for me. It's definitely different if the target is either trying to shoot/stab/bludgeon you or eat/gore you. For the price of a Benelli, I'd rather get a hi-cap assault rifle anyway.
Nothing against Benellis, mind you. Wonderful weapons. But I don't think you'd go wrong with the 1100 if you wanted home defense and weren't worried about competitions. Again, if you have the money, get what you want the most.
Nothing against Benellis, mind you. Wonderful weapons. But I don't think you'd go wrong with the 1100 if you wanted home defense and weren't worried about competitions. Again, if you have the money, get what you want the most.
baker1425
Member
M1 Super 90 Question
I've got Remington 1100s and the M1Super90. I like them all, I've shot a lot of rounds through the 1187 Police Magnum at work.
High round counts of contract buckshot and slugs tell the tale on reliability. I've never had a problem with 1100/1187/M1Super90s. A lot of regional agencies are going to the Nova and I've heard nothing but praise for them.
I like shooting the Benelli the best, but the Remingtons are easier on the shoulder.
I've got the extension and clamp for my Pistol Grip M1, I've not installed it yet. Are any of you aware of any restrictions on installing it that would be left over from AWB or 922?
thanks!
I've got Remington 1100s and the M1Super90. I like them all, I've shot a lot of rounds through the 1187 Police Magnum at work.
High round counts of contract buckshot and slugs tell the tale on reliability. I've never had a problem with 1100/1187/M1Super90s. A lot of regional agencies are going to the Nova and I've heard nothing but praise for them.
I like shooting the Benelli the best, but the Remingtons are easier on the shoulder.
I've got the extension and clamp for my Pistol Grip M1, I've not installed it yet. Are any of you aware of any restrictions on installing it that would be left over from AWB or 922?
thanks!
I've owned/shot both the Benelli M1 Tactical and a Remington 1100 Police shotgun. Both were only average shooters. The Benelli had better ergonomics with a pistol gripped stock and ghost ring sights. But a part of the rear sight fell off after about 400 rounds. The company sent me every part but the correct one for 3 months. By the time I recieved the correct part I had enough spare parts to build a new rear sight, all sent for free. The 1100 had no mechanical failures, but did'nt feel as comfortable as the Benelli.
Both had problems with various loads like any semiauto shotgun. If you want reliability go with a semiauto/pump combo like Benelli or Spas 12.
Both had problems with various loads like any semiauto shotgun. If you want reliability go with a semiauto/pump combo like Benelli or Spas 12.
Sir Aardvark
Member
FYI- the Remington 1100 uses rubber O-rings that could possibly fail if not properly maintained.
Benelli. Fast, reliable and simple. All the gunk goes out the barrel, not through a gas system (M4 being the exception). And you can cut the barrel whereever you want without effecting reliablity. 
(just make sure you get your stamp if you go under 18 inches)
(just make sure you get your stamp if you go under 18 inches)
Late to this thread, but...
If you have any intentions of shooting a 3-gun match go with the Benelli. M1 or M2. Almost the same gun.
They are much lighter than the gas operated guns and index from target very quickly. You will get more felt recoil due to the lighter weight, but after the buzzer you wont notice a thing.
Benellis also load easier, as long as you dont run them dry. 3-gun shotgunning is all about having a plan and keeping the gun loaded.
I call BS. Dont care how many posts sm has.
If you have any intentions of shooting a 3-gun match go with the Benelli. M1 or M2. Almost the same gun.
They are much lighter than the gas operated guns and index from target very quickly. You will get more felt recoil due to the lighter weight, but after the buzzer you wont notice a thing.
Benellis also load easier, as long as you dont run them dry. 3-gun shotgunning is all about having a plan and keeping the gun loaded.
sm said:
I call BS. Dont care how many posts sm has.
dcowboyscr
Member
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2007
- Messages
- 10
I owned a Benelli M1 Super 90 a few years back that was great. Never had a malfunction. Top notch quality. I'm looking into buying a Benelli Super Nova Tactical with Ghost Ring Sights(for budget reasons) now.
I'd like details into the 8 broken Novas that were mentioned in this thread earlier. Pics of even one of the damaged guns would be even better. Thanks.
I'd like details into the 8 broken Novas that were mentioned in this thread earlier. Pics of even one of the damaged guns would be even better. Thanks.
sm said:
Details please.
I have been rough on mine and would like to know what to keep an eye out for.
Zak Smith
Member
The Benelli M1/M2 S90 is the dominant shotgun in 3-Gun competition.
You are mistaken.
That has nothing to do with the Benelli autoloaders, though, just the Nova, which is a completely different animal. Same goes for the 1100 vs. the 870: many who will point out the shortcomings of the 1100 will highly recommend the 870 when you ask about a good pump.
And all of that said, I don't shoot 3-gun. But my old 1100 Magnum has never failed me when shooting doves out in the desert sun when it's 117 degrees in the shade, nor shooting 5-stand fast and furious and getting the barrel nice and hot. That tends to make me question just how problematic the 1100 really is. As in, if you have an 1100 that works for you, use it.
If you're looking to buy a new gun, though, look at what the top guys are using. They don't always make the BEST choices, their guns may be doctored to fix serious problems with a production version, sometimes they're paid to use what they use, and the gun may not feel right to you. But chances are, you won't go totally wrong buying what the winners are shooting.
In this case, that's the Benelli.
ArmedBear said:
SMs silence here speaks volumes about his busting of *eight* Benelli Novas. I like the Nova over an 870 as a pumpgun.
Hoser, you have no idea who he is.
You are mistaken.
You may like the things, but that has no bearing on whether he broke a bunch of them (stress-testing them, not just shooting a few rounds). There would be no reason he'd defend himself here, nor does that "speak volumes" about anyone but you.
If you're curious, why don't you send him a PM. I'm sure he'll give you more details if you are interested.
You are mistaken.
You may like the things, but that has no bearing on whether he broke a bunch of them (stress-testing them, not just shooting a few rounds). There would be no reason he'd defend himself here, nor does that "speak volumes" about anyone but you.
If you're curious, why don't you send him a PM. I'm sure he'll give you more details if you are interested.
Zak Smith
Member
No need for a pissing contest. Post count does not indicate much other than a lot of free time to post on internet forums, no offense meant. However-- there are a bunch of experienced practical shooters posting in this thread. If sm has claims that run counter to others' data, then it behooves him to provide details about the failures.
Chuck R.
Member
I disagree.
The last time we went through this, there was a sudden silence from SM on another thread, then the entire thread was deleted.
In that thread SM implied that there we’re K-Booms involved and gun recalls. At that point I contacted Benelli CS via Email and inquired about recalls. According to Benelli, there has never been a NOVA recall.
Hmmmmmmmmmmm
IMHO, if anyone is going to make a post that he broke 8 of anything, then he should at least report the facts. You may disagree, but probably for the majority of others an unsubstantiated claim of breaking 8 guns falls into the realm of BS.
Chuck
Not a pissing contest.
A suggestion to PM him, not just dismiss what he says because one likes a particular gun (which is not "data" either BTW).
I couldn't care less which pump someone likes, BTW. The mainstream pump guns these days are all serviceable. The differences really start to matter if someone wants to start customizing and accessorizing, and personal preference really rules the day.
A suggestion to PM him, not just dismiss what he says because one likes a particular gun (which is not "data" either BTW).
I couldn't care less which pump someone likes, BTW. The mainstream pump guns these days are all serviceable. The differences really start to matter if someone wants to start customizing and accessorizing, and personal preference really rules the day.
Why should it be a PM? It was stated here in public. I'm sure lots of folks would like to know details.
If I said, "I've had 8 Glocks that had slides separate", it would be reasonable that people would want to know details. If I posted it in public, it would be reasonable to elaborate in public. If not, I could claim anything.
If I said, "I've had 8 Glocks that had slides separate", it would be reasonable that people would want to know details. If I posted it in public, it would be reasonable to elaborate in public. If not, I could claim anything.
- Status
Similar threads
