So my comparison is re: Buckmarks but I think it will translate to Rugers.I have a 10 in bull barrel gun and a 5 in flatside bull gun. In my hands at 50 feet I can't really say the 10 in is more accurate(maybe at 50 YDS?).But when switching back and forth, the 10 in is MUCH quieter, and has much less muzzle rise.W/ a .22 recoil obviously isn't an issue but I can see how in some types of shooting the drastic reduction in muzzle rise from the extra weight could be helpful.My$.02