I have a compelling urge for a hammerless J-frame...

Status
Not open for further replies.
browningguy - I LOVE those grips! drool-drool :eek:

To the OP, how about something a bit more vintage???
Here's my 1969-1970 Model 38

M38-c.jpg
 
Don't let the lock dissuade you. It takes less than 15 minutes to remove it. Google it. There are multiple videos out there on how to do it.

Jim
So far my practice .38, a 642 J, has gone through maybe 2000 rounds. The lock has not been any problem and the gun runs fine.

Deaf
 
So far my practice .38, a 642 J, has gone through maybe 2000 rounds. The lock has not been any problem and the gun runs fine.

Deaf
The issue was with some of the first ones built and it only happened with people using hot loads, IIRC. IMHO it needs to go away if there is even the SLIGHTEST chance the gun could lock itself when it is most needed.

Jim
 
642. I've carried mine for most of a decade, almost every day. The finish is uglee now. But I can't imagine a better pocket gun. Reliable, accurate, no rust, light so it doesn't drag down my jammies. I even shoot it now and again in our club matches instead of a bigger gun.

I always come in close to last when I do that, but I get through the stages just fine.
 
^^^Ha! I've shot a number of classes with snubs or a P238 pocket auto. I don't think I've ever impressed anyone, including myself, but I always make it through fine. Better to know what's what in advance of need, I say.

Re, the lock: so long as no lock 442 and 642 are still easily found, it's probably a debate not worth having. Maybe later, so far as snubs, but not at the current time.

And, Hondo, I love it. I've got a 36, a 12 and a P n R 13 to hold down the blue and walnut end of things. I'm not opposed to matt black for this one.

I'm really leaning towards a 442, just cause I've never had one.
 
You can't go wrong with any of these fine quality choices. I loved my 642, but wanted the ability to take a single action shot if needed so I went with the 638 with the shrouded hammer.
 
I've carried a 442 for four years on my ankle and a 642 in the winter jacket pocket for three seasons. Great guns, not too heavy, I've practiced a lot and never had a problem. Watch out for the ammo, though, as I've read (from Mas Ayoob and others) that the +P load can push a bullet, especially RN, out of an unfired cartridge far enough to prevent the cylinder from turning. I use the Buffalo Bore +P 158 semi-wadcutter hollow point to prevent that...hopefully.
 
I have a 342 Airlite-Ti. It's rated for +P ammo in .38 spl. I mention this only to say that ever since I installed Crimson Trace grips on it, it is much much more pleasant to shoot. There is no reason to fear a lightweight .38 spl +P J-frame.
 
I had a 442?...not sure now of the designation, but it was very light, looked like a 442 only with a barrel almost 3" with XS sights. It was very accurate with some cheap WWB at 15 yds. I thought it was a very good shooter for DAO. Like a dope I sold it....geez, how many times have I kicked myself over selling a very nice gun!!! Now I carry a S&W 638-3 outfitted with a laser grip. My favorites to shoot though are my 2 Ruger SP-101's. One is 3", with XS sights, the other is 2"....comfy with 357's.
 
I appreciate all the input, folks. The bottom line on the thread is that I stopped by my friendly LGS today, and lo and behold, they had a new no-lock 642. That, plus a couple of 50-round boxes of 129gr +P Hydra shok, of all things. Suffice to say, it was an easy sale for them.
:D
 
Best price is your own reloads!

For those of you who think they can't do it, it's really not hard once you get the hang of it.
Reloading manuals are your best friend!

Lyman 49th Reloading Handbook is the perfect place to start.
 
I'm not searching. I don't even have a gun that shoots them. I'm just considering.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top