(Boise) Cop's second shooting in 1 yr

Status
Not open for further replies.

Idaho

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
85
Location
Between the desert and the mountains
Unlucky cop to be involved in two shootings in one year in Boise, Idaho - it's not like we have a lot of these around here. The previous one was clearly justified, and this one sounds like it, too - but even so, makes for a tough year for this guy.

Story from the Idaho Statesman:

A Boise police officer shot and killed a 34-year-old Boise man Friday night in the parking lot of the WinCo store at Fairview Avenue and Milwaukee Street.
The man pointed a gun at Officer Jeff Dustin and refused repeated commands to drop his weapon before Dustin fired, police said. Police had not released the man´s name by late Friday night.

The incident began about 6:50 p.m. when a resident in a Bench subdivision reported a suspicious person in his yard and ended about 10 minutes later when Dustin fired three to five shots, police said. At least one shot hit the man in the chest.

Two hours later, the man died at Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center.

Investigators aren´t sure whether the man fired his handgun at Dustin, Capt. Mike Webb, deputy chief of operations, said.

Dustin, who has worked on the Bench patrol for four years, was immediately placed on a standard three-day administrative leave, Boise police spokeswoman Lynn Hightower said.

Here´s the sequence of events as reported by police:

A resident in the 12000 block of Gawaine Street, about a mile and a half east of WinCo, reported a suspicious person near a recreational vehicle in the home´s back yard at 6:51 p.m.

Dispatchers issued an “attempt to locate†call on the suspect.

Ten minutes later, Dustin spotted a man matching the suspect´s description walking east on Fairview. He pulled into the WinCo parking lot to question him.

Dustin was wearing a police uniform and driving a marked patrol car. He ordered the man to stop. The man made derogatory comments and turned to walk away.

Dustin again told the man to stop. The man turned toward the officer, said he had a handgun and pointed the gun at him.

Dustin fired his gun, hitting the man at least once.

Andrew Parrish, who lives off of Fairview Avenue, thought he was hearing fireworks when the shooting took place.

“I heard a pop and a couple of other pops,†Parrish said. “It was a lot of sirens, even for this intersection. Within a minute this whole place was blocked.â€

Police shut down westbound traffic on Fairview at the Milwaukee intersection for several hours late Friday night.

An employee at Blockbuster Video, directly across the street, said a customer ran into the store screaming that someone had been shot.

Police interviewed witnesses who were in the parking lot during the shooting. Several witnesses said they saw the man waving a gun at Dustin as the two stood about 10 to 15 feet apart, Hightower said.

All patrol officers carry a recording device that tapes all conversations, and Dustin´s audio tape confirms that the officer repeatedly told the man to put the gun down, Hightower said.

“If you or I felt threatened with our life, I imagine we would take action,†Webb said.

Investigators are trying to determine why the man brandished a gun at Dustin.

A panel of officers from law enforcement agencies throughout the valley is investigating the fatal shooting. The Ada County Sheriff´s Office is taking the lead. Boise Community Ombudsman Pierce Murphy was at the scene Friday and will conduct his own investigation.

This is the second time in a year that Dustin has been involved in an officer-involved shooting. On April 9, 2003, officers exchanged gunfire with Milton and Melody Sanchez during a chase, but an Ada County jury ruled in December that the shots that killed the Sanchezes at the Boise Airport were self-inflicted.


To offer story ideas or comments, contact Chereen Langrill


http://www.idahostatesman.com/News/story.asp?ID=59878
 
Glad it turned out the way it did. The BG losing, that is.

Unlucky, indeed, given the way the system grinds on you in such instances.
 
Maybe he's unlucky or maybe he's just a dedicated cop and agressively does his job...

but an Ada County jury ruled in December that the shots that killed the Sanchezes at the Boise Airport were self-inflicted.
A really dumb question, but why would a jury be needed to decide if the BGs shot themselves?
 
I don't recollect the precise details re the Sanchez's, but suffice to say there was a significant car chase which ended up on the tarmac of the Boise airport (they drove through a fence) in a hail of bullets from both sides. The Sanchez's had multiple GSW's, and I believe there was some question as to whether the fatal shots were self-inflicted or came from cops. Perhaps the coroner's report was not definitive, or their were conflicting opinions.
 
When Matt Dillon shot someone, he wasn't investigated by the Grand Jury, wasn't persecuted by IA, wasn't subject to Civil Suit and wasn't crucified by the media.

Some guys just have it in their kharma. There is one fellow here who has pulled the trigger four times and has four to his credit. He doesn't look forward to taking human life it but has no remorse either since he considers his own life and those of the public more important than that of a criminal.
 
Update at:

http://www.idahostatesman.com/News/story.asp?ID=59962

Boise police Saturday released the name of the man who was shot and killed by an officer Friday in the parking lot of a Fairview Avenue grocery store.
Little information was available about Robert Keith Underwood, 34, except that he was a former prison inmate who lived off and on at the Boise Rescue Mission. A Rescue Mission resident who knew Underwood in prison and at the mission described him as a quiet, reserved person who kept to himself.

But Mike Webb, Boise police deputy chief of operations, provided more details Saturday about the shooting and the events that led up to it:

• Fourteen witnesses to the shooting said that Underwood brandished his handgun at Officer Jeff Dustin and ignored repeated commands to drop his weapon before the officer shot him.

• Dustin fired three shots; one hit Underwood in the chest. Underwood died from that wound at 9:04 p.m. Friday, about two hours after Dustin shot him in the parking lot of WinCo at Fairview and Milwaukee.

• Underwood apparently did not fire his semiautomatic handgun Friday night, but forensic test results are expected Monday to verify that finding. Police have not said whether Underwood´s gun was loaded but will release that information early this week.

• Witness statements have led investigators to believe Underwood was under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time of the confrontation. Toxicology test results are expected in about two weeks.

• Four of the five people who saw a suspicious person in the 1200 block of Gawaine Place Friday night picked Underwood out of a photo lineup, identifying him as the person they reported in their neighborhood.

• Investigators are not sure how Underwood reached the WinCo parking lot from the Gawaine Place and Jewell Lane area. He would have had to travel about 1 1/2 miles in 10 minutes to reach WinCo from that neighborhood.

Dustin was driving on Fairview Avenue about 7 p.m. Friday when he spotted Underwood walking through the WinCo parking lot. Underwood matched the description of a suspicious person reported on Gawaine Place about 10 minutes earlier, so Dustin stopped to question him, police said.

At the time of Friday´s confrontation, Underwood was wanted on a felony warrant charging him with failure to appear, which stemmed from drug-related charges in Boise, Webb said. The charges included possession of drug paraphernalia, manufacturing drugs and possession of a controlled substance.

Underwood was released from the state prison in Boise in March 2003 after he served time for firearms charges from Camas County.

Since his release, Underwood had lived at the Boise Rescue Mission and at the Brittney apartment complex off Hill Road in Boise, Webb said.

Underwood lived at the mission for about two weeks in late spring of 2003, according to executive director Bill Roscoe. Records show Underwood joined the mission´s job placement program and checked out of the mission on May 19 after he found a job. Roscoe wouldn´t say what kind of job Underwood got or where he was working. Underwood returned to the mission to stay for one night on Oct. 5, Roscoe said.

Residents at the Brittney complex who were shown Underwood´s photo Saturday said they didn´t recognize him.

The interagency Critical Incident Task Force is investigating the shooting, with the Ada County Sheriff´s Office as the lead agency.

The Boise community ombudsman also is investigating. Dustin was put on leave for three days — standard procedure in an officer-involved shooting.

Webb said Dustin has an excellent record as a Boise police officer. He has worked for the department for four years.

“We believe he did the right thing at the right time,†Webb said.



To offer story ideas or comments, contact Chereen Langrill
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top