Fun with black powder in .44-40 vintage Colt SA

Status
Not open for further replies.

hang fire

Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2012
Messages
1,089
Finally got around to doing some casting and loading for my recently acquired .44-40 Colt “Frontier Six Shooter” SA. (Colt letter states made in 1886) I have a 3 die set (7/8"x14) for .44-40, but no M die and my smallest boolit sizer was .430”.

Remembered I had a Ideal 310 tool in .44-40 (tools were caliber specific back then) with 6 die set. It had the M-die and lo and behold, a 427 sizing chamber which is what the .426" bore .44-40 calls for. So loaded up 100 rounds with the 310. Slow, but enjoyed using the old reloading tool. It produced good looking and performing ammo loaded with a 200 grain boolit pushed by 33 grains FFg BP.

The shooting of the 126 year old 7 1/2” barrel revolver was a blast, (pun intended) she bellered forth loudly, spitting flame and smoke. Was a little concerned about the 0.012” barrel/cylinder face gap, but didn’t get spit on and velocity did not appear to be lagging.

No targets for test run, was just busting cans and rocks. The thin front sight and fine vee in the rear trough allowed for accuracy test shooting from rest. (offhand for me, forgedabodit) Sitting and from across the knees, was able to consistently center shoot a man size rock at 75 yards.

But it was point and shoot where the naturally pointing Colt came into it’s own for me. With a few practice shots and ignoring the sights, got where I could I dust dance a pop can four out of five quick shots at around 15-20 feet. Maybe not great for the real pistoleros, but good enough for this child.

My boolit lube, consisting of one cup each of melted beeswax and coconut butter with a tablespoon of Mobil 1 oil performed great. BP fouling crud remained soft and damp for 50 rounds with no binding up of the works. I use this same lube for BP and smokeless alike with good results, even at higher rifle velocities. It remains softly firm without breaking down in this AZ heat. That hydrogenated coconut butter is something else, it sits and laughs at 125 degrees without melting.

I won’t be shooting the old girl much, but was tons of fun with it today.

The little Ideal tong tool did a good job of reloading.

TT1.jpg

Sure can’t complain about timing of the Colt.

TT2.jpg
 
Last edited:
I reload 44-40 for my New Service Colt. So far just medium strength smokeless loads. I haven't tried black powder yet. Maybe I'm afraid of the clean-up. I use store-bought 200 grainers, sized to .427 and get good accuracy.

I think you meant .427 not .327, right? A .327 bullet might tend to rattle a bit in a 44-40 barrel.:D

How about posting a picture of your SA?
 
Last edited:
As long as the BP fouling is soft, I find clean up fast and easy on my BP firearms.


You are right, had a duh moment, edited and now changed.

Pic as requested, it came with the period holster.

P1010258.jpg


P1010279.jpg
 
The sizing chamber die is to the left with the plunger sticking out. The cast boolits are sized base first to prevent finning on out of round boolits, the plunger shown has a FRN (flat round nose) profile on the pushing end.


P1010324.jpg

Can see the .44-40 stamped on side of steel tong tool.

P1010326.jpg
 
Nice.
I've been wanting a .44-40 for quite a while.
Full power .44-40 loads are no joke.
 
You got that right, was surprised at the power and recoil from just 33 grains of 2F BP under the 200 grain boolit.

This is my first .44-40 but can see why it was really the cartridge which won the west. Was reading where it brought down more big game, and men, than any other round in latter part of the 1800s.

The thin brass mouth of the case does not suffer fools gladly when loading. The slightest boo boo and one can just scratch and toss it. But that thin brass sure seals good and no chamber fouling like I get with my .45 LC and BP.
 
I used to have an OLD photo of a man with a .44-40 Winchester rifle and several deer he'd killed with it that day.
I'd love to have a .44-40 lever or pump rifle.
 
Howdy

Sure am glad you had a good time shooting 44-40 BP cartirdges. Yes, the thin case mouth can be a bit fussy.

I have five lever guns all chambered for 44-40 and I load my cartridges with Black Powder for all of them. Yes, with modern brass it is a bit tough to stuff more than 32 or so grains under the bullet. My standard load for 44-40 is 2.2CC of FFg under a 200 grain bullet. Depending on the brand of powder I am using that can vary from 33 to 37 grains of powder.
 
My standard load for 44-40 is 2.2CC of FFg under a 200 grain bullet. Depending on the brand of powder I am using that can vary from 33 to 37 grains of powder.[/QUOTE]

LOL, Driftwood, the Lee 2.2 CC scoop is the same one I used for 33 grains of FFg and 200 grain pill.
 
I have been playing around with black powder for more years than I care to remember.

Home page: http://hstrial-rchambers.homestead.com/Index.html

This is my favorite BPCR, A JM Marlin Ballard #5 Pacific in .45-70. Can't shoot like I once thought I could, but it is still fun to bust basketball size rocks out to 2 or 3 hundred yards with it.

P1010288.jpg

P1010287.jpg
 
LOL, Driftwood, the Lee 2.2 CC scoop is the same one I used for 33 grains of FFg and 200 grain pill.

So what brand of powder were you using? Shuetzen FFg usually weighs out to right about 33 grains when I scoop 2.2CC of it. Goex tends to be a tad heavier.
 
Graf's BP, which is identical to, and is in fact one and the same powder as Shuetzen. They are made in the same plant and Mad Monk ran tests which proved conclusively they are one and the same. This holds true until one goes to purchase, the Graf's price is much lower.
 
I know it's not a rifle thread per se, but what's the effective range of the .44-40 out of a lever rifle, about 24 inch barrel, on whitetails?

Been wanting one for a while
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top