I need some good advice. Sell or keep 45acp

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a rule: never sell a gun that you like. Every gun I've ever sold has been because I didn't like something about it.

If you still like your .45, then keep it. Selling off a gun because you got one in another chambering makes no sense to me anyways. Variety is the spice of life.
 
Part of your problem is you are doing two things at once: you're changing calibers and you are adding a new pistol. When I got my HK 45C, I also had my long time Colt Series 70 1911. So when the HK arrived, it sort of became like a little brother to the elder 1911.

I also have have thoughts of getting a 9mm. But if and when I do, it will NEVER bust up the .45 brothers!

Lou
 
It sounds like I am getting solid advice. That is what I needed. I don't need money to fund this idea. Just that I don't shoot the 45 like I use to. And I guess its like getting a new toy. When I got my 9mm, I just was a big kid in a toy store.
I will keep my 45, look for a quality ccw 45 and just enjoy my 9mm. I do agree that if I had to choose, the 45 would what I would want backing me up.
Thanks gunners for helping me.
I understand where you're coming from - my Browning HP is loads of fun to rip off a few mags' worth when I'm out plinking. 9mm is a very easy round to learn to shoot quickly! Still, when the rubber hits the road, I always pack a heavier caliber (.357mag, .44spl, or .45ACP).
 
"...replacing my 8-round .45 with a 16 round 9mm..." You really think the mag capacity matters? "I want one." is the only reason you need.
bikerdoc's right, but it's not Rule Number 6. snicker.
 
Whose going to buy your reloads? components yeah but reloads? I wouldn't. Other than that I'd say sell if you want, life's too short to stand Pat with firearms you don't want anymore.
 
If you have a good running 45 that you like you would be CRAZY to let it go. And you will regret it after a while.
I really like Glocks, but I still like to take the old Colts out to play now and then. Just something about them that feels good in your hand.
 
Step down to a 9mm from a .45 ACP? Never no way nohow. Put that crack pipe down man.
 
Keep the .45
Buy a Witness (or other pistol) with a caliber swapping kit.
Go 9mm AND .45!
Or 9mm AND 22
Or 9 and 40
Or 22 and 45

IDIC- infinite diversity/infinite combinations
 
NO! Part of the fun of gun ownership is accumulating guns. Now you have an excuse to get another one.

Here is what will happen: You'll have the affair with 9mm. You'll shot it quite a bit and whatnot. The, one day, you'll decide you need your 45. If it's not there, you'll have to buy another.

ASK ME HOW I KNOW!

The good news is the 1911 platform has been adapted to 9mm. There are several you can get (plus the 1911-like EMP).
 
Unless you are desperate for money, hate the gun, or have a lucrative offer, or some other extraordinary reason, never sell your guns or ammo.

If you sell it on a whim, you'll take a loss and regret it. You'll really take a hit on the reloads, maybe get 10 cents per round because nobody wants someone else's reloads.

If you are intent, a trade will net more value. Trade it for something you want. You'll be net = guns, maybe come out ahead.

The consensus from hundreds of years of combined experience here will overwhelming say keep it - especially a 1911 in .45. It's an iconic and excellent pistol. As others said, they take up little space, and are easy to maintain. Also great to use to train yourself and others on a different platform.

Clearly you know the merits of the 1911 and .45 as you have owned, shot, and reloaded for decades....

Also consider this. Let's say you need a backup gun for a spouse, one breaks, or you lose or have one of yours stolen or it's used in a home defense shooting and is confiscated as evidence - you have an instant replacement.

Guns are fascinating tools - affordable life savers. When you need one, you need one. No time to go to the store, fill out paperwork, etc.

Hold onto it, wipe it with oil, put it away. I nearly guarantee that in a year or five, you'll pull it out and be happy you kept it. The $500-700 or so you could get for it and the ammo would likely have quickly been spent on things you'll have long forgotten when that day comes.

But again, having said all that, if you are set on giving up the .45 if I were you I'd trade the entire setup rather than sell. You can almost certainly get a favorable trade deal into a gun and ammo of your choice, especially from reloaders in your area.
 
Last edited:
Sell the 45 and get a 9mm. I recently selected the SIG P239 for conceal carry.

The 1911 is heavy and large gun to carry whereas there are many different models and sizes of 9mm's to choose from. Contrary to the rest of the group I don't carry my 1911's and very much enjoy the smaller size, weight and less recoil of a sub- compact of 9mm's. There are dozens of 1911 manufacturers in all price ranges available.

However keep the ammo. It is good for many years, will come in handy if you get another 45 and will make good barter when the next Banic strikes.
 
Last edited:
I really haven't shot my 45's much in the last year. That said, selling them never entered my mind.
I go thru phases. Some calibers I may not shoot for 6 months. Then all of the sudden I'll pick them up again. I sold all my 9mm's except my sub compact a year or so ago. Guess what, I'm back to having 4 9mm's......lol.
 
I love both calibers (.45 and 9mm.), and all the guns they're chambered in, and wouldn't sell one over the other. Keep your 1911 (even if you needed the money to finance another 9mm.), and enjoy shooting both.
 
The 9x19 is the most popular pistol cartridge for a reason. Don't ask me what it is because I don't know. :D I only have one pistol cartridge. If it wasn't 45 ACP it would be 10mm.:eek:
 
Don't sell, I tried going all 9mm several years ago and it just didn't work, before long I was back to the .45. I still have and shoot a couple of 9s but much prefer the .45. Plus, it's much easier (and cheaper) to hold on to all that .45 stuff than it will be to get it all back again later.
 
I'm sure you're not a fortune teller, but...

I'd have to ask you to sincerely ask yourself if you would ever regret getting out of .45 completely. The cost to buy back in will be greater than what you receive on the way out.
 
I've been around the block, it's an expensive ride. I have nothing but .45acp's now and am completely satisfied....Oh the money that could've been saved had I not wandered.... :(
 
If money ($) is NOT an issue, then keep the .45 by all means. It will be waiting patiently in the safe for you to come to your senses once again.

I do not subscribe to the 'never sell a gun' school of thought. As mgmorden posted above, if you do not like a firearm, then sell it if you can for a reasonabe price. I have also sold guns I liked, but that were doubles of others, or were wanted by a friend who could put them to better use than I. That money went back into my shooting pasttime, or even bought my wife a set of new tires for her car, and I never lost any sleep over it.

My firearm collection is an ever changing (and usually growing) thing. That is part of the enjoyment. Having said all of that, there are SOME firearms that I have no intention of ever selling at any price - I just like them too darn much and they would be too difficult to replace. Still, come to think of it, at the right price ...
 
You have too much time and energy invested to sell it and give up on .45 now...

Besides, the 9x19 and .45 ACP are different enough that they cancel out each others strengths and weaknesses. If you keep both, they will fill almost any role...
.....40 S&W on the other hand...... :)
 
You need something different. But don't go backwards with 9mm, go forward with 10mm instead.

1911 has great ergos. But it is limited on rounds. So get a 1911 with a double stack 10mm such as the Dan Wesson Titan

There are quite a few other single stack 10mm 1911's to choose from as well.

If you want something different, EAA makes CZ clones in 10mm as well.

The 1911 is an incredible gun. You just need to mix it up some. But never sell them. You will regret it within minutes.
 
.
I am thinking about getting rid of all the 45 stuff and go with the 9mm.

Having read no replies in this thread I will still add my opinion:

BLASPHEME!


lol.

The ONLY handgun caliber worth having is .45ACP.

I've never! ever been interested in anything chambered in 9. Never saw the point of it. I have been afflicted with this opinion since birth, and there's nothing anyone can do about it. The best doctors... *sigh*

*grabs the popcorn*


:)
 
I'm a .45 guy and don't even own a 9mm or a 40 cal anymore, but this
The ONLY handgun caliber worth having is .45ACP.
is just a nonsense statement. There are several other effective cartridges out there that offer benefits over, and some detracting factors below, the .45 acp. It's a matter of preference and your ability to control a particular cartridge, in a particular gun.

I've never! ever been interested in anything chambered in 9. Never saw the point of it.

You are projecting your own interests on to others and completely neglecting the fact that many of us have interest in all guns and cartridges. Granted, some cartridges do some things better than others, if looking at measurable criteria. But your "interest" have nothing to do with the original poster's interests.

I have no need of a .357 Sig, or a .44 magnum, and I think there are other cartridges that do things better than both, but I'm still interested in those two cartridges, and may buy firearms chambered for them as funds become available.

I know the comments were made light heartedly, but ignoring options make no sense.
 
.
The next auto pistol I bring home will be a .22LR. It's the Commander-(proportion) Browning 1911-22.

Yes, my comments were made lightheartedly, but there are others that also feel that way about .45ACP.

Thanks for your post, Kodiak.
 
I would say ditch the .45 ACP except for one thing- the fact that you're already reloading for it. The price of ammo is the only issue I have with the .45 ACP. But if you already have a lot of brass, the dies, etc I say just get a set of dies for the 9mm and keep both. The 9mm will be cheaper to load but you can still crank out some forty five to plink with, too.

FWIW I decided to get out of .45 ACP once, too. But then I got an HK USC it pulled me back in!:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top