Ever been taken on a trade /paid too much?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Moonclip

Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2005
Messages
2,766
Location
USA
We always hear about the good deals. Whos man or woman enough to admit to the mistakes or to buying something at a very premium price for whatever reason?

I luckily have not too many bad ones but here goes.

traded a early 1950's 16ga Ithaca 37 16ga in 97-98% for a Plainfield m1 carbine! I only had $60 in the Ithaca though and the Plainfield has been flawless which seems to be rare for an non military M1 carbine. I had no use for the 16 ga at the time.

Traded a Colt New Service 45LC with minor rust but with real stag grips and period custom work for a S&W mod 14 6" from the late 1960's with Pachmayrs and it wasn't more than 95%!

In my earlier gun years I couldn't afford to shot much 45LC as 38spl and I had been wanting a K38 of some sort.

My dad paid $175 each for a pair of somewhat beat refinished model 10's. We had a hard time finding them at the time and wanted one and luckily later we made up for it by finding a guy selling security company trade in ones in better shape from $90-150.

I paid in 2002 $369 for a S&W mod 17 22lr 6". Seemed high at the time but it seemed NIB and it did have a tattered box to go with it. I'm very cheap sometimes when it comes to guns so even paying a normal price to get a special piece gets to me sometimes! I religiously search for gun bargains.

I let my dad trade a POS Sigma 380acp of mine and some cash(can't remember how much, maybe $100) for a used Llama 45 1911 clone of all things. Jammed somewhat, would not shoot to point of aim, and did not work well with standard 1911 magazines.

Ended up trading I think even for a late model Ruger standard MK1 22lr 6". Decent gun but I don't like how it does not lock the bolt on the last shot and MK 1 mags can be a pain to find and they come in two variations

Was going to sell it to a friend but he passed away. I may end up consigning this gun at a place I know that is known to get high prices( they sold my used EAA European model380acp for $200!) and at least gain back some of my wasted $.
 
If you trade enough...

You're gonna eventually get burned. Kinda like the guy who says he's never lost a fight. Very likely, he's never been in one. The same logic applies to both pursuits: Choose your engagements wisely, try to come out on top more than on the bottom.
 
I needed money after getting out of the Army for insurance for the kids. Sold my 1958 M-70 Winchester in .264 magnum for $110. Also sold my python with 4" bbl for $150 at the same time. Needed the money and knew I was getting taken but..........did it anyway.
 
i paid way, way too much for my first 2 rifles. it was awhile ago, so don't recall specifics, but when i found out how bad i got ripped off, i nearly left the shooting sports (incidentally, two of my brothers also got taken on their first rifle purchases, which also turned them off - they both are out of the shooting sports now because they didn't like getting ripped off).

fortunately for me, i figured out how things work, and i'm able to walk away from rip-offs w/ no troubles (latest example: dealer had a post-64 win 70 in 264 win mag - push feed - offered to trade it to me for my like-new remington m7 and only $400 more on my part).

also, fortunately for me, i figured out a little more, and actually made money on my last deal (sold a rifle to a local dealer, and made money on it, believe it or not)... was only about $75, but i'll take it!
 
Sure, happens all the time. I'm not a neophyte, but I'm not a full-time dealer either. I let emotion sway my decisions - - doesn't every gun-nut??

Worst one was a Colt Commander cut down to 3" with all the appropriate custom goodies. My smith discovered that it's insides had been cut so close that it was a wonder I could get it to fire intermittantly. I had to buy a whole new upper in order to sell it.
 
Don't know if I have ever been really burned. But I sure as heck feel that way doggone nearly every time I make a trade. I always have buyer's remorse and trader's regret :cuss:
 
Yep. I'll 'fess up to having made more than one bad trade. I once let go of a very nice '50s vintage S&W Model 10 for ... a new Kel-Tec P-40. Needless to say, I didn't keep the Kel-Tec very long. I traded off a nice old Beretta 1934 (in .32, not .380) for a ... gasp ... Taurus 908 that had some disturbing functionality issues ...

OTOH, I picked up a LNIB SIG 226 (that probably hadn't seen even one box of ammo through it) for a well-used SA Mil-Spec (that I, and some very good shooters, just couldn't get to shoot better than 6-inch groups at 25 yards after much work). The SIG turned out to be a stone reliable tackdriver ...

I would submit that anyone who's been in the gun-trading game for long has made at least one (in hindsight) horrible deal ...

I always have buyer's remorse and trader's regret
Same here, and every time, I say never again ... but comes then another gun show ...
 
Many Times!

Back when I was teenager of about 14 or about 35 years ago, you could not give away Colt SA's. They were dirt cheap and my Dad traded a 2nd. Generation SA 45LC in the black box for me a new Remeington 1100 skeet gun. I was shooting in a skeet league at the time and thought I had to have one. It would have been better for me to never have heard of skeet and still had that Colt SA! :eek:
 
I'm man enough to admit...I've loss money on gun trade-ins and paid too much for others. I've wondered about posts that state, "I really got a great deal", etc. Gun stores never lose money and mostly over price firearms. I've come to understand the trade.
 
I got burned many times when I was learning about firearms. Now I find I've developed a "nose" for value and come out ahead even when I don't know specifics about the item I'm buying.
 
I've paid too much, even on a sale price!

My SA M1A standard w. fiberglass stocks. $1250 + dros + tax etc... ended up close to $1400 OTD.

overall, with the sale price, thats a lot in the end to shell out for a upgraded SKS feeling rifle.
 
ah, I paid $479 for a Glock 23

about ten years ago. Was well under MSRP at the time. Well, ten years later, I can buy a new one for about that price. Guess it's not so terrible.
 
Paid too much:
Colt Delta Elite fitted with bomar sight, additional .40 S&W barrel at Colt custom shop, purchased used.....$950 3 years ago.
New beretta 87 with extended barrel (22 lr)......$420

Bought them during a moment of weakness, they just looked too nice to pass up. :eek:
 
Of course...a few too many. Usually happened when I bought something without having any information about it. One example- A guy offered me a choice of m1 carbines for $100. I chose the nice new Universal over the old dirty USGI models. Ohhh shiiiny!
 
I was browsing a funshow a year or so ago and found a LNIB series I kimber. It was on a table and marked $675. Assuming the seller was a dealer, I offered $700 OTD which including tax would be a decent deal. He gave me a funny look and said sure, here ya go, no tax or paperwork. As I walked away a light came on in my head, I just ripped off myself. I went back to his table and told him of the misunderstanding. He gave me my 25 back chuckling lightly, but could have kept it and laughed loudly. I probably could have gotten away for $650 or less :banghead:
 
There are many people who buy, sell, and trade guns regularly and who say they have never paid too much, never been taken, never regretted a purchase.

They are lying.

Jim
 
Itradeda Danish Madsen rifle for a blood hound one time,beat my self bad , ole dan didnt do any thing but mess up the yard. mike
 
Back in ' 93 (I was new in guns). I sold my Colt Combat Elite .38 super for $275. I didn't know how much its worth. I did it to finance a new purchase (I can't even remember now what is was). It does hurt to remember. :(
 
Interesting, Tman, those prices, especially the Beretta are not too bad but you are probably just cheap like me!

Actually, I think being in CA is not too bad for guns being high. We probably actually have a better selection and better prices than some areas of free America. Examples lately include NIB Ruger P97dc for $280 and used S&W mod 18 97-98% for $250. You just have to go out and search.

A Danish Madsen for a Bloodhound? What were you thinking? Although I have a strange desire to either get a English Bulldog or a blue pitbull with a white head one day and I guess a decent dog would be about the same value as a Madsen if not more.

$275 for a Combat Elite in 1993? Maybe you'll feel better that I sold a 45acp one about 90% for what I had in it, $200 in like 2001!

Kind of had to though, it had seen some duty in a rental case and developed problems and the guy who I bought it from never completed the transfer as required by our state so I just wanted rid of it.
 
I traded in my 6" GP100(the most accurate gun I've ever shot)for a Dan Wesson w/ the 3 barrels(mod. 15 i think).....plus I paid some extra money for an extra barrel.....the DW SUCKED....the thing would lock up in SA..the cylinder would bind up...I had the gun shop look at it..they said they didn't see anything wrong with it....I ended up trading it in on an SP101(the GP was long gone)....the SP was a good trade though.it's now my CCW...so I guess it worked out,but I'd still love the GP back....and I'll never buy DW again.
 
Were you using the feeler gauges to set the gap between the cylinder and barrel?

I've owned DW revolvers. Never had a problem.

I've sold guns that I regret selling. Guns that are worth so much today that I probably will never replace them. But I got a fair price at the time. I just never should have sold them at all.

Taught me to be careful about selling.
 
I got burned on my standard loaded M1a came out to around 1600ish... Found out other gun shop/range I was shooting at could have gotten it for 1400 :mad: but when I asked them about it they told me it was a standard not loaded...

But at gun shop 2 that had M1a cheaper I paid too much for my m1 carbine because it needed work but those were my first guns.

I made up for it with the enfield thoug I found one that looked brand new for 110 at a gun show C&R.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top