What is everyones thoughts on gun registration? I live in TX and its a non-registration state but I know some states are. My mom thinks its stupid to not register guns and of course Im not for it. What is everyone elses opinion on it? I could use some arguments in case it ever comes up in a debate .
Aside from the (IMO correct) concerns about 'slippery slope', the question is "what good would it do?"
Suppose we have
perfect registration. That is, every firearm is in a database someplace, and every theft is reported, every permanent move from one address to another is reported - "authorities" can look up firearms by address, or firearms by person, or firearms by auto registration/license.
I, Joe Librarian, have a legally registered pistol. I go to visit my brother, Bill Librarian, who has none and never has had any. There's a domestic disturbance in Bill's front yard, and the police are called.
Can the police reasonably presume that, since Bill has no firearms registered, no firearms are going to be involved? Obviously not - I may have mine, the people fighting in the front yard may have them, some random passerby may have one.
Similarly, suppose Bill's automobile is pulled over for a traffic violation. Can the police rely on the no-gun return on Bill's vehicle? Again, obviously not - there's no way to know who is actually in the vehicle, and whether or not those people are armed.
Even in a perfect system, LEO can't rely on the database to ensure their safety; they must always enter a situation prepared to deal with armed people.
If the police get no safety benefit, why bother?
Sometimes the argument is made that 'we register cars, why not guns?', and there are lots of sly responses that are accurate. But I always go for the efficacy aspect:
We have well over 50 years of experience licencing drivers, with state-by-state variations in the training and knowledge required for licensing, and registering vehicles, again with state-by-state variations in inspections and other aspects of registration.
All these licensed drivers, with hardly ever any ill intent, driving their registered vehicles, which are assuredly not designed for killing anything, have an appalling accidental death toll.
Why on earth would anyone look at all that evidence and conclude that guns would be different?
Actually, they are different - accidental firearms deaths are almost non-existent, with our unlicensed owners and unregistered guns.