Out of curiosity....what real difference does open/closed backstrap make?
According to a calculation I saw, a 12+ oz 340 if not held firmly while shooting a 357, achieves velocity of 45 feet per second in the milliseconds that a bullet is travelling in the barrel. The firmer the gun is held, the lower the velocity but unless it is welded to the bones, it will be substantial.
Basically, the effect is similar to someone hitting you with a hammer - a 12 oz hammer moving anywhere from 15 to 40 feet per second. That is exactly what it felt like when I shot those two 357s.
A 1/16 inch of rubber would make a lot of difference in how one feels that blow.
miko