I agree with Kudu that both are great shotguns. I prefer the Wingmaster because of its history. Our military and police use them, competitive shooters use them and millions of hunters use them.
"Rudy", to all his friends, held almost every Trap & Skeet shooting title and was a member of 14 All American Teams. He was the winner of the "North American Clay Target Championship" at the Grand American in every category; Sub-Junior, Junior, Amateur, Professional, Veteran and Sr. Veteran, a winner of the North American Doubles Championship 5 times, on 14 All American Trap and Skeet teams, and at 14 years of age won the Kansas State Trap Shoot. At the 1950 Grand, shooting one of the first Remington Model 870 pump guns produced (the same gun he would shoot throughout the remainder of his career) he broke 100 straight in doubles; one of the first ever recorded. He repeated this feat again 32 years later at the Louisiana State Shoot in 1982 by breaking 100 straight with the same pump gun. These titles go on and on, and include winner of the World Live Pigeon Championship HOA in 1966 in Mexico City, winner of the Live Bird Championship in Monte Carlo in 1955, in Madrid 1955, in Paris 1955 and Columbaire Championships in Seville, Spain 1965, Madrid 1966, Egypt 1955 and was high score 3 years in a row at the Grand National Quail Championship in Enid, Oklahoma. Unquestionably, Rudy’s accomplishments with a shotgun place him with the top echelon of the shotgunner’s world.
Only the Model 12 can match that record of accomplishments.