Can Domestic Violence Misdemeanant Possess In State Gun?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I posted this in another current thread started by the same person, but since this is getting more responses:


Many people associate domestic violence with "wife beaters". But the truth is, especially before Lautenberg passed this legislation, that a lot of people in messy divorces or with spousal problems had plead guilty to petty charges just to be done with a situation and move on.
Even many who had not done what was accused, when offered some deal like a couple days community service accepted.
It didn't remove your rights before it retroactively did in 1996, and some considered it a small price to pay prior. Even today many non-gun owners are not aware they can lose their rights over it, so many not fight it with thousands of dollars and refuse to take any deals, and then find out later they have no gun rights.

The other thing is what can count as domestic violence is very petty, in no way needing to approach "wife beating". Just getting in each others' face in what is considered an intimidating manner can be an "assault". No contact is necessary for an assault.
Even a battery can be very petty: Wife or girlfriend has a tantrum and starts breaking things and you grab her wrists and she yanks away or tries to go back to breaking things or even hitting you?
Well to hold on would take a relatively tight grip, the kind of grip that can easily bruise a woman (women bruise much easier than men because their higher ratio of body fat makes blood vessels less elastic and susceptible to breakage, just look at most female athletes they are covered in bruises the men who do similar things are not.)
That will readily be a battery charge, resulting in charges if the police show up. Even if it is just because a neighbor calls after hearing the argument, which was over 5 minutes later, and both spouses were working out the issue.

Or a women slapping a man, that is an actual strike, and obviously certainly a battery.
Yet Hollywood taught a whole generation of women that the right thing to do when your honor is insulted by a man is give them an open handed slap across the face.
Lifetime prohibition.
Or the drink in the face, yet another battery, yet it is another thing women who are insulted have been taught to do in some circles.
Lifetime prohibition if charged.


Then of course you have the blatant lies. Men and women are known to claim all sorts of lies or exaggerations in divorces, or custody battles. Or set up or frame the other to gain some sort of leverage. Some bitter towards the other for years.
Anyone can claim an unrelated mark, or bruise was put there by a spouse. Or even intentionally make a new one (knew a girl that actually hit herself in the face to get her boyfriend in trouble after he cheated on her.)
 
Lee Roder said:
I don't know you, or your wife, but I think it reasonable to expect a world of difference between any relationship you have with your neighbor outside your home and that you have with your wife. Legally, these are very different relationships. You owe your neighbor nothing. There are no issues of reliance or trust. As to your wife? Well ...

So.... based upon a purely EMOTIONAL argument, the penalty for slapping my neighbor's wife should be a misdemeanor, but the penalty for slapping my own wife should rise to the level of a felony, stripping a Constitutionally protected right from me for life. I am just not inclined to agree with that. (BTW, I don't assault either, just an example presented.)
 
No, not purely emotional argument, just recognize that your relationship with your wife is not the same as your relationship to your neighbor's wife. Your relationship to your own wife is much stronger than to your neighbor's wife, isn't it? If not, divorce would probably be more amicable solution for you, and if it is, well, it seems almost hypocracy to believe the penalties of bashing the fairer sex should be the same in both circumstances.
 
Last edited:
Honestly I feel bad for the people who get royally screwed by a vindictive "domestic partner". The only thing in this world that is more archaic than gun laws is domestic violence laws.

When an imperfect being creates a system it will inherently be flawed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top