First whitetail with a muzzleloader

Status
Not open for further replies.

Legionnaire

Contributing Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2002
Messages
8,637
Location
Texas
I've been hunting for many years, but just this last year got hooked on black powder. I've been shooting cap and ball revolvers and flintlocks for several months, and also bought a 209x50 barrel for my T/C Encore rifle. I'm still breaking in the flintlocks and have yet to determine optimal loads for them. But the Encore seems to really like a saboted .44 caliber 240 grain XTP over 100 grains of GOEX FFg.

PA's early antlerless muzzleloader season started Saturday. I was out on a friend's farm but didn't see anything all day. It was windy, and not even the squirrels were very active. I saw some sign, including a couple of fresh rubs (noted for the regular season), but nary a deer. Saw a couple of hunters on the adjacent property late in the day, but I gave up before the end of shooting hours and packed it in.

I took today (Monday) off from work to get out again. I was on stand by 6:45 a.m., a good 45 minutes before legal shooting hours. Weather was calm and dry with temps in the upper 40s, predicted to get up into the low 60s. After about 10 minutes, I heard something working it's way through the woods in front of me, coming down a ridge line from left to right. About 7:10, a solitary deer emerged from the thick woods into the more open woods around my stand. Still too dark to tell if doe or buck, but it worked its way to within about 10 yards of my stand, at which point I could tell it had no antlers.

Still 20 minutes until legal shooting hours. During that time I watched that critter wander all over my field of fire, browsing, nosing about, and doing what deer do when they are oblivious to human presence. About 7:25, close to legal hours but not quite, I took advantage of the deer having moved about 40 yards away and standing behind a tree to cock my Encore. Her head came up immediately as she tried to identify the source of that unnatural sound. She didn't, and continued to browse around.

I checked my watch several minutes later and good to go. By then she was about 50 yards out, quartered toward me. The crosshairs rested on her right front shoulder, and the 240 grain XTP went through the shoulder and both lungs. Never experienced the cloud of black powder smoke blocking my vision before; as it cleared, I saw that the doe was already down, about five yards from where she had been standing.

Not the largest doe I've ever shot--in fact, she was pretty small. But first ever with a muzzle loader, and one for the freezer in mid October ... I'm more than satisfied. Still have my PA buck tag and multiple tags for NY, so hoping this one is the first of several this year. And since I still have time today, I'm headed to the range to keep working on one of my flintlocks. Gotta be ready for primitive muzzleloader season in December!
 
Congrats....My first was with a sidelock and a patch and ball. For years my state did not al low inlines and/or optics....I kind of miss the old days.
 
Congrats.
Hoping to have my first ML deer this coming saturday. Going to the range to make sure she's still dialed in tomorrow. I'll be using the saboted 240 grain XTPs as well, behind 90 grains of Pyrodex.
 
Thanks. ColtPythonElite, PA has two muzzleloading seasons. Early is antlerless only, and inlines and optics are okay. Late season is still primitive: flintlocks and irons (I guess fiber optics are okay, but no scopes).
 
I'm very proud of your accurate and lethal shot. This confirms your practise time and careful loading procedure.

I also hunt with Hornady's 240 grain XTP bullet because it makes big holes in deer every time! Accurate, too.

TR
 
Legionnaire, I have joined the club.
I too killed my first muzzleloader deer just yesterday with the same bullet we have been discussing. When the smoke cleared, I looked for the deer and saw the white belly on the ground. Mine was a doe as well, about 90 lbs or so.
The XTP did a very nice job too. A complete pass through with a large exit hole.
 
Good job, Paul; congratulations! I hunt in a "shotgun only" section of NY State every year; no smokeless rifles, but muzzleloaders are legal. Seriously thinking about taking my Encore instead of my shotgun next month. PA also has a late primitive season: flintlocks and iron sights only. It's well after the regular gun season, and if I still have a tag, I'll be out with a Lyman Trade Rifle.
 
Seriously thinking about taking my Encore instead of my shotgun next month.


I think I would rather shoot my muzzleloader than a shotty. It seems like the 240 grain XTP would have a bit more range than a big slug. It may not be so, but it seems like it.
 
I think I would rather shoot my muzzleloader than a shotty. It seems like the 240 grain XTP would have a bit more range than a big slug. It may not be so, but it seems like it.
I chose to purchase a ML for hunting in no rifle WMUs in NY (I had been borrowing a shotgun from my FIL). My reasoning was that the ML allowed me to hunt in the ML season as well as the gun season. I'm not sure how much extra range the ML offers. Some of the saboted shotgun ammo approaches 2,000 fps MV which is probably about the same as what one gets with 100 gr. powder and a 240 gr. bullet. The inline MLs are lighter than shotguns and mine has a sweet trigger which make it nicer to carry the ML.
 
Congrats! all this talk about muzzleloaders is making me want to get mine out and work up a load for this season. hopefully i can bag my first handgun deer in december. fingers crossed!
 
Congrats on your first muzzleloader deer. This coming season will be my first time taking the muzzleloader to the woods. Hoping I too will get my first deer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top