carry weapon

revolver or 1911

  • revolver

    Votes: 58 27.5%
  • 1911

    Votes: 77 36.5%
  • other

    Votes: 76 36.0%

  • Total voters
    211
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank You Vern
I have been carrying FULL size Revolvers and Semi's for 30 years. My first CCW was a S&W 29 4 inch. Current CCW is a S&W 1006. Yes I have smaller handguns, but not much weight differance between a 1006 and a 686 2.5 inch. If you really look at it a loaded Glock 22 weights about the same as my loaded S&W 1006.
 
My knife never misfires

Yea, if my blade cannot save me, the other guy is well-practiced with his pistol. Only been shot twice, so I feel no need for a firearm MOST of the time. Most people cannot shoot for S__t. I laugh at their wavering aim.
 
My preferred Carry Revolver is a 3" GP100.

It's as easy to hide as my 5" 1911, but I prefer a High Power for a concealed autoloader. I carry both the GP100 and the High Power in a Milt Sparks Summer Special II Inside The Waistband Holster with a Gibson 1 1/2" Gun Belt. I also carry a Double Mag Pouch IWB, by Sparks, for my two reloads.

The 5" 1911 is carried in a Mitch Rosen ARG Holster. If you haven't noticed, I'm a big fan of IWB Carry. I find it easier to hide a bigger gun that way. My BUG is either in my pocket, or on my ankle, depending on if I'm wearing shorts or long pants.

As far as which gun to get, get both. I actually recommend that people start on a Revolver. The reason for this is, Revolvers are easier for "Administrative Handling", loading, unloading, checking to see if safe and what not. Autoloaders are more complex, but faster to reload in a gunfight. Also, if you learn to really "run" a Revolver you can transition over, IME, to any other handgun platform easily. The same cannot be said going from Autoloader to Revolver.

If your wife may have to use this gun one day I would definately recommend the revolver for it's "administrative handling" qualities over the autoloader, unless she is willing to spend a lot of time learning and practicing. Another plus to the revolver is, you can carry it with .357 Magnum loads and then load it with 38's for her if she needs that. Autoloaders generally don't work well with lower than standard power ammo. With a revolver, as long as you have enough pressure to push the bullet out of the barrel, you're good to go.

Just my $0.02.

BikerRN
 
I have never been able to carry a revolver, since I only have a 6" L-Frame and a 4" N-Frame and don't have particularly good holsters for CC for them, and I have actually never fired a 1911. I blame that on not having any friends who have taken the plunge and bought a gun of their own, and that my family is extremely anti-gun. Anti-weapon really.

Anyway my first gun was an HK USP .40 fullsize, and I find that it conceals pretty well. If you are moving to or living in Texas, I would check out something like the Glock 27, I bought one a year ago when I got my carry permit in anticipation of summertime carry. That gun is extremely compact, the barrel is long enough to let JHP loads work like they were designed to, it is short enough that it doesn't irritate me while sitting, the grip takes some gettingn used to because it really does work best without a mag extension, just letting the pinky curl underneath it, but it still holds 9+1 rounds or 10+1 if you get the 26 instead. Also, it is accurate, just as accurate as my other pistols. And it is pretty light as well.

I feel that it is the smallest and tightest package for CC that doesn't give up anything major. Some guns may be more accurate, but it is definitely good to go as far as service/defense accuracy goes, some pistols do hold more rounds, but not in the same size, and even out of other subcompacts it is one of if not the shortest from mag basepad to the top of the slide. I'm not counting pocket .380s and .32s in that comparison, only subcompact versions of service pistols.


I also carry a Glock 23 (the 27 won me over in a big way), a CZ 75D PCR (fantastic pistol, totally reliable and it can take an extremely high-quality .22 conversion kit), and also an FNP-9M which is a great gun.
 
I can't vote without more information.

Personally, I'm short and slim and I wear fitted clothing. A Kel-tec PF-9 is the most all-purpose CCW for me. Consider your body type and what you're comfortable shooting and go from there.
 
My full size M&P .45 ACP is huge but is concealble in winter and with a special rig concealable in the summer. No worries here.

The Colt Commander is my second choice for a carry gun, also full size.
 
As has been said, shoot both ,then choose the one you shoot the best. I have to agree with Mr. Humphrey. I've been carrying full size 1911s and N frame Smith .44s as concealment guns for over thirty years. Never uncomfortable, but always comforting.

Just my thoughts.

Respectfully,

DarkSoldier
 
Bond Arms snake Slayer, with 45 Long Colt hollow points.:D Small, comfortable to shoot and very easy to conceal. I am not looking for a long battle, just to put the bad guy down and get to safety. This is my Symphony carry and my Springfield sub-compact is my every day carry.
 
I tried many different guns for CC and settled on a XD40 Sub compact. Hey, it was a way to buy a bunch of guns with my wifes approval. Yes, I even bought a Bond Snakeslayer .45/.410. The XD40 is an outstanding weapon
 
An FBI friend of mine says "dress for the occasion" and I think that applies to clothes as well!

You get tired of packing large (larger) chunks of steel around, especially if you are just running down the street to the quickie mart, so I have a couple of snubbies (44 specials) and a sub compact 9mm to pick and choose from.

But, if you have to be in tougher areas a 1911 may be the minimum to carry.

What is more important is that you have a gun (any gun) when you need it.

Just my $.0000000002 (adjusted for current government spending).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top