Hmm, time to add to the collection again

Status
Not open for further replies.

MacTech

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
774
Location
Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
Decisions, decisions…

I have an old, original Winchester '92, 44-40, it's an old "plantation" gun, it's been refinished, the bore has been recut and has a couple divots in the grooves near the receiver, it tends to get leading and copper buildup with whatever factory ammo I run through it

It does have the ladder sight and the furniture appears to have been hand checkered

With factory ammo, I can print 3-4" groups at 50Y, consistency is poor due to the recut bore, I'm sure I'm getting some gas blow by as the bore diameter has been enlarged by recutting the grooves

It was Dad's old deer rifle, he bought it cheap ages ago, paid around $200 for it, there's no sentiment attached to this gun, it was Dad's cheap deer gun, he only used it for a couple seasons at most, then it simply gathered dust in the gun cabinet, Dad was like me in that he was constantly trading guns as new ones caught his fancy, his last love before he sold most of his collection off was collecting and restoring Stevens Favorite youth rifles, his Win '92 was a tool for harvesting deer, nothing more

I had it appraised at the LGS for around $500, and have been contemplating trading it towards a different gun, in keeping with Dad's likes, I've been leaning towards one of the types below

A Winchester lever in 30-30, same style, with easier to find and cheaper ammo

A Ruger #1 in 30-06, Dad loved his single shots, 95% of his collection were singles

A Revolver in a decent centerfire caliber (Dad was a revolver fan as well)

Over at the LGS, I have a used S&W 686 6" barrel model, with the factory wood grips, firing pin on the hammer, and NO Hillary Hole on 7 day, it looks to be about 95% new condition, points well and balances nicely, and would fill a hole in my collection nicely

I have some Rimfire rifles, a Rimfire revolver, an AR defensive rifle/plinker, a "Bidenator" SxS 12 gauge, a smattering of single shots from Dad's collection, but I don't have a defensive handgun, or a long range precision/hunting rifle, but then again, I don't see taking a shot over 200Y anyway, especially in the dense Maine woods, any hunting I do would be covered by a slug from a shotgun, or a heavy 60-something grain bullet from the AR

Right now, it's down to either a used Ruger #1 in 30-something or 45/70, or that nice classic Smith 686.....

Right now the 686 is in the lead, and I could eventually get a .357 Lever to go with it when finances permit, I think Dad would have approved of that plan
 
As you said, there is a need to be filled. You have other guns that dad left you but it was your dads. Weigh your choices carefully.

Hard to go wrong with a classic like a 686.
 
Last edited:
In my experience (only 7 years of gun "collecting") buy what you wont regret. There is always a practical choice but the difference between a right or wrong choice here is buyers remorse. I'm sure if you had it your way you would just buy all of them but that wouldnt be much fun...
 
Here's the thing, I never saw him shoot it, he never let me shoot it, in fact, I never knew he had it until a couple years ago when I unofficially inherited his collection, once I did shoot it, I immediately took a dislike to it for accuracy issues, and wanted to trade it for a Marlin 336, if it were mine to trade

Dad wasn't really a "gun guy", fishing was his true love, the only guns I EVER saw him use were the Ithaca 49 he taught me to shoot with, and his Ruger Single Six, which sits in a place of honor in my collection and will NEVER be sold or traded, the family Parker VH occupies a similar place of honor

Those guns have more happy memories associated with them than any of the other guns in his austere collection

The Winchester is just a plain old gun, nothing special, no family history like the Parker or the little Iver Johnson Safety Hammerless black powder .32 hidden in his sock drawer, or his beloved Single Six

Dad was a man of simple tastes and no pretenses, he adored the simple, basic reliable tools, single shot long arms, and revolvers, both single and double action

I'm sure if he were still with us, and he saw that 686, he would have come home with it, and would have set money aside for a matching .357 lever...

Hmm, perhaps at some point I should write a little story starring Dad's favorite guns...

I shudder to think what Dad would have thought if he saw me bring home an AR-15 ;) , he *really* disliked semiautos, He was most emphatically NOT an anti, mind you, he just preferred manual actions and singles, after all, he didn't like wasting ammo....
 
Last edited:
MacTech;

I have been in your situation myself, though not recently. Here's what a friend told me to do to help with these kind of decisions; Vow that you will abide by a coin flip, toss the quarter & then see how you feel about the result. If there's even the slightest regret that it came down the way it did, then go t'other way. Save for getting the other one another day.

Personally, I don't think you'd go wrong with either the 686, the 94-.30-30 (pre 64 of course), or the Ruger #1 in ought-6. Just buy the Ruger used & make sure it shoots before you lays yer nickel down & own it.

900F
 
Here's the thing, I never saw him shoot it, he never let me shoot it, in fact, I never knew he had it until a couple years ago when I unofficially inherited his collection, once I did shoot it, I immediately took a dislike to it for accuracy issues, and wanted to trade it for a Marlin 336, if it were mine to trade

Dad wasn't really a "gun guy", fishing was his true love, the only guns I EVER saw him use were the Ithaca 49 he taught me to shoot with, and his Ruger Single Six, which sits in a place of honor in my collection and will NEVER be sold or traded, the family Parker VH occupies a similar place of honor

Those guns have more happy memories associated with them than any of the other guns in his austere collection

The Winchester is just a plain old gun, nothing special, no family history like the Parker or the little Iver Johnson Safety Hammerless black powder .32 hidden in his sock drawer, or his beloved Single Six

Dad was a man of simple tastes and no pretenses, he adored the simple, basic reliable tools, single shot long arms, and revolvers, both single and double action

I'm sure if he were still with us, and he saw that 686, he would have come home with it, and would have set money aside for a matching .357 lever...

Hmm, perhaps at some point I should write a little story starring Dad's favorite guns...

I shudder to think what Dad would have thought if he saw me bring home an AR-15 ;) , he *really* disliked semiautos, He was most emphatically NOT an anti, mind you, he just preferred manual actions and singles, after all, he didn't like wasting ammo....
Who are you trying to convince- us or yourself?
 
At the LGS right now, the 686 is a 686-1, grips are date stamped 1986

Got a more than fair offer, enough to cover the price of the 686 and give me money back that I put into ammo....

I even found a set of speedloaders in my misc. gun stuff box at home, guess it was meant to be

And now my collection has no more trade fodder, yaay!

Edit again...
It's a 6" barrel with full under lug, leaf spring hammer spring the cylinder gap is exceptionally tight, no flame cutting on the top strap and the rifling is sharp and clean

Trigger pull in both SA and DA are absolutely stellar, the SA trigger breaks like a glass rod, and with a light touch, not a hair trigger as it does require an actual pull, but no grit, creep, or slop the DA trigger has a smooth, consistent pull, light enough to be easy, but with enough resistance to prevent negligent pulls, there's absolutely no grittiness, it's as smooth as glass

The heft and balance are perfect, if there's just one downside, it's that the factory wood grips are a hair too wide for my firing hand and the checkering is a tad on the aggressive side, no matter, a nice set of Hogue or Pachmayr rubber grips will solve that minor issue....
 
Last edited:
Went through a very similar process after my Dad died. The firearms that were special stayed, the rest went.

Only note I'd make is that Ruger No. 1s can be finicky due to the nature of the fore-end and how it attaches.
 
MacTech

Sounds like a definite win-win situation. You thinned the herd with a gun you were never really attached to and netted yourself a fine .357 revolver in the process.
 
MacTech;

Don't be too quick to go to the rubber grips. There's a fair amount of variation in the wood target grips & I'll bet if you go poke around at that gun show you might just find a pair that'll fit and look much better than rubber.

900F
 
TRX- you just added up about 250 bucks worth of stuff.. for a rifle he isnt very fond of it seems like that would be a bit of a waste unless he would be able to sell it for atleast that much more
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top