In reading the Militia Acts of 1792, it struck me that part of our problem is the mistrust that has developed between gun onwers and the government. I am not sure when that happened, but it was not always the case. The Militia Acts show that private gun ownership was not something our Founders looked upon with suspicion, but a necessary part of the national defense.
From my point of view, a legitimate militia that actually meets and trains regularly and can be called up by local or state authorities has several advantages.
1. The government gets a little control of gun owners, at least on paper. I have seen a list of what weapons militia members showed up with for muster called "the Gun roll" that I think dates to before the Revolution. So the idea of some higher authority than yourself knowing what weapon you had wasn't always so bad. At least on paper, the government knows that you have one rifle and that can make them feel warm and fuzzy.
2. Military spending. We spend a truckload of money on the military and we're so badly in debt we don't know what to do. We could decrease military spending by having a semi-trained militia ready to step up quickly and be assimilated into a real military force if needed, but otherwise not costing any more than whatever it takes to keep us semi-trained. Most of us would even stay semi-trained on our own.
3. Gun owners aren't the bad guys anymore.
4. People who are terrified of or despise guns will have some exposure to them in a positive light and may even build some comraderie with gun owners and realize that we don't all want to shoot up the local Pizza Hut.
5. Maybe we can weed out some nuts. Most of you are probably OK, but there are some guys out there who you positively do not want armed. But they do slip through the cracks. Maybe militia service would provide commanders the chance to help identify some of these people early and put the most dangerous ones under a little closer scrutiny.
6. We could be an asset during times of national emergencies. If even 20% of the population were trained in emergency first aid and other crisis type skills, they could be mobilized in a catastrophe and quickly used under an existing militia command structure (maybe under the local sheriff or police chief).
Just some thoughts.
From my point of view, a legitimate militia that actually meets and trains regularly and can be called up by local or state authorities has several advantages.
1. The government gets a little control of gun owners, at least on paper. I have seen a list of what weapons militia members showed up with for muster called "the Gun roll" that I think dates to before the Revolution. So the idea of some higher authority than yourself knowing what weapon you had wasn't always so bad. At least on paper, the government knows that you have one rifle and that can make them feel warm and fuzzy.
2. Military spending. We spend a truckload of money on the military and we're so badly in debt we don't know what to do. We could decrease military spending by having a semi-trained militia ready to step up quickly and be assimilated into a real military force if needed, but otherwise not costing any more than whatever it takes to keep us semi-trained. Most of us would even stay semi-trained on our own.
3. Gun owners aren't the bad guys anymore.
4. People who are terrified of or despise guns will have some exposure to them in a positive light and may even build some comraderie with gun owners and realize that we don't all want to shoot up the local Pizza Hut.
5. Maybe we can weed out some nuts. Most of you are probably OK, but there are some guys out there who you positively do not want armed. But they do slip through the cracks. Maybe militia service would provide commanders the chance to help identify some of these people early and put the most dangerous ones under a little closer scrutiny.
6. We could be an asset during times of national emergencies. If even 20% of the population were trained in emergency first aid and other crisis type skills, they could be mobilized in a catastrophe and quickly used under an existing militia command structure (maybe under the local sheriff or police chief).
Just some thoughts.