1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Looking to buy quality 357 magnum revolver

Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Dog Wonder, Sep 4, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Dog Wonder

    Dog Wonder Member

    Dec 6, 2008
    East Coast
    I am looking to buy a quality 357 magnum revolver! This handgun would be used for both home defense and shooting at the range! I have shot a couple of revolvers-Ruger sp 101 357 magnum & a smith & wesson 38 caliber!
    Some people at my range said that I might want to look at a Smith & Wesson 686 with a 3 inch barrel! I have medium size hands and find that a revolver would truely be a very nice gun to own for reliability and accuracy!
    I am open to opinions on any brand & barrel lenght!

    Many thank-you's for your thoughts!

    P.S. what do shooters think of the Ruger GP100 "Wiley Clapp" 357 Magnum Revolver?
    Last edited: Sep 4, 2012
  2. 98Redline

    98Redline Member

    Jan 3, 2011
    For a gun that will serve both range and home protection duty I think something in the range of 4" to 6" is about the perfect size. Long enough to be accurate, short enough to not be unwieldy. Using full tilt .357 loads the longer 6" barrel guns will weigh a little more, especially around the barrel, and will tend to be a bit more pleasant to shoot. Not that a 4" will be bad, just a little snappier to shoot. I would advise to say away from the smaller framed .357s not for any other reason than those smaller framed guns with full power loads can be a real handful for a beginning shooter and the shorter barrel will not work quite as well as a range gun. Guns that fall into this category are pretty much any 5 shot .357, regardless of frame material.

    Regarding particular guns I would suggest, there are two. Either a S&W 686 or a Ruger GP100. Both are proven performers and will be more accurate than you are likely to be for a long time. The Ruger will be less expensive than the Smith, but will be just a hair less refined.
  3. 357 Terms

    357 Terms Member

    Oct 8, 2010
    A 4in 357 is arguably the most versatile handgun you can buy.

    You get good performance with the 357 hot loads and you can shoot everything below that, including light 38's.

    The 686 is a good choice, so is a Ruger gp100.

    On the used gun market a Colt Trooper at a reasonable price, or a Six series Ruger (Security, Service,Speed) would also be a fine choices.
  4. adelbridge

    adelbridge Member

    Jan 30, 2012
    I prefer 6" or longer barrels for better velocity and accuracy in the longer sighting plane. If it is for home or range and not carry a 6" is perfect. I had and dearly loved a Ruger GP100 but the trigger pull was not as nice as Smiths or Colts. Despite the pedestrian trigger that gun was hyper accurate out to 50 yards. I would hang poker chips at 30 yards and chip them away to nothing.
  5. bikemutt
    • Contributing Member

    bikemutt Member

    Dec 24, 2010
    Vancouver, WA
    Consider the Ruger GP100 3" "Wiley Clapp" model. It has a higher level of fit and finish than the baseline GP100 and is a darn nice gun to ogle, a word not often associated with Rugers.
  6. hardluk1

    hardluk1 member

    Mar 27, 2009
    nc mountains
    Try to pickup a dan wesson 15-2 series. Price tends be better , 350 to 450 for a solid nice revolver accurate and stronger but not any larger. And have a choice of barrels from EWKarms and other small aparts to upgrade with. Not restricked by grips size ether as it is a post mounted grip.
  7. Roverrich

    Roverrich Member

    Aug 19, 2012
    I shot a longer "Dirty Harry" sized barrel (8 in) I believe and 6" Python and 4" smith. Aside the differences in actions, the 4 " Barrel seemed to be the best option for me. While not small by any means, it wouldn't be impossible to conceal if you so chose to do so. It does tame the cartridge a bit, but is still pleasant to shoot. I also have a LCR in 357 mag and don't like shooting more than a few rounds to keep up proficiency. I have a 686+ in 4" and agree that this could just about be the most versatile gun I own. As always to each their own, you may want to go to a range and shoot different length barrels and see what suits you best.
  8. mdThanatos

    mdThanatos Member

    Aug 11, 2008
    I own a GP100 4" and while I really like it, I did get a chance to fire a S&W 19 and the trigger was far better than mine. I like the balance of a 4" barrel is fantastic and would recommend trying either a GP100 or a 686.
  9. 303 hunter

    303 hunter Member

    Dec 30, 2011
    Fayetteville N.C.
    +1 on the GP100 or the 686. The 586 is also a great gun.
  10. skidder

    skidder Member

    Mar 26, 2011
    I'm a brand loyal kinda guy...

    and that would be Ruger:

    used: Security Six 4" barrel
    used/new:GP100 or SP101 3" or 4" barrel

    They are just so dang tough.
  11. Hotshot10

    Hotshot10 Member

    Apr 2, 2011
    I own both a Smith 686 and a Ruger SP101. The 686 has a four-inch barrel, and the SP101 has a three-inch barrel.

    The Smith trigger, as others have indicated, is smooth. The Ruger was pretty rough until I had a gunsmith do a trigger job, and it's pretty good now.

    If you intend to carry, the SP101 is much more manageable, which is why I bought it. If you intend to shoot it mostly at the range, the 686 would be my choice.

    Honestly, if I had it to do over again, I would buy a older, used Smith, maybe a 686 no dash or a 686-1. Both my Smith (canted, misaligned barrel) and my Ruger (single-action trigger that hung up halfway through the squeeze) had problems out of the box. I don't want to bash either brand, but the older ones I've shot or handled are what I would choose.
  12. OrangePwrx9

    OrangePwrx9 Member

    May 30, 2009
    North of the Fingerlakes-NY
    I have a small collection of .357 revolvers. Here are my impressions:

    6" nickel Python: Accurate, nice action but DA trigger does stack, too prissy for everyday use. Hard to keep it looking good.

    6" ported stainless 686 from mid '90s: Scary accurate, great trigger, too heavy for carrying

    4-5/8" Ruger BH convertible (9mm/357): Fun, accurate, cheap to shoot w/9mm, most versatile handgun I own, creepy trigger, big and heavy for what it shoots, single-action only.

    4" blued S&W 586 from mid '90s: Currently back at factory (2nd time) to fix serious accuracy problem that it has had since new, factory trigger job very nice, pretty, but too heavy for carrying.

    4" stainless Ruger Security Six: My favorite, outshoots everything but the 686(for me, anyway) while being compact and light enough to carry. Shoots target wadcutter loads and hot 125 gr. JHPs to same point of impact. Double action shooting is as accurate as single-action shooting once you get used to it...maybe even better. Trigger is good and consistent, but not great.

    3" SP101: Suffered from poor sights and poor regulation out of the box. Filing the front sight to get it to hit at POA, made sights even worse. BUT when the light was right and I was on my game, it shot very accurately. Finally fixed the sight issues with both a CTC laser and an XS Big Dot. OK for belt carry, too heavy for pocket carry.

    2-7/8" stainless Security Six: Just got it; may get to shoot it today. Seems to have a much nicer trigger than my 4" SS.

    Had an early blued 6" GP100 for awhile. Only 357 I didn't like. Heavy, felt like a brick, action & trigger inferior to the Security Six, mediocre accuracy. Traded it off. Haven't sampled the GP100 well since.

    One thing I've noticed is that the triggers on the stainless Rugers seem to clean up on their own with plenty of dry firing. Smith triggers are usually very good to excellent out of the box. My 586 didn't need the trigger job but there was a promotion going at the time.

    Last edited: Sep 5, 2012
  13. Guillermo

    Guillermo member

    Feb 20, 2008
    Austin, Texas
    4 inch 686 police trade in is a great buy.

    Made before the internal lock and the injection-molded internal parts.
    Tough and while not a great trigger from the factory, most any gunsmith has parts and the ability to work on it. They can be smoothed out and tricked out.
  14. 460Shooter

    460Shooter Member

    Feb 12, 2011
    The Land that Time Forgot
    S&W 686
    S&W 627
    Ruger GP100
    Ruger SP101

    Pick one. They are all good guns.

    Boy OP I have never seen so many exclamation points in a post before. You are really excited. Well, good luck and enjoy!
  15. TrueTexan

    TrueTexan Member

    Aug 23, 2012
    Fort Worth "Cowtown" Texas
    Like almost everybody else go with the Smith 686 or Ruger gp 100. I have the 686 plus that has 7 rounds and it is wonderful to shoot. Has the 6 inch barrel. Recomend go with stainless. The only pistol that I have that is more accurate is my Ruger MK III target.
  16. Upstater

    Upstater Member

    May 30, 2012
    Upstate N.Y.
    Does it have to be double action? If not the op might consider a nm vaquero by Ruger, mine is 4 5/8 bbl and I gotta tell you it is more accurate than any other pistol I own, and this gun will handle every load that can be made safely it is like a tank in your hand but very well balanced and doesn't weigh a ton.:)
  17. Rexster

    Rexster Member

    Mar 25, 2007
    SE Texas
    Easy take-down and reassembly were important in your 1911 thread in the Auto Pistol section; if that is a factor here, Rugers are a bit friendlier than S&W, though no DA revolver is going to detail-strip as easily as a 1911.

    I own several each of the GP100 and SP101, in various barrel lengths, and a 4" S&W Model 19. Both companies make very good revolvers. The L-frame S&W Models 586/686/581/681 are size/weight counterparts to the Ruger GP100; my Model 19 is a K-frame, which is just a bit lighter in weight, making for better all-day concealed carry, though the L-frames and the GP100 certainly can be carried all day, and I have done so.

    For home defense and range training, a 6" barrel is going to be friendlier to one's ears when shots are fired, as more of the powder is going to be burned inside the barrel, and the muzzle blast is going to be a bit farther away, than with the shorter barrels, if using magnum ammo. This is not the relatively much milder, lower-pressure .45ACP! The .357 Magnum is a superb street-fighting cartridge, but if I am inside the home, and have the time to choose, I would rather use my 1911.
  18. WardenWolf

    WardenWolf member

    Nov 11, 2008
    Northern Virginia
    I recommend a Ruger SP101 with the 4" barrel or a Ruger GP100. They're very solidly built revolvers. I will caution you that the SP101 really needs Hogue grips to be fun to shoot.
  19. beag_nut

    beag_nut Member

    Nov 21, 2011
    Seymour, CT
    +1 for what wardenwolf said.
    Except that the 6" GP100 is the most accurate DA revolver I have ever seen (in 40 years). I have one, and I am challenged to exploit its accuracy. I also have a 4" SP101, and the Hogue grip is a necessity. The GP already comes with a great grip. With either I can keep all shots within a 3" circle, doing DA, at 50 feet, which is OK for my age of 66+ (offhand). But I would choose the SP for home defense (easier to carry around).
  20. Resto Guy

    Resto Guy Member

    Feb 2, 2009
    I notice that many suggest a 4" or 6" barrel. I have revolvers with 2", 4" and 6" barrels. I am most comfortable with the 4". In a home defense situation, that is the one I would probably reach for if they were side-by-side.
  21. barnbwt

    barnbwt Member

    Aug 14, 2011
    Funny how that doesn't suggest a 5" barrel to be the best solution? ;)

    S&W TRR8

    Great trigger, 8 shots of .357 on tap, great (and adjustable/replaceable) sights, cut for moon clip goodness, comfy (Hogue?) rubber stocks tame recoil greatly. 5" barrel gives respectable velocities, good sight radius, and preserves handling/balance to only slightly barrel heavy (aluminum frame).

    Light enough for carry, possibly small enough for carry (it is an N frame, after all:)), ugly enough to carry. It is my go-to gun for backwoods trekking in hog/black bear/grower country. Galco makes a very comfy Phoenix OWB holster, Bianchi's X15 shoulder holster works, and I'm working on a pack-mounted rig that holds the gun at the ready right behind my neck.

  22. C5rider

    C5rider Member

    Mar 1, 2011
    'Tween swamp and sun!
    Agreed. Don't overlook the Dan! :D

    FERLACH Member

    Jul 27, 2006
    Plainfield, In.
    Back in the 80s, I was an owner of a gun shop and also had a gun range in my back yard. Most used guns we took in trade, I test fired at my home. Shot probably over 500 differant guns over several years. SW, colt, ruger, star, taurus, you name it, I probably shot it. Hands down, I would stake my life on a 2" to 4" Smith Wesson revolver over anything else. If you dont plan on ever carrying it, which is unlikely, then I might go with a 6". Just my 2 cents. There are a lot of good dependable guns.
  24. Starter52

    Starter52 Member

    Oct 16, 2005
    Northeast USA
    I'd recommend a used S&W Model 28 "Highway Patrolman" with a 6" barrel. Tough as nails and a great .357 magnum.
  25. 22250Rem

    22250Rem Member

    Jun 28, 2011
    Western NY State
    I love my 4 inch 686. A 4 inch makes a nice compromise between a snubby and a 6 inch barrel. Darn accurate too; even in my hands and I'm far from being an expert pistolero. But then, there's a lot of very sweet Rugers out there also. I've had the privledge to shoot a couple of Colt Pythons in years gone by and they are absolutely SUPERB. Only problem is that they are also very expensive. There's a lot of nice stuff available including the previously mentioned Dan Wessons. Look around at quality guns in good shape and pick some up and see how they feel in your own hand. Only you can decide what feels just right. 357's are very versatile even if you don't plan on running any 38 specials through it but it's always nice to have that option.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page