Colt O1991 and warning about Freedom Munitions

Status
Not open for further replies.

Big D

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2005
Messages
280
Location
Southeast Georgia
Hey yall. Just wanted to give yall a heads up about Freedom Munitions, out of Lewiston, Idaho. As a caveat, I must say I only purchased this ammo as I had good experience with their 115gr 9mm FMJ and .38spl rounds in the past.

During the last week of May I purchased a Colt O1991 .45ACP from Buds Gun Shop. In addition to this, I purchased 1,500 rounds (1,250 230gr FMJ along with 250 rnds of Freedom Munitions 230gr HP) of re-manufactured ammo from Freedom to run through my new Colt.

Last week, on 06/04/2015, I had been shooting the new Colt, which had been performing flawlessly with the ammo to that point. I had approximately 350 rounds downrange as of that morning. I loaded a magazine (Brownells brand Metalform) with a mixture of the Freedoms FMJ and HP, and began shooting again. I had fired approximately 4-5 rounds, with no noticeable change in report (semi-rapid fire), when the Colt just blew out of my hands. I saw a bloom of what appeared to be blue smoke, and felt metal fragments pepper the left side of my face. I immediately checked my face, discovered my left and right eye was fine, but found several fragments had embedded into my cheek and under my left eye. I will admit I had forgotten my shooting glasses that morning (which are dark tinted), as it was overcast and raining (I know no excuse). A larger fragment had embedded into the side of my cheek, which was bleeding.

After checking myself, I went back to retrieve my 1911, which I found was out of battery approximately 1/4'', and would not reciprocate (i.e. the action was jammed shut, and no amount of force I could muster would locked it open). I looked down directly in front of where I was shooting (private property and I am the only person who shoots there), and discovered a severely bulged and disformed case with a blown primer. Next to the casing was a severely disformed HP bullet with no rifling contact grooves. I then cleared the magazine from the weapon, and found two rounds remaining inside, which exhibited carbon residue in addition to being disformed and set back in their cases. The magazine follower was stuck approximately a quarter of the way down the tube, and upon closer inspection I discovered the base plate was bent outward, and one of the welds was broken.

Upon returning home, I found that the weapon did not had any bore obstructions, but a spent casing was lodged into the chamber, which was locking the action up. I did notice a hairline crack at the base of the round in the chamber, which I could only view from the muzzle. I had taken photographs of my injuries, the weapon and rounds and sent them to the customer service supervisor of Freedom by e-mail. At this point, I contacted Freedom Munitions, which took forever to get a hold of someone as a result of the time difference (Georgia here).

I finally managed to make contact with an admin in a Freedom store in Houston, Tx, how I do not know. He listened and advised he would forward this to his supervisors. Shortly thereafter, I received a call from a Mr. Jansen Jones, VP of Sales/Marketing. I explained the incident to Mr. Jones, who of course apologized for the mishap. He assured me I would be reimbursed for the ammo and my weapon would be purchased by the company for retail value as he wanted to see exactly what had happened to the weapon. He advised me I would be contacted by a customer service rep later that day (06/04/2015). I was not contacted until 06/05/2015, by e-mail from customer service.

I was advised by customer service I would be reimbursed for the ammo, with free return shipping. Here is where the story deepens. The rep told me I would need to take my weapon to a gunsmith to determine whether or not it was repairable. At that point, I stopped the rep and advised that was in stark contrast to what Mr. Jones had told me just one day earlier. The rep advised she would be e-mailing the shipping labels for the ammo, and I told her I would be in contact with the VP about my weapon. After contacting Mr. Jones again, I advised him of the discrepancy between his statement and the customer service rep in reference to my handgun.

After I explained my disappointment in receiving two differing stories, he advised I could either, 1. Take the gun to a 'smith, at no charge or 2. He would personally see that my weapon was purchased by the company and I would fully reimbursed for said weapon. I chose the latter of those two options, and was advised to forward an e-mail with my receipt of purchase, which I did. On 06/08/2015, I contacted customer service, to verify they had received the receipt for my handgun. The rep advised me she had, and had forwarded the receipt to her supervisor, who would be handling the weapon claim.

I contacted the supervisor on 06/09/2015, left a voicemail and inquired as to the status of my claim and an explanation of the claim process so I could have an idea of how long it would take. I did the same on 06/10/2015, and sent an e-mail. I have yet to receive a response to the e-mail nor phone calls. My intention here is not to smear the company, if I wanted to do that I would have sought out a lawyer from the get go. I only wish them to stand by their product, and adequately compensate me for the damages to my weapon and reimburse my ammo.

So far it seems the ball is rolling in the right direction, but I am disappointed in the lack of communication from customer service. I can understand them wanting to communicate by e-mail (leaves a paper trail), but receiving a phone call is not too much to ask for. So far my only communication by phone with the company has involved me having to call and ask questions (with the exception of the first call from the VP). I will be posting the photographs I sent to Freedom. I am not saying all their ammo is bad, but it only takes one bad round to ruin your day.
 
20150604_093012_zpsdrfmcfhq.jpg

20150604_093105_zpswcekpmwv.jpg

20150604_093124_zpskhzleeth.jpg

20150604_093309_zpsybark4ye.jpg

20150604_093809_zpsxaaqyecf.jpg

20150604_093759_zpsegjiir32.jpg

20150604_093043_zpscliln53b.gif

I also want to note I was removing metal fragments from my face for most of the week. Yesterday I removed a shard of copper from the cut to my cheek.
 
Remanufactured ammo is just a fancy name for reloaded ammo. I am not placing any blame but just stating a fact.I would never shoot ammo reloaded by someone else-regardless of fancy names or packaging.i am glad you weren't seriously injured.
 
So did a cartridge ignite while it was being fed into the chamber? Or did it fail to extract an empty cartridge and the next round ignited when it jammed?
 
You are lucky that you can still see . Sorry to hear about your accident and thinks for the heads-up .
 
I saw your post oout this on a 1911v forum. Glad you were not more seriously injured - a good reminder to always wear eye protection. Different guidance from different CS reps is not uncommon. Let us know how they address your O1991. Had you mentioned you sustained physical injuries, though minor?
 
thank goodness you were shooting a stout well made, forged steel frame and slide pistol!

I wonder what a poly framed gun would look like after that Kaboom!
 
Remanufactured ammo is just a fancy name for reloaded ammo. I am not placing any blame but just stating a fact.I would never shoot ammo reloaded by someone else-regardless of fancy names or packaging.i am glad you weren't seriously injured.
I disagree. Remanufactured ammo by an operation such as this is done in a factory, under factory condtions, with more QC than just some guy loading in his basement. Obviously things can go wrong like what happened here, but this isn't the first time something like this has happened with factory ammo, remanufactured or not.

Regarding Freedom Munitions customer service, I too have had less than stellar experiences.
 
Remanufactured ammo is just a fancy name for reloaded ammo. I am not placing any blame but just stating a fact.I would never shoot ammo reloaded by someone else-regardless of fancy names or packaging.i am glad you weren't seriously injured.

No.
Reloaded ammo is done by people in their homes, as a hobby.
Remanufactured ammunition is just that, and is done by a company that offers a warranty in the case of exactly this kind of incidents.
If these were reloads, he'd be out of luck except for a civil case.

I have never had any issues with freedommunitions, but I know that about every ammo manufacturer has experienced this problem, its all in how they deal with it, and how often it occurs. Hope everything works out for the OP.
 
Buying your gun from you and refunding the cost of the ammo is getting off the hook very cheep for them.... and is why they are very happy to do it.

None the less, this is a decent outcome to a messed up situation.
 
Hopefully they will offer a full reimbursement of the original purchase price of the pistol, or current purchase price of a replacement, whichever is higher.

Has the OP heard back from the company yet with their final decision or offer ?
 
"with more QC than some guy reloading in his basement..." Obviously not. :scrutiny: I will happily put my QC work up against any factory any day. I'm not selling the stuff - I am going to shoot it in my guns - in my hands. I won't carry any factory ammo for defensive use and this is why. I have been carrying my reloads for over 35 years. I haven't had one single round blow up a gun or fail to fire. Show me one factory that can say that.
 
Last edited:
"with more QC than some guy reloading in his basement..." Obviously not. :scrutiny: I will happily put my QC work up against any factory any day. I'm not selling the stuff - I am going to shoot it in my guns - in my hands. I won't even carry any factory ammo for defensive use and this is why. I have been carrying my reloads for over 35 years. I haven't had one single round blow up a gun or fail to fire. Show me one factory that can say that.

Even with the best QC in the world, things still happen when dealing with such large quantities, it's a simple matter of numbers and odds. And not to go to far off topic, but a lot of people ALSO disagree with the idea of carrying hand loads for defensive use, for more than one reason. I don't know about 35 years ago, but the quality of the defensive ammunition on the market today is very very good. Not to mention the legal ramifications it could have should you ever need to fire it for self defense purposes.
 
Care to name a better reason than "I KNOW it will work when someone tries to kill me or a loved one?"
 
This might be better asked in the gunsmith forum but what makes the O.P. think the ammunition caused the incident?

Could this be the result of a stuck firing pin or debris causing the round to fire prematurely?

Anyway Freedom is being generous to offer to repair/replace your gun without even looking at it. Most likely they do need the gun first though before they will issue you a check for the cost of your gun. Maybe they are waiting on you to send it to them.
 
Last edited:
I have buds who were Armorers on military ranges. Even mil spec ammunition blows up guns. A USMC Armorer told me of the M14's he saw blown by recruits. The Bolo is missing the target, getting yelled at by the DI, and he has no idea that the round in the M14 did not have any powder. The primer had enough energy to lodge a bullet and the next round blows the rifle all to pieces.

Guys who manage ranges see all sorts of ammunition related failures, new and reloads.
 
I have shot thousands and thousands of FM remans and new manufacture and have had zero issues.
The only rounds I have ever seen come out of the box with alarming setback were factory new, from reputable companies like Remington and Winchester.

I hope they take care of you OP. Be patient and keep politely bugging them about it.
 
So far, I am awaiting the claim paperwork to be sent to me by customer service. I had a hell of a time getting in contact with the supervisor handling my claim.....I spent all of last week trying to get in touch with her, and had to go above her head and speak with her boss to finally get a phone call from her. She alleges that I should receive that paperwork within the next day or so....we'll see.
 
Last summer when ammo and components were in short supply I picked up a box of Freedom 230FMJ 45s from a small LGS. I filled a mag and fired 3 rounds - all of which felt very powerful. I chased down my brass saw signs of very high pressure (extremely flattened primers). I dismantled the rest of them and tossed the powder. After hearing your story I am very glad I did. I'd be curious to see a picture of one of the spent shells that still has a primer in it.

Sorry for the loss of a very nice Colt but am glad you weren't hurt any more than you were. Please keep us posted on the outcome.
 
No.
Reloaded ammo is done by people in their homes, as a hobby.
Remanufactured ammunition is just that, and is done by a company that offers a warranty in the case of exactly this kind of incidents.
If these were reloads, he'd be out of luck except for a civil case.

I have never had any issues with freedommunitions, but I know that about every ammo manufacturer has experienced this problem, its all in how they deal with it, and how often it occurs. Hope everything works out for the OP.
Any company can say anything about their QC. I am sure some remanufactured ammo is just fine but who is to say that some is not fine? I would not take the risk myself.There is nothing stopping me from calling my reloads " REMANUFACTURED. A name will hold still for anything. There is a case of a guy blowing up a brand new S & W M & P Pro and is have a warranty problem because he used " REMANUFACTURED" ammo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top