I don't judge by the gun much really. I have hunted with all sorts of people from every type of economic situation, city and country boys, etc. I can pretty much gauge if I want to hunt with them as soon as the gun is out of the case. My favorite hunting partner has a nice but well worn Remmington 870. Good gun handler and quick wits. And he hunts deer with a 6.8 AR. I've also hunted with a guy that had a $1800 Berreta Silver Pigeon (engraving, gold inlays, the whole deal). WORST gun handler I've ever seen. Needless to say, I don't hunt with him anymore...
In Missouri we can basically kill one buck with a gun, one with a bow, and unlimited does in the northern part of the state. I use a M94 for a woods gun, a Savage .243 for open areas, but I prefer a bow
. I have hunted with my SKS before and lend it out for friends, but it weighs a ton and is about as accurate as the M94.
The above preferred hunting partner mostly drives deer out of thickets in his camp, so he has an AR with a low power scope. He killed three deer in 3 minutes last year! Downed the buck, then had two does run by. Doe one was shot at about 8 yards, doe two at about 50. So a quick semi-auto makes a difference around his area.
Now, I do judge a hunter by what he carrys
While squirrel hunting earlier this year, I noticed my friends pack looked a little heavy. Asked him what was in it; only 40 rounds of ammo, 2 liters of water and rope! Apparently he expected too run into a trap range! I had about 5 shells, a lighter, and a pair of gloves in addition to a Camel Back...
HB