Interesting CLP test video

[mcb]

CLP (Clean, Lubricate and Protect) products always seem to be a highly debated topic here. This video does some interesting testing on common gun CLP products.



I have been following this channel for several years. He usually focuses more on tools and building products but he has good well thought out if a bit "farmer-engineered" test setups and his results seem to hold up to my own real world use and testing. Thought you guys might like to see it. -enjoy!

 

[243winxb]

Break Free CLP #1 in my testing. But Browning shotgun ejectors were glued in place, while in storage , using it.
WD-40 was used to break them free on 12,20, 28 & the 410.

 

[Gtscotty]

Project Farm is a YouTube channel that tests all kinds of tools and equipment. I've been impressed over the years with the creator's impartiality, attention to detail and methodical test methods. Anyway, he just posted up a video on CLPs for guns that is pretty good, even though my preferred Slip2000 didn't do the best.

 

[ericuda]

Interesting view. Like the guy he does tests from this to adjustable wrenches. He is quick and doesn't beat any aspect to death as most reviewers do.

 

[Pew-Pew]

I have been using CLP for years

 

[mcb]

Definitely some confirmation bias on my part posting the video as I have been using Break-Free CLP for nearly everything for the past 20 years. It's affordable and works well and easy to find.

 

[Ramone]

I follow Project Farm, too, though I haven't watched that one yet. I really like that their videos are information dense, without a lot of filler and chatter.

I've tried a lot of products over the years, and always went back to CLP. I've been using it since the '80s, and it's always done the job ( I do use stronger cleaners for deep cleaning from time to time).

 

[CapnMac]

He has unique ways to pronounce various product names [] (I kept shouting "hop EEs" silently at my screen [] )

He did compare a lot more products head to head than I might have--but, that's why I watch Project Farm.

 

[CapnMac]

Break Free CLP in the original formula was pretty amazing. I'm not entirely sold on the current formula.
My mileage varies from others'.

 

[Rule3]

No one ever tests EEZOX

https://www.eezox.com/

 

[iShatterBladderz]

I use the newest formulation of Break Free CLP. Before switching to this, I used ballistol for years and both worked great. My opinion is that for the average person, as long as you keep it clean and lubed with something, wether it’s a CLP or using solvent and gun oil, you’re fine. If your firearm is often exposed to harsh elements or high humidity, you may want to be a little choosier without what you choose.

 

[redcon1]

That was excellent. Looks like Clenzoil wins unless you're operating in extreme cold weather in which case Hoppes would be the better choice.

 

[mcb]

I am not sure he emphasizes enough just how corrosive his combination of hydrogen peroxide, salt, and vinegar is in his corrosion test. You have corrosive salt, vinegar (acid), and hydrogen peroxide (an aggressive oxidizer) mix together. I am not saying this is an invalid test but just that its an extremely touch test one very few of use will ever be in a position to subject our firearms too. This is considerable more sever than even what even a saltwater duck hunting shotgun is likely to see even if it goes for a dip and gets left wet with salt water for days after.

I got caught in a rain storm one fall day out walking the property. I could not have been wetter if I had jumped in a lake. It was a real gully washer and one of the hardest rain storm I have ever seen let alone been out in the middle of the woods for. At one point I looked down, the port cover was open and I had water running out of the bottom of the magazine. Break-Free did a fine job protecting my firearm. Even after a long day of being this wet wandering in the woods when I got home and took the gun apart for a cleaning, the BCG and most of the internal parts were still beading water off them and there was no rust anywhere. Are there better corrosion protection than Break-Free CLP, yes no doubt, but in my experience I have not found a need for it for my guns and I am not afraid to drag mine through the snow, rain, and mud. If I was a salt water duck hunter I might look for something better but in north Alabama and middle Tennessee I am a long way from salt water.

 

[iShatterBladderz]

I would love to hear feedback from someone who’s used both break free and clenzoil, as to whether or not they notice any kind of substantial difference.

 

[mcb]

I would love to hear feedback from someone who’s used both break free and clenzoil, as to whether or not they notice any kind of substantial difference.

Clenzoil does look tempting to try and in Alabama/Tennessee I am unlikely to need the flow at -40F feature of Break-Free.

 

[PCFlorida]

I've used Break Free for many years, but am going to try Clenzoil just because. Here in Florida we don't need the -40F feature, more likely the 100F feature.

 

[JDeere]

I see no reason to switch myself. I have been using Break Free for years and it has served me well. I run my 1911s hard and have not managed to wear one out using it. If I were going to switch I would give the Clenzoil a shot. I love the smell of Break Free in the morning.

 

[Hugger-4641]

I've been using Break Free for several years in my AR-15's, bolt guns, and shot guns. I like something a little thinner that leaves no residue in my auto pistols so they get Rem Oil.
Never heard of Clenzoil, will have to try it.

 

[LeftyTSGC]

I am in southern Alabama, a lot of moisture and heat here.

I have used Frog Lube now for about 5 years on all my firearms, and have never had a problem with cleaning or rust, or operations.
You just need to know that you have to follow the initial steps on using frog lube and over time it performs better as you continue to use it. I still use a little grease (synthetic) on the rails of my Pistols, but technically i do not need too.

Everyone has their favorite for one reason or another. Just wanted to post what i use.

Also, On the CLP video, the Frog Lube was not applied and used as directed, overall Frog Lube still did well if you look at the chart. the Video also only used the
frog lube paste and not the liquid. I choose frog lube because of its non-toxic formula, and it works for what i need on my, rifles, pistols, and shotgun.

leftytsgc

 

[Otto]

I've never been a fan of "one-size-fits-all" gun lubricant. If it turns, use oil. If it slides, use grease. If it does neither, use Loctite.

 

[Nipty]

I use clp ...Yellow words on black label..can't remember brand... and recently got some ballistol. Actually used it on some dies while they sit not being used. The test. Always looking for good products. And yes this guy does no nonsense. Gets right to the point. That's why I ll watch his videos.