Hunting for a new Rifle (~$500). Opinions Welcome (Long Post)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
8
Location
Texas
Howdy yall. Been a long-time lurker, first time posters.

I've found myself with about $100 in Academy (a local sports & outdoors store, which sells firearms) gift-cards from Christmas, and so I thought I'd treat myself to a nice post-Christmas gift, since the GF got me a nice watch instead of something truly useful :p (but don't tell her that). Anyhow, I've gotten myself into a bit of a stink about what kind of new rifle I want to pick up.

A bit about my hunting life:
I live in South-Central Texas and do a lot of deer hunting, with the odd exotic every once in a while. I go hog hunting pretty often, though varmints (ringtails, coons, squirrels, yotes, neighbor's cats, etc) are statistically what gives up the ghost most often when the trigger gets squeezed. I do quite a bit of plinking, though it's usually just the sparrow-game, or random plinking, but I always use the .22lr's for that. The places that I hunt offer no more than ~500yrd shots, other than one property's 900yrd field which never has much traffic, so we use it only for the rare friendly competition when someone wants to see who's hands shake less.

Shooting style:
Definitely not a spray-n-pray'er; I prefer the longer shots requiring accuracy over squirting mass volumes of lead. I haven't ever burnt out a barrel before (usually upgrade my rifles LONG before I ever have a chance to; most of my guns haven't gotten to 1000+rds, besides my AR's). I do not rely on "stopping power"; have always stressed shot placement (friends call me the HSK, head-shot-king. Though I'm quite adept at hitting other vitals). One-shot-one-kill has always been my modus operandi. Even though I prefer smaller, fast, flat-shooting rounds, high-caliber heavy recoil doesn't bother me in the slightest. I'll shoot a 50BMG with the same gusto as I'll shoot a 7.62.

Stock preference:
If it's wood, I generally like to refinish them myself to something pretty (I can't afford those guns that come new with a hand-rubbed oiled stock of flamed walnut, so I usually have to do it myself lol). Synthetic doesn't bother me in the slightest, since my guns do see some hard treatment (never found any joy in benchrest shooting, other than zeroing in), and lightweight is nice for when I'm out prowling about and shooting offhand-nonsupported.

Tinkering:
Definitely no stranger to R&R'ing guns. I love refinishing or installing altogether different stocks, doing trigger jobs, and making upgrades in general. I wouldn't mind building my own from scratch, but I'm not going to invest in all the other specialty tools I'd need (I have all the tools to build ARs, but that's where I cut myself off). Basically I prefer guns that have an aftermarket (unlike my Savage AXIS, which is a superb cheap MOA rifle, there's just nothing you can do with it besides doing a trigger job or replacing it with a basix/timney).

Debates:
I believe in frugality, but also love to try something new. Which means I don't necessarily mind buying a new caliber, so long as it's not inherently expensive (ie, I shoot a lot and HATE spending more than $25/box-of-20), though I definitely don't mind picking up a new gun in a caliber I already have another gun in.

I do not reload/handload (I know... No need to even bother preaching to me. Some day I'll do the smart thing), so the idea of sharing common ammunition between a variety of guns is very appealing to me (I currently use 17hmr, 22lr/mag, 223/5.56, 270, & 30-06 between about 15 different guns).

A quick note to the magnum-itus/30cal+ only crowd (not hating, just never had a legitimate need for one) to take out a hog, deer, or the like, you need not make that recommendation to me. I take game and varmint all the time with relatively small, fast, flat-shooting calibers. I tend to think I have the opposite of magnum-itus; I like taking out the critters with a single shot from a smaller caliber to highlight what accuracy, velocity, and shot-placement can do. At the appropriate range respective of caliber of course. I haven't met a bigger-game quadruped I couldn't take out with my 270 up to 500yrds yet. Though if Texas had bear or moose, I might then see the need for it.

Anyhow, some of the guns I've been debating with has been the Rem 700 ADL, T/C Venture, Howa Lightning, Tika T3 Lite, & Ruger M77. And no idea on what caliber I want just yet (if anyone wants to venture a caliber I might like, or tell me to keep up with the ammo-sharing method, feel free! Same for gun recommendations).

I was initially leaning towards the 700 in .308 because of their huge aftermarket and it'd be interesting to see how the .308 hangs with the rest of my calibers (besides being relatively cheap). But, I've heard the build quality of the 700 has gone down the toilet recently, and getting a gun that'll do 3" groups out of the box is hard. So now I'm thinking maybe not. If Savage can make the AXIS a MOA for $300 (reliably. I mean, mine does sub-MOA) out of box, I don't see why the legendary 700 should preform any less for more money. So now, I'm entirely open to suggestions.

Anyhow, sorry for rambling on and writing a novel. Just wanted to answer any questions I could think of before hand for anyone who's interested to read it. I guess I can sum it up quickly here:

Which Gun?:
~$500ish
Bolt-Action
No stock preference
Has an Aftermark

Weigh in:
Get a caliber I already have, or try something fun and new?
If new caliber, what's good and "cheap"? (220 swift, 22-250, 25-06, etc.)

Thanks a lot yall!
 
Hill Country hogs hate .308. Academy once sold their monarch .308 for $7 a box last year. Ask academy what their warranty policy is for a remington 700 that shoots 3" out of the box, pretty sure they would send it in if you got a lemon. Remington 700 ADL should shoot 1" or better and Remington is still putting out good guns.
 
I see a gap you need to fill. A Vanguard in .257 Weatherby would fill it. The ammo cost would be the only sore point. Might get you to reload faster though.
 
Buy reloading gear. You already have plenty of rifles.

Too many guns? Blasphemy! Lol. Well my horrible little secret is that I already have access to all the gear, and would just need the dies to start reloading. I save almost all my brass, and will probably start one day, but it's a "science" I haven't cared to take the time to learn yet. And from what I've heard from friends who reload, with how the prices were about a year ago for reloading all the super common calibers I have, the price saving would be almost negligible for someone like me. I doubt I shoot more than 200 of each caliber I have a year, besides my 17hmr (which is rimfire, so I can't reload those anyways), and my crate of 10k steel case 5.56s (got at a phenominal price of about $0.10/rd a few years ago).

Hill Country hogs hate .308. Academy once sold their monarch .308 for $7 a box last year. Ask academy what their warranty policy is for a remington 700 that shoots 3" out of the box, pretty sure they would send it in if you got a lemon. Remington 700 ADL should shoot 1" or better and Remington is still putting out good guns.

I think hogs hate me more than whatever caliber I'm using haha. In particular they loath my 5.56's from my ARs.

As far as Academy's warranty is concerned, for firearms it's non-existent. Once it's sold, there are no returns, you have to go through the manufacturer, which is a giant PITA that I'd rather avoid if possible. If they did returns, shoot, I'd have no problem returning 20 of them until I got the golden egg!

Like I said, I originally thought the 700 was what I wanted (based on a legacy for a great gun), but the accounts of how their newer products the past couple of years has been hit and miss has concerned me. Might have to try and hear more about it.

I see a gap you need to fill. A Vanguard in .257 Weatherby would fill it. The ammo cost would be the only sore point. Might get you to reload faster though.

Ouch. I just looked, and on paper the 257wby looks pretty sweet (though very similar to my 270, except ~250fps faster), but hot damn you magnum guys want blood and gold for your ammo. It's a little over 2x as expensive per box as my 270, and I can't see much that it'll do better other than burn barrels faster. I'd say if I was doing moose or bear, I'd definitely take a look at the 257wby and 7rm. And if it was my only gun, I'd definitely be reloading it! Lol
 
And on the note of Academy, I just went there about an hour ago. They're dang near sold out of everything! Only thing I could find was a 700 SPS Tactical in 223 for $519. Not really all that fond of floor plate on the SPS (so I figured I'd just save some money and get an ADL, and do a DBM once I replace the stock eventually), or of the short "tactical" 20" bull barrel... If I was going to do the SPS Tactical, I think I'd want it in 308 (which is sold out everywhere apparently).
 
Weatherby Vangaurd 2 7mm-08. Great rifle with MOA guaranty,excellent customer service. 7mm-08 will do anything. 308 will do with less recoil. Downside is the Vanguard is not a light rifle. Savage in same caliber may also be had with Nikon in package for similar price.
 
And on the note of Academy, I just went there about an hour ago. They're dang near sold out of everything! Only thing I could find was a 700 SPS Tactical in 223 for $519. Not really all that fond of floor plate on the SPS (so I figured I'd just save some money and get an ADL, and do a DBM once I replace the stock eventually), or of the short "tactical" 20" bull barrel... If I was going to do the SPS Tactical, I think I'd want it in 308 (which is sold out everywhere apparently).

You're like a deer in the headlights. You're all over the place. You don't know what you want, you just want to spend some money. Take the $500 and buy some good glass.
 
I just bought a Savage Model 11 Hog Hunter in .308. You may want to check it out.
 
You're like a deer in the headlights. You're all over the place. You don't know what you want, you just want to spend some money. Take the $500 and buy some good glass.

Haha, so true! You're not the only person who's told me that. But hey, at least I try to "look before I leap". And that's the point of this thread, trying to find exactly what it is I want lol.

I already have the funds for glass for whatever rifle I get. Probably get another vortex diamondback. Maybe a viper if I'm feeling froggy.

I just bought a Savage Model 11 Hog Hunter in .308. You may want to check it out.

Funny you should mention that, I just started looking at the Savage 10,11,110,111 series, and am really liking what people are saying about them compared to the competition for that price point. And if the AXIS's I've owned were any indication of the build quality of even their low-end products, I'm thinking the mid-range might be pretty decent.
 
Buy a Savage in .243, .260, 7-08, .308, or .338 Federal, if you can't be convinced to start reloading. But if you buy anything but a .243 or .308 and don't reload, you'll shortly be reloading for it.

Reloading makes your ammo available for you when you want it, as opposed to when the store gets a shipment. Reloading tailors your ammo for your rifle, as opposed to taking whatever median load that should work in anything the factory makes.

U.S. factory ammo may be the best in the world for factory ammo, but my Savage .243 shoots lights out with my handrolled ammo, and I spend 1/4 the amount of money factory loads cost making them.

$500 will buy a pile of reloading equipment and supplies.
 
I have an RRA semi-auto in .308, and a Savage bolt in .308. I love them. the .308 seems to always do the job, it's accurate, easy on the shoulder for us old guys, and the variety of ammo seems endless.
 
A savage in 308 or a 25.06 is also a good round. The 270 you have is a good gun to load for it has a large range of bullets weight. That is a plus for you. BUY your self reloading equipment and powder primers. GOOD LUCK
 
Who the heck are you to shoot someone's cat? Do you even care what pain you are causing people? My wife will grieve for a year over a lost cat. People like you give gun owners a bad name friend. If they're causing problems, you have tried to deal with the cat's owner and that owner fails to make changes then maybe but to just shoot one? It's no wonder the gun grabbers think we're all animals.

My father taught me to never shoot anything that wasn't a real nuisance or something I intended to eat. Believe it or not almost all shooters live by a moral code. Every time you kill a cat you create an anti-gun voter. Plus it's just flat wrong to shoot something for no reason.
 
Last edited:
Oh geez. I suspect there might have been a bit of tongue-in-cheek there re the cat thing. The OP seems very informed, very knowledgeable and there's not likely to be much more that he's going to learn from the internet unwashed (I didn't shave today either).
But a Tikka T3 in .308 seems like a price/performance leader for his use. And there's the option down the road of putting some new stock/chassis on the thing. They just seem to be incredibly well made, accurate and cost-effective. It's a new cartridge for the OP, but not a pricey one.
GL with the hunt. For the rifle that is.
B
 
Who the heck are you to shoot someone's cat? Do you even care what pain you are causing people? My wife will grieve for a year over a lost cat. People like you give gun owners a bad name friend. If they're causing problems, you have tried to deal with the cat's owner and that owner fails to make changes then maybe but to just shoot one? It's no wonder the gun grabbers think we're all animals.

My father taught me to never shoot anything that wasn't a real nuisance or something I intended to eat. Believe it or not almost all shooters live by a moral code. Every time you kill a cat you create an anti-gun voter. Plus it's just flat wrong to shoot something for no reason.
Whoa there sea-biscuit. I realize tone is hard to infer from text, but maybe you should take my old pawpaw's advice, "Think before you open that big yap of yours".

If we're going to start throwing around "you people's", non-reasonable hot headed people like you are the exact kind of people higher-functioning shooters like me (who's moral code is a rock solid foundation the likes of which you evidently couldn't imagine) roll our collective eyes.

As B!ngo said, and as I intended my post to imply, I did have a fair bit of tongue-in-cheek humor in my post. I like to try to keep folks grinning through my habitually long winded ramblings.

I forgive your impertinence, but don't appreciate being lambasted for such inanities. Anyhow, buck on topic!
 
Cats without collars get shot around here. They're called feral. Close kin to groundhogs, crows, and coyote.
 
Buy a Savage in .243, .260, 7-08, .308, or .338 Federal, if you can't be convinced to start reloading. But if you buy anything but a .243 or .308 and don't reload, you'll shortly be reloading for it.

Reloading makes your ammo available for you when you want it, as opposed to when the store gets a shipment. Reloading tailors your ammo for your rifle, as opposed to taking whatever median load that should work in anything the factory makes.

U.S. factory ammo may be the best in the world for factory ammo, but my Savage .243 shoots lights out with my handrolled ammo, and I spend 1/4 the amount of money factory loads cost making them.

$500 will buy a pile of reloading equipment and supplies.

Yes, I'm definitely looking very closely at the Savage Trophy Hunter XP rifles in now. And I think I'm leaning about 90% towards 308, since it's a cheaper caliber I don't already have, and it gives me a huge variety of rifles to build for since I like keeping ammo available for multiple rounds. Who knows, maybe I'll take the east bloc's bait and finally build an AK down the road after I stock up some 308 lol.

And I agree whole heartedly about the benefits of reloading/hand-loading. I have to leave some project for when all of our favorite guns become banned and we can't buy them any more :p

A savage in 308 or a 25.06 is also a good round. The 270 you have is a good gun to load for it has a large range of bullets weight. That is a plus for you. BUY your self reloading equipment and powder primers. GOOD LUCK

Thanks AABEN. I'll get around to it some day!

I have an RRA semi-auto in .308, and a Savage bolt in .308. I love them. the .308 seems to always do the job, it's accurate, easy on the shoulder for us old guys, and the variety of ammo seems endless.

Which Savage do you own? I have the AXIS, and like it reasonably enough, but am still looking into which of the middle-range (pricewise) I might want.

You need a .30-.30. Everybody needs a .30-.30. Plus you probably have the cowboy hat and boots to make it feel authentic.

I actually do have two 30-30's, guess I forgot to put it on the list. I have an old bolt-action Stevens 325 (which I actually just did a quick and dirty stock restoration on), and a lever-action Marlin 30AS (which I like for when I go hunting up in Michigan and need a decent brush gun).

And how'd you know about my hat and boots? Lol

Who the heck are you to shoot someone's cat? Do you even care what pain you are causing people? My wife will grieve for a year over a lost cat. People like you give gun owners a bad name friend. If they're causing problems, you have tried to deal with the cat's owner and that owner fails to make changes then maybe but to just shoot one? It's no wonder the gun grabbers think we're all animals.

My father taught me to never shoot anything that wasn't a real nuisance or something I intended to eat. Believe it or not almost all shooters live by a moral code. Every time you kill a cat you create an anti-gun voter. Plus it's just flat wrong to shoot something for no reason.

Only cats I really shoot are bobcats, and the feline's close kin, ringtails. Or if someone needs a dirty deed done and can't afford a vet, I offer a quick and painless $0.50 injection :p

Oh geez. I suspect there might have been a bit of tongue-in-cheek there re the cat thing. The OP seems very informed, very knowledgeable and there's not likely to be much more that he's going to learn from the internet unwashed (I didn't shave today either).
But a Tikka T3 in .308 seems like a price/performance leader for his use. And there's the option down the road of putting some new stock/chassis on the thing. They just seem to be incredibly well made, accurate and cost-effective. It's a new cartridge for the OP, but not a pricey one.
GL with the hunt. For the rifle that is.
B

Thanks for the vote of confidence!

Any particular Tikka T3? I saw ONE at Academy, though it kind of looked like like a youth model with speckled black synthetic stock for around ~$600. Care to wage in how the Tikka compares to the Savage 11 (so far my only other real contender that people keep mentioning)? I definitely do like the fact that you said you can put a different stock on it. Always been a sucker for the thumbhole varmint laminates varieties.

And like you said, the 308 is appealing because it is a new caliber for me, relatively cheap, and there's a lot of other good rifles out there I can build for once I bite the bullet and buy one to start stocking up ammo for.
 
Any particular Tikka T3? I saw ONE at Academy, though it kind of looked like like a youth model with speckled black synthetic stock for around ~$600. Care to wage in how the Tikka compares to the Savage 11 (so far my only other real contender that people keep mentioning)? I definitely do like the fact that you said you can put a different stock on it. Always been a sucker for the thumbhole varmint laminates varieties.

And like you said, the 308 is appealing because it is a new caliber for me, relatively cheap, and there's a lot of other good rifles out there I can build for once I bite the bullet and buy one to start stocking up ammo for.
Being an avid shooter of both let me chime in.
Accuracy: both are accurate out the box, but in my experience the Tikka is accurate with a wider variety of factory ammo then the Savages which can be a bit fussy. With handloads they will both shoot remarkably well.
Customizing: the Savage has the advantage in simplicity if you ever want to tweek a rifle the Savage is KING. Easy barrel nut design combined with a VERY strong aftermarket makes for the perfect storm of DIY custom.
Trigger: I like the feel and break of the Tikka trigger better then the Accutrigger, but the difference between them is splitting hairs they are both great.
Stock: Big advantage for the Tikka, high end fiberglass reinforced composite vs mold injection is no contest. If you are talking hardwood the Savage looks better but the Tikka feels better to me.
Action: The Tikka is hands down the smoothest in the industry at any price, but the Savage does have a nice firm feel. Another thing to consider is that on my Tikka at the range I have to look to see if it is cambering a round since it is so smooth I cannot feel it chamber (yes I am OCD like that) Not an issue in the field since I can hear it slide out of the magazine.
Recoil pad: Savage! Without a doubt Savage wins that one hands down, my 111 came with the best recoil pad of any rifle I have ever owed and the Tikka feels like it has a chunk of mud tire bolted to the back, good thing it is a sissy kicking 6.5x55 not a 300 mag or I would have to go looking for an aftermarket one.
Overall I like the Tikka better and my brother likes my Savage better.
 
I bought a Howa 1500 in .308 win, it is a 18 inch heavy barrel with synthetic stock, shoots well and if I had any complaint about the platform it would be the stock [needs to be a bit stiffer in the forearm area]. Same rifle as weatherby vangard without the name. Tunable trigger and more accurate than most people me especially lol. Stocks and triggers are available in the aftermarket and .308 is a good all around ctg. Just one opinion.
 
Get a Savage package gun model 10 in 260 Remington...Upgrade scope when you can. Keep an eye on Gunbroker ect for a used wooden stock to refinish. If you find you don't like the 260 Remington you can sell that barrel and get some different 243, 260,7-08,308, 338 federal or even the 358 Winchester,,, Savages are a tinkers dream
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top