Confusion over Canadian gun laws leads to injury in bear attack

Status
Not open for further replies.

Preacherman

Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
13,306
Location
Louisiana, USA
From CBC North (http://north.cbc.ca/regional/servlet/View?filename=sep05gunlawattack05092003):

Guns not at ready before bear attack
WebPosted Sep 5 2003 09:13 AM CDT

IQALUIT, Nunavut - A misunderstanding about firearms legislation may have contributed to the severity of a polar bear attack near Kimmirut on Tuesday.

The Inuit guide who was the victim of the brutal bear attack did not have a gun to defend himself.


bearattackmain.jpg



Kootoo Shaw says as far as he knew, he wasn't allowed to have a gun while he's working as a guide.

"We Inuit are not supposed to have any guns when we guide people from down south, that's why we didn't have a gun," he says.

However, that's not what the law says. While Nunavut's Wildlife Act says Inuit cannot use guns to hunt while they're guiding, they can carry guns for protection against bears.

Shaw says that isn't how he understood the rules.

The U.S. hunters also seemed to have misinterpreted national rules.

John Clark, one of three hunters with Shaw, says his group was told they could carry guns but that the bullets had to be removed when the gun was idle.

"The reason we left is because we knew there are more bears out there, they've been seen and there's no way of protecting yourself," he says. "Unless you can sleep with a loaded weapon, and even that is a little chancy."

The Canadian Firearms Act governs how firearms are stored, and stipulates when guns should be unloaded.

Hal Major, the district manager of the Canada Firearms Centre in Winnipeg, says hunting trips are one of several exceptions to the rule.

"The firearm does not have to be unloaded, it does not have to be rendered inoperable," he says.

Major says that if confusion exists about Canadian gun laws, it's possible that more public education about the rules and regulations is required.

Meanwhile, Kootoo Shaw remains in hospital, recovering from his injuries.

He required 300 stitches to his head and suffered numerous bites and slashes to his back and feet.
 
Is the Canadian Firearms Act and the Nunavut Wildlife Act only printed in English and French?It seems that there may be a language barrier here.
 
This is the sort of thing that happens when you wind up with all manner of restrictions on what can or cannot be done, and where and when and all that. For instance, what difference does it make if a guide hunts or does not hunt when guiding customers? And I'd bet the regulations about emptying a gun and storing the gun and all that don't make it obvious that there is an exception "when hunting".

When fools are in charge, you get foolish rules.

"Real" people die; unfortunately, the fools don't.

Art
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top