I used/owned quite a few handguns before getting a 1911, and I would say if had not been for that experience I would not be in love with my first 1911 now... you gotta know what crap is before you get something that isn't crap, otherwise you won't appreciate it, you'll take it for granted.
It's like owning a swiss watch when all you've ever owned was plastic digital watches and cheap reproductions. I mean sure the cheap plastic watch will tell time just fine, but... I had the same feeling when I first got a pocket watch, it's metal, it's well crafted, and it does a damn good job of keeping time in style.
My 1911 is well crafted, metal, and does a damn good job of keeping time in style.
Maybe I'm gushing a bit, or talking too much smack, but I'm in love with my 1911. I wouldn't say it will fit everyone's style, but it fit mine, and is in jeopardy of becoming a dangerous addiction.
Just, get what sounds like it would be fun, or cool, or whatever. Get a gun that fits your style, otherwise you may get a 1911 based on reviews from guys like me and it doesn't fit your style and you'll be wondering why the hell did I listen to that guy.
Just do what feels right. Like my buddy on the police force swears by glocks, loves his glock, it fits his style... that's cool, he likes plastic watches, I like plastic too, it's just not a crafted metal pocket watch. I'll never convince him otherwise, and he'll never convince me otherwise, we just have different taste.