If you can OC in a State park (you can in VA, PA, and WA) you can in a NP. The rule is, whatever state law is.
We've already been over this-stating you can OC in a NP (in VA) just because you can in a SP and
The rule is, whatever state law is may not necessarily be the same thing.
Again, what state law are we mirroring to justify OC in a NP?
As has been pointed out, there are 3 different rules/laws/
directives covering OC in VA-if anyone can point out an official document stating it's OK to OC in a NP according to VA law, I'd be glad to see it (and print and carry should I go to a NP).
Apparently it has only recently become legal to OC in a VA SP, and it was made so by a directive from the governor-it was reported carrying in a NF located in VA was currently open for feedback etc, and may be subject to a future directive from the governor as has recently been done for the SPs.
I'm still a little fuzzy on the directive thang-our current governor was formerly our AG, but what if the current AG doesn't agree with the governor and his directive? Who is the highest LE official of the state, and who is going to have the final say? Exactly where does a directive fit in AFA state laws, which one carries more weight, and which one is the local DA going to enforce, etc?
Now I would assume the governor would consult with the current AG when issuing his directive, but I've seen nothing to indicate such.
I CC, but have on occasion OCed in VA, but ain't no way I'm going to OC in a NP located in VA since this is still a VERY gray area.
99% of the time in a NP I'd still prefer CC-I could see OCing while hiking on a trail etc during warm weather etc, but I see no reason to scare the natives when in the lodges/restaurants etc.