Federal excise tax on guns: double dipping?

Status
Not open for further replies.

weasleyhr

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2020
Messages
14
The federal government imposes a 10% tax on pistols/revolvers and 11% tax on other guns and ammo. Now, you can argue whether this tax is good or bad (I'm not going to do so here) but here's what bothers me: with state sales tax, the states are charging tax on the tax. Double dipping.

For example: suppose I buy a rifle that's worth $500. Counting the excise tax, that's $555. But here's the thing. When I look at my Sportsman's Warehouse receipt, I don't see a line for the excise tax. The price of the gun and the excise tax is lumped together in one price, and the 8% sales tax is added to that. So instead of $500 plus $55 plus $40 (8% of 500) equals $595, it's $555 plus $44.40 (8% of 555) equals $599.40.

Yeah, it's only $4.40 difference, but it's as if you pay, say, $1000 to the IRS for income tax, and then the state comes along and says "We're going to charge you sales tax on the tax you paid to the IRS. You owe us $80." Just like postage stamps are not supposed to be taxable, but now the states are charging sales tax for shipping on internet orders. :fire:

Please excuse the rant. :thumbup:
 
There's a Federal Excise tax on tires and then you pay sales tax on that new amount; there's a federal "luxury tax" on imported automobiles over a certain dollar amount, and then you pay sales tax. Would you prefer the European model with a 22% VAT (National Sales Tax?) At least this tax (and it is on more than just guns and ammo) is used to fund things like shooting ranges and the like.
 
The 11% tax in the link is due to the Pittman-Robertson Act from 1937. One of the few taxes I don't mind paying. The funds go into a special fund and can only be used for certain things.

Pursuant to the 1937 Federal Aid in Wildlife Restoration Act (often called the Pittman-Robertson Act), taxes paid into the United States Treasury under Chapter 32 go into a trust fund. The funds may only be used for wildlife restoration and hunter safety training programs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top