Grizz attack #2! -gun free victim zone

Status
Not open for further replies.

gunsmith

member
Joined
May 8, 2003
Messages
5,906
Location
Reno, Nevada
http://www.dailyinterlake.com/articles/2005/09/15/news/news03.txt

Why dont they outlaw bears having "tooth and claw" in National Parks? Her dad fought back with a rock, I wonder if he will be prosecuted? :fire:

Teen on bear attack: 'My dad was screaming'
Posted: Thursday, Sep 15, 2005 - 08:18:48 am PDT
By JIM MANN
The Daily Inter Lake





The father and daughter who survived a bear mauling in Glacier National Park last month recalled the attack Wednesday in appearances on two national news shows.

Johan Otter, 44, and his 18-year-old daughter Jenna were interviewed from La Jolla, Calif., on NBC's "The Today Show" and ABC's "Good Morning America." While Johan Otter held a press conference at a Seattle hospital last week, his daughter made her first public comments about the incident during Wednesday's interviews.

"My dad was screaming, and that's like one of the worst sounds in the world you can hear," she said, recounting the attack in an interview with Katie Couric on "Today."

In talking with "Good Morning America" host Charles Gibson, both displayed ALERT helicopter T-shirts from Kalispell Regional Medical Center.


The Otters were hiking Aug. 25 on the Grinnell Glacier Trail when they rounded a corner and Jenna encountered a female grizzly bear with two cubs about five feet away.

Her father said he remembers his daughter saying "Oh no!" and then the grizzly bear "was into my thigh within a half second."

He said he attempted to keep the bear's attention diverted from his daughter, at one point gripping the bear with one hand while trying to strike it in the head with a rock.

"I'm doing really good because my dad took the brunt of it himself," said Jenna, who was wearing a torso brace and had obvious wounds to her right arm and a wound from the right corner of her mouth across her cheek.

Johan Otter wore a "halo" brace to stabilize his head because of several fractured vertebrae, and his damaged right eye was covered.

In addition to inflicting severe bite wounds to Otter's thigh and arms, the bear bit into his head, tearing away part of his scalp. Otter said that when the bear was biting his head, he could feel a tooth grinding into his skull.

The attack lasted about five minutes, and eventually Johan Otter intentionally fell off the trail, tumbling down a rocky embankment, in an effort to escape the bear. The physical therapist from Escondido, Calif., said he shouted at his daughter to get off the trail, too, and in doing so attracted the bear's attention again.

But eventually the bear went after Jenna, who had retreated to a bush off the trail, where she said she was silent and curled up in a fetal position.

"I think the bear was satisfied with the injuries it inflicted on my dad so then it came over to me," she said.

She told of trying to push the hovering bear away.

"It grabbed my face and tore me this way, then it grabbed my shoulder and tore me the other way," she said. "I think there was enough blood everywhere to make the bear think or be satisfied that we were adequately injured or dead, so we weren't going to hurt its cubs, so it just left."

"You do whatever you have to to protect your own," Johan Otter said at one point, apparently referring to his actions as well as those of the mother grizzly.

The interviews on both shows were brief, and the Otters did not mention the extensive efforts involved with their rescues.

About 20 park rangers were involved in the initial response and providing first aid.

The ALERT helicopter did short-haul extractions from the largely inaccessible trailside area using a manned sling tethered beneath the helicopter.

It was more than six hours from the time they were attacked until they arrived at Kalispell Regional Medical Center.

Park officials have yet to locate the bears involved in the incident, which prompted a temporary closure of trails in the Many Glacier Valley.

The attack attracted considerable media attention from across the country, according to Kalispell Regional Medical Center spokesman Jim Oliverson, who fielded interview inquiries from the morning news shows as well as other national programs such as "Inside Edition."

Reporter Jim Mann may be reached at 758-4407 or by e-mail at [email protected]
 
I've been reading of this sort of event for somewhere near a half-century. I'm sorta thinking out loud, here: If you're out hiking in country where hostile critters are loose, you better think like a hunter. You do your best to see bears before there is some sort of surprise encounter.

We have a similar "sudden encounter" problem with mountain lions here in the Big Bend. Much less actual danger, of course. But if you're on trails with switchbacks, don't charge blindly into the tight spot. Same for canyon country. It's the ancient "Stop, look and listen." thing that we were taught as kids.

You don't have to shoot in order to hunt. "Hunt" means "look for" or "search". As for guns, the problem is that national parks aren't a refuge for people; they're set up as havens for critters. What's not emphasized strongly enough is "Enter At Own Risk". Even the warning signs about bears and lions don't drive home the point that "If things go wrong, you may die."

People whose focus is on the beauties of nature when out in Bad Critter country, and not on hunting, are always going to be candidates for the morgue, the hospital, and TV commentary...

And a .454 Casull is a good beginning. :)

Art
 
"You do whatever you have to to protect your own,"
Apparently not.

I surely wish one day the Park Service would be sued for these stupid Rules they promulgate. They are above prosecution, of course...unless they had Rules banning partial birth abortion.

Rick
 
Art:

Here in Montana the bears seem to know the difference between places (and times) they can be hunted and when they can't. At least with black bears, their tolerance for people changes dramatically.

It may help somewhat to be more aware in bear country, but that won't change the ways that bears respond to people.
 
That's why I don't go on NPS lands. I consider them occupied by a hostile foreign power. Sadly, until we get a President in power who will fire the JBT's running that organization and a Congress that will repeal their absurd regulations, the situation will continue. Guns in the parks is just the tip of the iceberg. The NPS has a long history up here of considering locals a nuisance. They don't even want people getting from A to B with snowmachines across "their" property! When the odd but harmless Pilgrim family tried to use an old dirt mining road across NPS territory as (SHOCK!) an old dirt mining road, the NPS sent hundreds of armed agents and SNIPERS to stop them, on the theory that even an old truck driving across NPS territory in a remote corner of Alaska would rupture the ecosystem. I'd call them animals but frankly I don't want to insult the rodents. Never was a federal agency more in need of a swift kick to the teeth. Frankly the whole operation should be shut down and transferred to state control or at least to the Forest Service. But alas most Americans love the NPS and love the song and dance they put on--including the trained bears at Katmai.
 
Jonathan, no argument. I guess my main point is the human attitude. If I'm hunting, I'm not Dudley Doofus with a focus exclusively on sky, rocks, flowers and views. When I'm hunting, I'm still seeing all those things, but I'm on the lookout for (usually) Bambi--or in bear country, bears.

My notion is that if I see a bear at 50 or 100 feet, that's a bunch better than at five feet. 100 yards and more is even better.

When I was a kid, my grandfather told me that the way to avoid rattlers was to never walk where I couldn't see the ground through the high grass or weeds. I just figure the same sort of reasoning about trees and brush when going cross-country...

:), Art
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top