For SD against dangerous game DA is nice to have. For true hunting type scenarios, SA is always gonna be more accurate. That's why it's nice to have both options available.
MY state, like many others, does not allow for the use of lasers for hunting. I use traditional open sights......IMO, what handgun hunting is all about. Over the last few years, I've had to pass on many shots with my handguns that would have been "gimmees" with my scoped ought-six. Very similar to hunting with a bow. Part of the progression of many hunters is the focus turning to the hunt itself and not the kill, or the amount of game in the back of the truck. Many times, knowing one had a shot and decided to pass is more satisfying than the trailing/dragging of an animal from a remote area, especially if it is not a special animal. Used to be I would shoot any buck, any where and do whatever it took to get it out. Nowadays, the amount of work after the shot is a big consideration. Lately, I'd rather shoot a nice doe close to the truck or road as opposed to a fair buck a mile back in. Used to be the other way around. Used to be, I had to come back with something or it was not a successful hunt. Anymore, it's a success just to get out.
Good to see you are realistic in your expectations. So many come here and to other gun forums and think that when they fail, it is because the bullet, the bow or some other equipment failed them. Truth is, that is rarely the case. Truth is, more times than not, they are the ones that let themselves and the quarry down.
Part of the reason I enjoyed hunting the tough area I did is because of the challenges it presented. It is still why I go back even tho I now have easier places to hunt. The bucks are smaller and fewer, but the challenge is what makes for the trophy. It's not for everyone. It ain't about the braggin' rights or the mount on the wall. It's about the satisfaction and the feeling I get from the hunt there itself. To those that don't understand, it ain't worth the trouble to try and explain.