I like it for .357 J frame loads. I've found velocity tends to be erratic with light loads of Longshot and that it's no substitute for powders like HP38/W231. 125, 140, or 158 grain bullets loaded to near maximum pressure won't give the velocities of H110, but the recoil is a lot less. One of the reasons for substantially less recoil is Longshot has greater power density. A charge of Longshot half the mass of a charge of H110 will deliver slightly less velocity but a lot less recoil, because the mass of the powder, which is being accelerated to ~150% the velocity of the bullet, is so much less. Powders like H110, W296, H4227, Lil'Gun that have a large mass of deterrent to slow combustion come with a heavy recoil penalty. Even so, there's still no way to match the velocities that can be obtained with H110 and similar powders with Longshot or W572.