Just Stating What Everyone Knows Already...

Maybe I should have included a picture of the gun. I figured everyone was sick of seeing it but there might be one person out there who hasn't. ;)

28NGR.jpg

28NGL.jpg

It was sorta rough when I got it, but a little Flitz, Ren Wax, elbow grease, and a decent set of Altamont grips, got it looking good enough for polite company. It is rapidly becoming one of, if not my favorite revolver.
 
Gamesman mentality. More power to you if that's the way your stick floats. The first 357 Magnum was the 6-shot Registered Magnum. My first duty weapon (in 1973) was a 4" M28-2. Six round revolvers just seem proper to old geezers like me.

Dave
When you're gaming it's best to have a gamesman mentally. But it's not an exclusive mentality for me, for social situations I prefer 38 Special in a much smaller frame. For hunting I prefer something in .40 cal or bigger. I personally just don't have an application for a 6-shot 357 mag N-frame. I want more rounds for gaming, more caliber for hunting, and less weight and power for social or utility. I realized the history of, and nostalgia for, the 27/28 but from my point of view that is not strong enough to trump my use applications that drives me away from that configuration. I love the N-frame, own four N-frames, more than any other frame size I own, if that matters.
 
Last edited:
Model 28s and wadcutters seem to go hand in glove!

My self customized Model 28-2,

View attachment 1194301

View attachment 1194299

My wadcutters, current favorite on the left, SAECO 453. The other two bullets are being tried.

View attachment 1194300

So far the 453 has been an accurate bullet. It shoots clean through Ohio white tailed deer at about 850 fps.

Kevin
Kevin,
I have to tell you that your model 28 is one my favorite guns here on THR. That is just a great revolver.
 
Maybe I should have included a picture of the gun. I figured everyone was sick of seeing it but there might be one person out there who hasn't. ;)

View attachment 1194375

View attachment 1194376

It was sorta rough when I got it, but a little Flitz, Ren Wax, elbow grease, and a decent set of Altamont grips, got it looking good enough for polite company. It is rapidly becoming one of, if not my favorite revolver.
Who would be sick of seeing that? It’s a very nice revolver.
My only N frames are my 327 Night Guard and my Model 25-15. I let a new model 27 “Classic” get away from me during the covid silliness. It was a 4”. But the lucky thing was that was when I found my 25-15.

S&W 327 Night Guard 8-shot .357 Magnum
1707854603331.jpeg

S&W 25-15 .45 Colt
1707854713931.jpeg
 
My 28-2 with Thai Magnas and a grip adapter.

SW28-2-Left.jpg


I picked up an El Paso Saddlery 1942 Tanker holster for packing it in the woods.

eps-tanker-front.jpg

As I am not a fan of the .357's blast and flash, I shoot it with .38 Specials. For Pennsylvania woods use I'd load it with Matt's Bullet's 178 grain Keith on top of 5.0 - 5.5 grains of Unique in .38 Special brass, which should give ~930 to 1,000 FPS.
 
Did somebody say Model 28s?

I have three, they are all Model 28-2.

This one has an extra long spur on the hammer.

403jWf.jpg





This one has a regular hammer.

fi4cLw.jpg





This four inch one was refinished.

rnRThX.jpg
 
No. I've been a Unique/Bullseye guy all my life, but haven't been able to find any lately, so the guys at the gun shop recommended W231 for my wadcutter use (so do a lot of books) and the 244 for my moderate 357/44 loads, so that's what I'm working with for now. I don't load anything "hot" or really even moderate. My 357 are at the bottom of the listing .
I've used Unique for a loooong time, but, like most, haven't seen any for the longest time. W 231 and HP 38 are said to be the same powder, despite widely differing loads in the manuals, good for the middle of the road loads I like. AND...140-158 @ 900 fps +/- is not to be snickered at. AA #5 is said to be close to a Unique equivalent. That said, I'm probably going to pick up some #5 and HP 38 for my 357 Magnum "Hot 38-Mild Magnum" loads, and jump on any Unique I may stumble on.
 
I've used Unique for a loooong time, but, like most, haven't seen any for the longest time. W 231 and HP 38 are said to be the same powder, despite widely differing loads in the manuals, good for the middle of the road loads I like. AND...140-158 @ 900 fps +/- is not to be snickered at. AA #5 is said to be close to a Unique equivalent. That said, I'm probably going to pick up some #5 and HP 38 for my 357 Magnum "Hot 38-Mild Magnum" loads, and jump on any Unique I may stumble on.
I burned a lot of #5 before I "discovered" Unique in the 1980s. I still prefer Unique in general - and especially in the .44 Special - but have gone back to #5 now that Unique is so hard to get, and have generally had good results with it.
 
For cutting X's out to 50 yards! :)
Mounting a red dot solves vision issues for "grey beards"! :)
 

Attachments

  • 20180930_112925.jpg
    20180930_112925.jpg
    101 KB · Views: 7
  • 20171106_142118.jpg
    20171106_142118.jpg
    173.5 KB · Views: 7
Those grips look like some elk I have from Bigmtnman at S&W Forum.

No, I don’t believe I have. That one is very nice too.
What are those grip panels made of? I like that one too. I am assuming it’s.45 ACP?

The stocks are smooth elk, from Ken, aka bigmtnman. Don’t bother looking for a website, he does not have one. He has a unique business plan. Actually not a business plan at all. Ken looks at an antler section and decides if it will work for a S&W or a Colt revolver. He then cuts it, shapes it and decides how much, if any, bark will remain. He fits them to revolvers he has on hand and offered them on one of two forum. I have seen them last as long as a couple of days but usually they are snagged within hours. At least the ones I like. He does not do commission work nor does he accept orders. Strictly a hobby. He does not want it to become a job. This works for him and he is as successful as he chooses to be. It annoys me but it works for him. More power to Ken!

Yes, the Model 25-2 is a 45 ACP. The last custom job I did. The grips are smooth elk, N frame, round butt Magnas. Paired with a Tyler T Grip. My favorite grip combination.

Kevin
 
The stocks are smooth elk, from Ken, aka bigmtnman. Don’t bother looking for a website, he does not have one. He has a unique business plan. Actually not a business plan at all. Ken looks at an antler section and decides if it will work for a S&W or a Colt revolver. He then cuts it, shapes it and decides how much, if any, bark will remain. He fits them to revolvers he has on hand and offered them on one of two forum. I have seen them last as long as a couple of days but usually they are snagged within hours. At least the ones I like. He does not do commission work nor does he accept orders. Strictly a hobby. He does not want it to become a job. This works for him and he is as successful as he chooses to be. It annoys me but it works for him. More power to Ken!

Yes, the Model 25-2 is a 45 ACP. The last custom job I did. The grips are smooth elk, N frame, round butt Magnas. Paired with a Tyler T Grip. My favorite grip combination.

Kevin

That is cool Kevin. I do like his work. You have a couple of unique revolvers with unique one of a kind grips. :cool:

I like your model 25-2. Maybe one day I will have a similar one. I never considered a .45 ACP or even a 9mm revolver until I had Ruger make me a .45 ACP cylinder for my New Vaquero. I love shooting it with that cylinder in it. It’s actually more accurate shooting .45 ACP than it is with .45 Colt.
 
That is cool Kevin. I do like his work. You have a couple of unique revolvers with unique one of a kind grips. :cool:

I like your model 25-2. Maybe one day I will have a similar one. I never considered a .45 ACP or even a 9mm revolver until I had Ruger make me a .45 ACP cylinder for my New Vaquero. I love shooting it with that cylinder in it. It’s actually more accurate shooting .45 ACP than it is with .45 Colt.
Here is a thread on that specific revolver.


On another forum, it was panned by nearly everyone. Called everything from a money pit to a boat anchor.

I like challenges.

Kevin
 
Here is a thread on that specific revolver.


On another forum, it was panned by nearly everyone. Called everything from a money pit to a boat anchor.

I like challenges.

Kevin
It came out great. 😍
As soon as I saw that revolver in the link I remembered it instantly. You have more talent and confidence than I do.

Was this other forum for uptight unimaginative people?
 
For cutting X's out to 50 yards! :)
Mounting a red dot solves vision issues for "grey beards"! :)
So does only running the target out to 7 yards. ;) I remember shooting at a pepper popper once at 50 yards back in my IPSC days. I actually hit it, which surprised me so much, I just stood there and admired my work until I heard the buzzer...EEEEEEKKKKKKKK. I forgot I was supposed to keep shooting.

It's no wonder my ISPC career was so short. :rofl:
 
It came out great. 😍
As soon as I saw that revolver in the link I remembered it instantly. You have more talent and confidence than I do.

Was this other forum for uptight unimaginative people?

Thank you. As soon as I saw that revolver it called out to me like a puppy in the pound. Once the OP decided to pass on it, I asked for the shop information and contacted them. You see the results.

The other forum is a great forum. Mostly collectors or others who like to see standard factory models. Some of them do cringe a little at changes as drastic as what I have done. But, as I said, a great forum.

Kevin
 
The Model 28-2 is a helluofagun. This is sort of a range report I suppose. I don't have pictures of targets to go along with it, but I took my 28-2 to the range with me yesterday along with 110 wadcutter loads (148 DEWC Berry's over Win 231) and 50 rounds of starting level 357 magnums (158 grain TC Berry's over Win 244). I figured that should hold me long enough for my back to really start hurting and be ready to go.

I started off running a double handful of the wadcutters through my 642 carry gun. It's actually fun to shoot with wadcutters. Now I'm working on being accurate with the little thing. It's a work in progress but coming along nicely.

Then I stapled up a B-27 and ran it out to the twenty yard line. That was a mistake. Between my back hurting, and the red insert front sight blending in perfectly with the red 10/X ring on these targets, I was all over the place. Ran it back in to seven yards. I shoot just for the fun of it and it's more fun to hit what I'm shooting at. That was a big difference (obviously). Suddenly I could see my sights and proceeded to cut the 10/X ring out of a couple of those B-27's. Just left a big hole in the cardboard backing. Those wadcutter loads are FUN in that big gun. Sort of a POP...a little muzzle rise and back on target. I'd load five, shoot five, call the target back, set down on my walker, kick the empties out, put them back in the box, and load five more, check the target and run it out again. When the target got too ragged to tell where I was hitting, I'd change targets. Not very tactical, but almost as much fun as shooting tin cans down on the creek bank.

By the time I got finished with the wadcutters, I was getting a little tired, but wanted to shoot some 357's again, just for grins and giggles. I switched out to smaller target with a couple of IPSC type silioutes on one paper. The magnums had a lot more boom and flash, but shot just about as well. I budgeted 25 per target and didn't do too awful I suppose. The range guys didn't tell me to leave, which is my ultimate measure of success. Actually one of them came over and asked what I was shooting and we talked revolvers a bit.

All the shooting was double action by the way. Since I started really working on DA with my Colt Python, it seems I've forgotten how to shoot SA. Even when I shoot off the bench I use DA.

Anyway, if you've stuck with it this long expecting it to get interesting, I'm sorry. Just an old man talking himself really.
The model 28 was my last issue carry gun. Yeah, dating myself when a revolver and 18 rounds of RP 125 gr JHP 357 magnums were the issue. Shooting HBWC through that beast was fun and I still do it just because it is fun.
 
I concur that Model 28s are marvelous. I’ve owned a few over time and, while my current tastes have taken me down the road of the Model 27 more recently, I’d like to pick up another 28.

Pics here of a somewhat unique bird acquired a few years back on another forum. It was listed as a 4-inch 28, but I knew that barrel just didn’t quite look like it was reaching the 4-inch mark.

Got it in and, thanks to a little online help, found it to be a 28-2 that had been fitted at some point in its life with the 3-1/2” barrel of a Model 27. An unknown gunsmith had also bobbed the hammer, installed a trigger stop, and re-did the front sight before having the gun refinished to what appeared to be a durable flat-black finish. The seller had no history on the gun and I was never able to get more info on it. I can say that it handled / shot / carried quite well.

I do wish I’d held onto this one though, if I had, I believe I’d have tried to have a ramp-style front sight re-applied haha…

Shown here in a zoom-in of a little posed-shot I took of it at the time.

1708146004034.jpeg

…edited to add that, on reviewing my past posts, I already did a write-up on this one last year LOL…

 
Last edited:
Back
Top