Do you really need more than a .44 magnum?

Status
Not open for further replies.
...if you shot them enough, accelerate the onset of your arthritis about 25 years.

Actually, my arthritis showed up first in my neck and upper back, not my shooting hand. It runs in my mother's family as far back as anyone was ever able to remember.

I doubt shooting big bore revolvers causes arthritis, but am sure it can cause tendon problems and make arthritis pain worse.
 
I doubt shooting big bore revolvers causes arthritis, but am sure it can cause tendon problems and make arthritis pain worse.

Injuries, even small ones, and wear can materially contribute to arthritis. Many runners, for example, pay for it in later life with athritic knees.
 
Another problem is what was called repetitive motion syndrome, now referred to as carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). When bending the wrist the same way for extended periods, and especially with vibration or recoil-like movement, the nerve bundle leading through the carpal tunnel in the wrist joint is abraded by rubbing on said passage, causing nerve damage. This is sometimes evidenced by an electric-shock-like feeling and an involuntary release of what is gripped. It is worsened by continuing the repetitive process - and, some say, our diets. The mylos, or sheath, is said to be thin due to diet - adding certain supplements may help here - I think it has in my case. Surgery may be an aid, or a temporary relief, but the nerve damage is mostly permanent.

I developed CTS by holding woodturning chisels for hours as I turned the 12,000+ items I turned for my retirement hobby/avocation, now terminated, arts and craft business. It was just as I wound that down that I decided to start shooting a lot - mostly .45 Colts - and .454's. The weight of the revolver proved more troublesome than it's recoil. The trigger pull was worse - the AMT DA Backup's I had - and my neat little 1895 Nagants - both with 'tweaked' triggers over 20 lbs - hurt more than the 629MG stoked with .44 Magnums. The key here is to break up your regimine - don't do the same thing continuously. Treat the ache with whatever OTC antiflammatory you can - maybe even sleep with wrist braces on. Get professional help before you loose feeling in your fingers, etc.

BTW, my .45 Colt-style heavy push form of recoil hurts less than the sudden recoil of a .44 Magnum. Both can be made more manageable with a better grip position and grip construction, the SRH and the new S&W .500 grips being examples of such an improvement.

Stainz
 
I've fired both 44 magnums and the Freedom Arms 454 Casull. I found the 44 magnum to be more than enough. But that's from my end as the trigger puller. I wouldn't reccomend the 44 mag as a plinking round. As far as target shooting goes I'll stick with the 22LR, 38 spc and 45 acp.

I've also had the opportunity to fire a Model 70 in 458 Winchester Magnum and a Weatherby MK V in 460 Weatherby. Wow! I can honestly say that a 12 gauge shotgun and a 30-06 rifle is enough for me.

Notice that I said nothing about need. Just what I feel comfortable with. However all you power guys go have a good time.
 
I've got no desire for anything more than a .44 Mag. Even at the .44, I'm only good for a box or two of ammo at a time. Boy that thing gives me a bloody headache, but it's sure fun!
 
Don't get me wrong I love Ruger's .44 Redhawk but then I picked up a
BFR 45-70. It is an amazingly easy to shoot gun for its power and has
a wide range of rounds available. From hogs to BIG Bears you can tailor
load it to meet your needs. You can even safely generate more power in
it than the S&W.500. There is a reason the 45-70 has been around for
over 100 years. I would suggest going to www.garret.com if you do not
hand load. And I agree with using a Ruger for the heavy .44 loads.
 
I've found that recoil is over come through repetition and technique. Originally, when I got my RBH, I was in severe pain. I like shooting more than the pain's discomfort. Plus I was to hardheaded to admitt I had "too much gun". After a while I became used to the recoil and allowed the gun to roll in my hands freely. My .44 is my plinking rnd. My .500's aren't all that much worse. Depending on the grain, I can rapid shoot fast enough, on target.
good shootin
kid
 
Uhhh....to me the .357 Magnum loaded with 200 grain Cor Bon is about all I want to handle in a pistol. If I need more power, I'll grab a rifle (or shotgun). Just IMO, YMMV

I don't think any pistol round is terribly effective on a charging bear for example, but with a pistol I can control (.357), I think the chances of a follow up shot are greater than a pistol that is hard on my body (.44 magnum). Truth be told, if I was going into (big animal) country, I'd be carrying a rifle (with a .357 6" loaded with 200-grain Cor-Bon as backup).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top