• You are using the old Black Responsive theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Diagnose and Fix thread! [loonie]

Status
Not open for further replies.

sm

member
Joined
Dec 22, 2002
Messages
28,387
Location
Between black coffee, and shiftn' gears
loonie has a 870 problem

http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?p=2637965#post2637965

I decided to start a new thread to assist member loonie and perhaps others with similar problems.

I propose we simply list the steps, and walk thru the problem solving steps.

Number these steps to make it easier for referencing.

loonie - we want you to simply go down the list, and use the corresponding number to respond "yes" or "no" as you go down the list.

Folks - please use the numbers and Please feel free to use additional numbers as we go along.

When we get to place this thread is "edited and straightforward" , hopefully we will have a 'checklist' in the proper order.

Feel free to edit or make suggestions.

Steve
 
Preface for new folks to shotguns.

Four Rules Of Gun Safety Apply
Rules of Safe Dry-Fire Apply.


Do not buy a shotgun.until :

a. you have been with a seasoned shooter, whom knows about gun fit, and various shotguns to assist in what shotgun and loads for various tasks from target, to hunting game, to competition.

b.. Shoot with that instructor a VARIETY of shotguns to determine if that gun fits YOU, and gun fit encompasses a LOT of matters such as "can YOU reach the controls and manipulate them".

c. Ladies are strongly Urged to have ladies assist them , and/ or have a competent qualified seaonsed male instructor that has EARNED the confidence of ladies to work with Ladies and the ability to address the special needs of ladies.

--Now after shooting a variety of Shotguns, and with seasoned assistance you now KNOW what fits YOU and your tasks, have a seasoned shotgunner go with you to inspect shotguns, new or used, to look for any problems from the factory, or any deviations on a used one someone may have done to used for competition or anything else.

--You now have a gun.

d. Used, order the Instruction Manual.

It would be really great if the seasoned folks that have assited thus far , continued to assist you with the following steps below.


--

1. Read the Instruction manual at least 3 times.

Commonly referred to "RTFM"

2. From RTFM have the Proper tools to take apart the gun. Also have any Factory supplied/ suggested tools handy. Golf tees work well to punch out receiver pins to drop trigger group [TG] for instance.

3. RTFM as you "Step by Step" take gun apart. Putting parts on a cleared table, workbench, the floor, somewhere where they are in some kind of order removed, and will not allow parts to get lost, or other parts mixed in with them.

4. Do NOT force anything - if it does not feel 'right' - Stop! Do not force, slow down and RTFM. If you cannot figure it out - Stop and contact someone that knows that gun and can assist.

5. RTFM on how to Clean & Lube the gun.
[THR / TFL have specific threads on certain aspects of guns on how to clean. Such as chambers, Trigger groups, how to seal end grain...etc.]

Clean & Lube the gun according the instructions.

6. RTFM as you put gun back together.

Do NOT force anything. Again if something is not right, stop, take a break, RTFM and go back to last steps where everything was fine.
Ask for assistance if stuck.

7. Gun is back together, clean and lubed as per the instructions and now cycle the gun.

8. RTFM on what the Shotgun was designed to shoot.

9. Buy Quality Target loadings such as those used for Skeet, Trap, Sporting Clays - that also fall under "what this friggin' gun is designed to shoot".

2 3/4" shells only please. Save the hulls. Make notes in notebook of any problems, and use a Sharpie Marker to put a number on that hull that matches in notebook the notes of any problems with that shell.

10. IF the gun ran fine - Great! RTFM and clean and lube again allowing you to inspect any wear marks, to see how gun wears, what gets dirty and needs cleaning, any areas you had not enough lube or too much lube...etc.

11. Go Buy more ammo and start Patterning the gun with various loads making notes in a notebook.

12.
Gun Did NOT Work. RTFM as to any nuances the manual may suggest is common with shotgun when new until worn in some.
Used Gun - RTFM to see if any characterics are stated telling you a part is in need of replacing, such as a spring.

13. Ammo. Suggested to use Quality Target Ammo as these are most often made to better specifications.

Some guns do NOT like certain ammo. If you used Promotional Ammo, then you opened yourself up to possible headaches such as not being in spec, [bases, diameter of shell, length of shell...] inferior base material and constructions and - you just made diagnosing [ Dx] harder on yourself.

IF quality ammo was used-

14. Chambers are the number one reason a gun fails to feed and extract - no matter the action type. Plastic shells leave a "plastic" residue that the old waxed paper hulls did not.

Wisps of Finest grit of Scotchbrite Pad - or 0000 steel wool on a bronze brush on a cleaning rod in a battery operated drill will clean this fast.

15. Extractors come up as number 2 reason guns do not feed or extract.

(1a)On a barrel there is a "barrel cut" for the extractor to fit into. If this gets too much debris, or is gunked up due to grease or whatever used to protect the gun in the elements, to keep it looking nice, or protected - debris will buld up.
The Extractor cannot properly fit into barrel cut, and this can impeded feeding, and extraction.

(2a) Extractor is out of specificiation.

(3a) Extractor spring is weak or broken

(4a) Extractor is broken.
Some have reported MIM extractors breaking.


I am going to stop here and allow loonie to read and others to chime in.

My gut says the Extractor is the problem his new 870.
 
Good thread. Good list.

Not sure if this is as scientific but 870's are so modular that I have found it quite useful to swap parts with guns that work. This is especially helpful for proving that a problem is with a barrel or extractor. It is very easy to switch to a barrel that is known to work. So easy in fact, I'd do this first. Bolts are the next easiest thing to swap as you can to this as a whole unit, again swapping with a known working part.
After that, it gets a little more complex if you want to be changing lifters and stuff. As many posters here, I have a gaggle of 870's and this technique has always worked for me.
Mike
 
9mmMike

Great Post.

loonie when you get to # 15, since you stated your friend has exact same gun,
take his bolt [has the extractor] and try on your gun, and him yours.

Just a step by step problem solve excercise is all we are doing.

Only ONE step at a time, then WRITE this step down. Too many "fixes" at the same time messes with DX and Ax [assessments].

NOTE: One MUST have a baseline.

This is another reason we suggest Checking out a bone stock firearm before bolting on any accessories.

If something is not right, makes Dx and correcting a nightmare. It could be the factory gun is at fault and not the bolt on stuff.
 
thanks to sm, I did all the checklist,but the thing is, please check the pic, it shows where the empty shell stuck in my gun. as you see,the empty just stuck there tightly,but in my friends barrel,it was just a little bit tight but still can be ejected out. so I don't think this problem caused by the extractor. what do you think? BTW,the dealer said to me that day, they selled about 1000 870,only 3 gun has such problem(tight chamber in barrel)...
 

Attachments

  • 870.jpg
    870.jpg
    58.2 KB · Views: 33
Step 9.

That pic , well that shell sure appears to have the cheesy base metal a LOT of folks have had trouble using. Including Training courses instructed by Awerbuck , Cain and others.

Word that I have received is - these Training Folks tell the students to NOT bring that Win Load or the Win Reduced Buckshot to class because of Way too many problems.

I welcom Lee Lapin, Gordon, and others that have attended training to give input .

loonie-

Step 12 and 13.

Get some Quality target loads. Heck go bum some. With barrel still off the gun, just slip these quality shells into chamber.

Repeat with one of these loadings like in the pic - my gut says you will feel a difference right there.

---

I still say to:

Step 9 , sharpie marker and notebook part.

I would also make sure extractor is clean. I would even way sharpie marker both your extractor and friends extractor and compare extraction marks.

I / we are testing for extractor differences

Fired shell get hot, expands. If extractor does not get a grip, cannot pull out,

With lesser quality bases being a pain in the backside anyway...longer that shell in in gun more it may expand.

If extractor is correct, and shell is quality - then snatching the hull out proper is a snap, if left in [not shucking the gun] the quality hull is not going to expand as much and for sure still be in spec.


Reloaders get lazy and do not re-size hulls. We see the same thing loonie.

Gas guns shoot a shell and expand it more than Over and Unders [O/U] If one does not re-size that hull - ALL THE WAY down to base, that shell is not going to even fit in a O/U - much less extract.
 
Last edited:
Step 12 and 13.

Get some Quality target loads. Heck go bum some. With barrel still off the gun, just slip these quality shells into chamber.

Repeat with one of these loadings like in the pic - my gut says you will feel a difference right there.
I did what u suggested,the thing is,even the crappy unfired ammo can slip into chamber very easily(it seems the ammo expands after firing too much).

Fired shell get hot, expands. If extractor does not get a grip, cannot pull out,

With lesser quality bases being a pain in the backside anyway...longer that shell in in gun more it may expand.

yeah,I almost can rule out the problem of extractor,since my friend's shotgun has longer barrel(870 express super magnum synthetic) and maybe his barrel just looser than mine,so more chance to get empty out... anyway,to sm,do you think what I can do is gonna ask for remington's gunsmiths to resize the chamber in barrel?
 
loonie,

Earlier you said the gun shop checked your chamber and it was in spec - didn't you?

1. Send the gun to Rem and have them check it out under warranty.

2. Go find someone either at a Range that is qualified and knows shotguns - please - and let them shoot this gun. Be nice, and if lucky maybe someone will measure your chamber.

3. Pay out of pocket to have a qualified gunsmith check out this gun. Qualified Gunsmith will be honest and evaluate, he will need the exact same box of shells to check this problem out.
If he feels gun needs to go to Rem, fine. If he can cure fine.


Just you really need to spend time - even if it costs money - to hang with and listen to seasoned shooters.

I have measured shells, and all sorts of stuff to learn from.

Heck I have used Play-doh, to get inside dia so I could measure a chamber or choke and measure that way.

Silly Putty too...

loonie,

you have a gun problem. I just believe in keeping simple when Dx and coming up for the "why" and "fix".

Do not make this any harder than it is. Sometime the best thing is to put down a problem and forget it.

When you come back - fresh perspectives come to light.

Not just for shotgun fixes either...

I bet you have not drop-kicked that barrel yet either. :D

Kidding!.....Well sorta...drop-kick is on down the list we ain't got to yet.:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top