how much is too valuable to use

Status
Not open for further replies.
It isn't a question of dollar value, but of how readily replicable an item is. I carry a Sebenza and use it very frequently. If I couldn't replace it readily I might have a point at which I'd decide to use it or not. OTOH, I have knives that are antique or vintage or unique that I would be reluctant to use because they can't be easily replaced. Their dollar value isn't the issue. The fact that they aren't replaceable is.
 
The knives that I have that are heirloom knives, there are 4, get used and carried. I cannot imagine what my response would have been if Dad had given them to me and told me to "look at them and then lock them up and never carry them", I would have been at a loss of words. Those 4 knives deserve better than that, they deserve to be use and fondled. I know days when I carry the Remington I will find my thumb running over the smooth bone scales and memories of the times I saw my father and grandfather using it will come back to me. Sadly I have no memories of my great grandfather, they tended to die young in the coal mines. That knife cut loose a bull and cowboy that managed to go down in a chute and get hung up pinning the cowboy down. It has been camping and hunting with me. It served in place of the Boy Scout knife I never owned because they were too expensive for an E-6 with three kids in the 60's.

This will be passed along to one of my nephews, I have one that is shaping up nicely as a knife person. With it will be a letter that will include all my memories of the knife...both my own as well as what I know from it's prior owners. And I will tell him a knife is meant to be used.
 
Out of curiosity what is ya'lls top dollar amount for a knife you would actually use for me personally I'd have to say $150 for a pocket knife and $250 for a fixed blade any more than that and I'd be too concerned with damage/loss to ever actually use the knife other than for specific occasions/family tradition

Just curious

What do you mean by use? Carry and cut with?

I have several knives that retail for $200-$450 that I carry and use.

Microtech Combat Troodon
Cold Steel Master Tanto
Bradley Mayhem balisong
Chili Brothers Habanera

Here are my non-balisong folders.

a689088c-17ad-f906.jpg
 
For me, it depends on the job. I don't have any knives for "display" or collecting purposes. But I do have quite a few of them and I select a knife based on the intended usage.

So the EDC for general duty won't be the one I carry for SD. Different tools for different jobs. The SD knives are almost never used unless by "use" you allow "carry."
 
I got a couple of dozen, some I made.
All get used except 2. My Randall my dad gave me when I went to viet nam and a Nazi Knife my Dad got at the battle of the bulge - took him until I was 40 and he was 70 to tell me the story
 
I don't have a knife i won't use, and i must have a hundred of them around... EXCEPT, this origional Samuri sward,

orig.jpg

My dad gave it to me long ago, and i guess i'll keep on keeping it, even though i don't use it, or even have a use for it.

DM
 
These knives are well over $600 each and I won't be carrying these

Please understand I am not flaming or being a smartass but I simply don't understand why a person would spend money on an object he wasn't going to use. If I owned a Holland & Holland I would shoot it, if I owned a Lamborghini I would drive it, if I married Salma Hayek ... well you get the idea. I can't understand why buy something just to lock it away behind glass or in a safe. To me the pleasure lies in using a finely crafted piece of gear for it's intended purpose.

Did you buy them as an investment hoping to sell them later for a profit? That I could almost understand tho most knives and guns appreciate very slowly unless the makers is famous and dies before his time, I own several Sid Birt's and his unexpected death did increase their value quickly but that is kind of a long shot.

Please enlighten me...
 
I try to not carry collector knives in very good condition that I have (Old Cases), or ones that are over $50.

I stick with a (very) cheap single, locking, SS blade, Pakistani job. Takes alot of beatings but works great and has never seriously let me down.
 

Attachments

  • DSC08995.jpg
    DSC08995.jpg
    217.3 KB · Views: 3
  • DSC08996.jpg
    DSC08996.jpg
    247.9 KB · Views: 3
My EDC knife is a one of kind custom by a friend of mine Harvey King. The knife cost me $200 or so I use it each and every day. Since I am a remodeling contractor I am using a knife almost constantly for something or other. If the utility knife is not within easy reach my Harvey always is. This knife has cut tar paper, shingels, carpet, sheetrock, laminate, split romex, stripped wire, you name it. I love this knife and don't feel a bit bad about the way I treat it. browningbdaedc004.jpg
 
The most expensive knife I used to carry was $600. Mammoth ivory and damascus blade. It's long since sold, unfortunately, but was carried daily. Little 2-3/4" folder. :)
 
I don't have a problem carrying what I buy. Just careful where I carry it. In 2009 when I deployed to Afghanistan, I was pretty minimal. I did not carry a knife I could not replace if I lost it. I didn't have any problems with what I took, but a lot of guys did.

1. The British handled the security at Kandahar Airfield for departing flights and were bad about confiscating anything they deemed as not military issue. One Canadian CIVPOL I worked with had a Kabar confiscated because he was not a Marine??? Seen similar happen several times. Getting in with something was no problem ~ leaving was. I mailed my Emerson folder and Swiss Army Knife home the day I left.

2. Our unit was a MTT Team (embedded trainers), and we were all issued the Benchmade Prisidio Automatics. I took my Emerson instead, which was not a problem. Our guys who did carry the Benchmades had memorandums on the automatics and had no problems. Without that, Customs would have confiscated everyone of them when they left.

3. I am also conscious about state and local laws when I travel.

To me its not so much about carrying the knife ($$$) as it is being able to do so without running into problems.
 
I am a very practical sort. I lost a $30-40.00 knife. It was replaced with a $4.00 liner lock from china that I used til I broke the clip off. It is my back up now for my replacement a much maligned S&W Extreme Ops that I paid $10.00. I have had it now for close to 4 years. It does everything I need it to do. Why should I spend more to get the same thing?
ll
 
I try to let all of my knives take a turn I'm the ol pocket. I tend to gravitate to my benchmades more often than not. The onslaught and LFTi are my 2 personal favorite EDCs. The only thing I cant stand is having a blade with a black finish that is all scratched and worn. My CRKT hissatsu is So scratched up that I'm actually embarrassed to show it to some people. I guess if it's a custom collectors knife, I can see the reason behind keeping it safe at home. My brother has a mint SOG desert dagger he Never uses. Because it took him forever to find one I'm perfect condition for a sane price
 
I am a very practical sort. I lost a $30-40.00 knife. It was replaced with a $4.00 liner lock from china that I used til I broke the clip off. It is my back up now for my replacement a much maligned S&W Extreme Ops that I paid $10.00. I have had it now for close to 4 years. It does everything I need it to do. Why should I spend more to get the same thing?
ll
This may sound funny. You don't tend to lose $300.00 knives.
 
I am a very practical sort. I lost a $30-40.00 knife. It was replaced with a $4.00 liner lock from china that I used til I broke the clip off. It is my back up now for my replacement a much maligned S&W Extreme Ops that I paid $10.00. I have had it now for close to 4 years. It does everything I need it to do. Why should I spend more to get the same thing?

Better steel? Smoother action? You just like carrying a nice knife? Part of it for me is the steel - nobody uses 52100 in a production knife. Another part is that I just like having a functional work of art.

James
 
I am a very practical sort. I lost a $30-40.00 knife. It was replaced with a $4.00 liner lock from china that I used til I broke the clip off. It is my back up now for my replacement a much maligned S&W Extreme Ops that I paid $10.00. I have had it now for close to 4 years. It does everything I need it to do. Why should I spend more to get the same thing?
ll
Plus have you ever cut a Fine Ribeye steak with a $300.00 Knife. I haven't used a steak knife in over two years. I always use my EDC. I am never embarrassed when I put out my knife to cut my steak in any restaurant.
 
The only knives I won't carry are the ones that don't do what they're supposed to.

I had a friend that bought a very expensive custom from a local maker, he needed something fixed on the sheath, the maker looked at the knive and smiled and said, finally....someone that uses one of my knives.

I have some knives that I wouldn't use because they were made to be pretty not used. They have paintings on the blades, or an etching on the handle.......but just wouldn't work for anything. It's more art than anything.

But if it's made to use, use it!
 
Losing Expensive Gear

This may sound funny. You don't tend to lose $300.00 knives.

Many years ago I had a problem with disappearing pens. You know, little BIC stick pens, or their Paper Mate equivalents. Your standard 25-cent pen (in 1975). I did all kinds of things, notches, special marks, initials. Pens would just walk off. People would claim that the pen they were using was theirs. The end of the pen would be missing, right where my notch or mark or initials would have been.

Yeah, I know. Stupid, really. Cheap pens. But still . . .

So one day I dug up my $5.00 Parker pen. It didn't match anything else on anyone else's desk. No amount of defacement would render it "plausibly common." It was strangely immune from "borrowing" and disappearance. It was always right where I left it.

But there was something else.

In those days, five bucks was a lot for a pen. That alone made people think twice. It was unique in that setting, which made it impossible to swipe, bite off the end, and shrug that "this one's mine." Yes, that was all good, and made it dramatically less likely that it would wander off.

The "something else," however, was in the way I regarded the pen. I'd spent real money on it, and I no longer left it casually lying around. I would no longer scribble some note and drop the pen on the desk. Now, it would go back in my pocket. Always. It didn't matter that it was now a low theft risk. It mattered that I placed more value on it.

Before long, I had switched from cheap writing
instruments of any kind to those more costly,
more durable, more valuable, and worth keeping
and caring for.
(I have a Parker 51, for those of
you who remember what that is.)​
parker51.jpg

It changed the way I shopped for a number of things, including knives. When I went shopping for the "gentleman's knife" to replace the SAK I was retiring, I didn't wander in and ask myself, "what knife can I buy that I won't mind losing?" Instead, the thinking was more along the lines of, "what can I afford that I'll be willing to carry from here on out?"

I broke the tip off that new knife (Gerber Silver Knight)in the first couple of months I had it. I took it back to the knife shoppe to see what could be done. The guy carefully ground and polished a new tip for me. If you don't hold it up next to a brand new one, you really can't tell that the point isn't the original.

And I still have that knife. Hey, in 1982, forty bucks was a meaningful amount of money.

Nowadays, when I shop for a knife, I try to get the best quality I can afford, rather than the best bargain available.

It's a lot easier to keep a knife when you actually value it.

That's my mileage. Yours may vary.

 
While I have some nice knives, I don't have any art knives per se. Every single one I own has been used or set aside for another person's use. Some people think it's crazy for using such expensive knives, but I my enjoyment comes from carrying and actually using it, not by looking at them from afar.

If I owned an Aston Martin DBS, I'd drive it.
If my girlfriend was a Victoria's Secret model, I'd do more than just look at her.
 
Carry and use an Elishewitz Ghost every day , it gets used like it supposed to , showed it to Allen at SHOT Show a few weeks ago , he smiled when he say the marks from useage. I guess the value on it new was about $500 or so..

I also have a couple custom fixed blades I rotate thru , between $400 and $550 , they get used all the same.

I won't buy it and not use it.

The one knife that I have the gets used very little is a Simonich Crowfoot that was ground by Rob himself , and not a mid-tech. For sentimental reasons , that one doesn't get used but twice each year , Robs birthday and the date he passed away.
 
Man you guys must be rich!!! haha I would say after 150$ I would be getting a little nervous. (but ive never paid that much for one) I think in the end it depends on how much money you make. 3 or 4 hundred dollar knife?!?!? that baby would be on my wall!!
 
Plus have you ever cut a Fine Ribeye steak with a $300.00 Knife. I haven't used a steak knife in over two years. I always use my EDC. I am never embarrassed when I put out my knife to cut my steak in any restaurant.

Thank the lord I am not the only one that does this. I does not bother me even a little bit. However it drives my wife nuts.

Man you guys must be rich!!! haha I would say after 150$ I would be getting a little nervous. (but I've never paid that much for one) I think in the end it depends on how much money you make. 3 or 4 hundred dollar knife?!?!? that baby would be on my wall!!
February 4, 2011 10:00 PM

Not at all I do want a quality. Just like my tools I buy the best tool that I can afford. I simply can't afford not to. I do custom remodeling and I demand a lot from my tools and my customers demand a lot of me. So buy the best that you can, take care of it, keep track of it, and it will give you years and years of flawless service.
 
so someone pays $500 for a handgun , maybe they use it once or twice a month at the range , I carry a knife and a 1911 daily , but I use my knife many many times a day , the 1911 will go days without being used.

So based on a per user basis , the knife is a better purchase .

I call it "smiles per dollar".

Although I don't carry a cell phone , smart phone , blackberry , drive a new car ( mine is 1986 ) or spend $$$ on fancy dinners ( now there is a waste - literally :) ).

Put your money in what is important to you , afterall it's you money. Me , if I buy something it is getting used , no room for wall hangers.
 
Price is subjective

This is my EDC


I have ran through alot of knives over the years......I EDC that one for daily-But when I travel out in the woods I tend to leave that at home and carry a microtech troodon in wharncliffe blade config..
 

Attachments

  • WH6-Final.jpg
    WH6-Final.jpg
    175.9 KB · Views: 4
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top