Could they really be "cooler"

Status
Not open for further replies.

mossberg

Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
378
Location
Saskatchewan,Canada
First off, I don't own a Revolver or and auto loading pistol. Main reason being I live in Canada which makes shooting and owning handguns (and everything else) pretty difficult. However, I don't know why, but recently I have thought of Revolvers as cooler. They are traditional and reliable. I have not recently been watching "westerns" either. I just like revolvers all of a sudden. Who else likes revolvers better than pistols?
 
Canada's handgun laws are pretty strict. First off, you need a special license to own them. Then they are either restricted or prohibited based on barrel length. You are not allowed to shoot them at an informal range, or in other words land you own where you are allowed to shoot long arms. You must belong to a range to purchase or own a handgun.
 
With gun laws like that Canada must not have any violent crimes.

What do the Canadian police do with all the spare time on their hands?
 
I love revolvers, particularly the S&W K frame Model 66 .357 Magnum 2.5 barrel,L frame 686P .357 magnum 2.5 barrel,and the N frame 629 Classic .44 Magnum 5.0 barrel.
You've got me in the mood to go out and shoot my .44 Mag this weekend.
It's sad and disturbing that Canadians like yourself have to suffer with these insane restrictions coming out of Ottawa,Toronto and Montreal.
Is succession for Western Canada a possibility?
We tried it here once but a few mistakes at Gettysburg ruined our chance to succeed.
 
It may sound funny.............but it's still true. ;) Cooler AND less Evil!

I've been a wheelyshooter since I was a kid. Started with a Fanner 50, moved up to a Colt SA, then lots of Smith & Wessons, some Rugers, now lately I'm thinking I'd rather have more Smiths than anything else. I carry a Model 64 at work, a Model 65 at home, and should pick up a 44 Special (Rossi) this weekend. If I had the cash, I'd pick up another 686, and a 696, and a K-22, and M-27, and a 57, and a 625.....................for starters.:eek:

Papajohn
 
Another Canadian here. It takes about six months to get a license for pistols, you have to take two safety courses, pay about 150 bucks, pass two tests, fill out a stack of forms. Sign a form swearing that you aren't nuts and have never abused your spouse, fill in more paper work, then go and buy your new toy.

Every year we have more gun crime, but less gun owners, funny eh?

Back on topic revolvers are pretty cool. I have both auto's and revolvers and the one that does it for me is my black powder 1858 remington(which has to be registered same as a new glock).
 
I like revolvers because I don't have to search all over Creation for my brass when at the range.

And if I spread out that white bedsheet to catch'em, never fails my range buddies with muddy feet tramp all over it. :)

My condolences for gun-owning Canadians. Mom is from Winnipeg, Dad is from Calgary -- but they winter in Florida (with dual-citizenship). Best and worst of both worlds. Strangely enough, they have firearms in Florida... but not even a BB gun in Canada.
 
I'm a Minnesotan; we're neighbors! I use to be an all-1911 guy, but I've evolved into an all-revolver guy. In fact an all-stainless-DAO-Ruger-revolver guy. Mine are short barrels, though, so, they're too evil for Canada. You can get the GP100 in a longer barrel, though. I sure like mine.
 
Well, at least you can get a Swill Mini Gun in Canadia. Here, they're considered "unsporting" by the gommt. Apparently, the Canadian government does not consider it to be a legitimate firearm, and don't feel like it's worth restricting. I think that the differences in the governing attitudes are interesting, to say the least. :rolleyes:

./Michael
 
Gotta love that Swill. Under the prices tab I got a grin on these lines:

Miniature Revolver in 18k Gold, hand engraved, delivered in a luxurious green tinted maple wood presentation box in which are fitted, a 18k Gold key holder, a green rocket-launcher tube, 48 cartridges, 24 live and 24 blank and 36 luminous rockets, 12 of each red, green and white and a cleaning set.
 
Revolvers are cooler. plus they just look neater when being used by either good guys or bad guys in the movies.

The only exceptions for "cool looking" auto loaders would have to be either the Mauser C96 Broomhandle or the Luger P-08. Now those models are wicked looking.

JMHO.
 
Revolvers are different, and fill different nitches than automatics nowadays.

Revolvers:

  • Capable of using wildy varying ammo -- for example, you can shoot full charge .357s and powder-puff .38 Special target loads from the same gun.
  • Available in more powerful cartridges -- few automatics will handle something as powerful as the .44 magnum or hot-loaded .45 Colt.
  • They don't throw away your brass and leave you crawling around in the woods looking for it.
  • Simple to operate -- point and shoot.
  • Aesthetics -- many fine old revolvers are true works of art.
Automatics:

  • Higher cartridge capacity.
  • Quicker reloads in combat.
  • Flatter, easier to conceal.
  • Generally more durable under severe conditions.
 
I bought my first auto pistol a couple of years ago. It has functioned flawlessly and is more accurate than I expected, but it just doesn't excite me. But I see a revolver (especially a single action) and I have to touch it, admire it (buy it lol). I've purchased 4 revolvers since. I guess I'm pretty much a revolver guy.
 
My first gun, which I bought (with my dad's signature, since I was only 16) with my own money, was a brand new S&W 625. I wanted the .45 ACP, and I LOVED revolvers. Thought they were the coolest invention on God's Green Earth.

I still have it. It sports a Red Dot and new Performance Center grips. It's a wonderful piece, and I consider it much "cooler" than my other pistols.
 
I'm both Canadian and a wheelgun enthusiast

It is easier to own (buy?) firearms/handguns in the U.S. because you don't need a PAL (Possession and Acquisition License) like we do. But once we have a PAL, buying firearms is not a big deal. One thing that bothers me with Canadian firearms regulations is the prohibition on handgun barrels less than 106 mm.; so that precludes snubbies and service-type 4 inchers.

There are 4 advantages of wheelguns over autos:

1. Reliability - functionally and mechanically simpler than autos, no magazines to loose or worry about, jams are almost non-existent
2. Ease of use - no safeties to think about, just point and squeeze, very simple manual of arms
3. Inherent accuracy - most stock revolvers are more accurate than most stock autos
4. Prettier:)

There is only one disadvantage: you're limited to 6 - 8 shots (in a defensive caliber like 357 magum ... you can get 10-shot .22 lr revolvers) but if you consider the first three advantages above, a couple of speedloaders and some practice will more than compensate.

Have always had both types since 1987, until two weeks ago. I sold my last 1911 (Colt Mark IV Series 80 in blue) and replaced it with a new Ruger GP100 6".

Right now, having a couple of issues with the GP100 but I'm sure they will be resolved.

Jet
 
1. Reliability - functionally and mechanically simpler than autos, no magazines to loose or worry about, jams are almost non-existent
Hang around this board long enough, and you'll read about plenty of revolver stoppages. Most stoppages in automatics can be cleared by a simple tap-rack-bang drill. But once a revolver packs up, the shooter can't quickly clear it.
 
Revolvers do jam, but....

you are correct Vern (Humphrey), and like anything man-made, revolvers ... all guns... will jam sometime in their lifetime. IMO, he probability of stoppage is lower for wheelguns than it is for automatics. This is because of the inherent mechanical and functional complexity of all autos.

Any firearm malfunction no matter how quick, simple or easy it is to clear, if it occurs at the most inopportune moment, can be disastrous.

In my humble experience, target range/competition only, i can recall many 1911 stoppages (11 different 1911s at some point...all gone) and not a single revolver jam (S&W M-14, M-28, Colt Python, always had/have two S&W 686s at any one time).

The 686s had primer-caused misfires initially, when stock hammer and trigger return springs were replaced, that were remedied by using Federal and Winchester primers exclusively.

Primer misfires also happened in 1911s when hammer springs were modifed/replaced with weaker ones. or hammers replaced with lightweight titanium models in the pursuit of quicker lock times and light trigger pulls.
The 1911 functions beautifully when all the parts function perfectly, IMHO the ultimate play/defensive automatic.

In fairness to J.M. Browning and his 1911 auto, I would say that in trained hands, a properly tuned, quality manufactured (i.e. Springfield Armory, Colt, Remington) 1911 auto fed with ammo it likes, will be as reliable as any tuned, decent quality revolver, with good ammo of course.

Alas, the main reason I prefer wheelguns today, is the fact that passage of time has decreased my willingness to bend over to pick up brass:) :(

And my brand-new baby, a Ruger GP100, is exhibiting timing problems and the cylinder has jammed (refused to rotate) twice already. I think it is a warranty issue at this point and am hoping it will be resolved easily. I sold my Colt Gold Cup Series 80 to buy this GP100:(

Jet
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top