I looked at purchasing both rifles you've mentioned. The Marlin seemed like a better rifle, but was MUCH more expensive and didn't seem worth the extra money. I ended up purchasing the Henry and have been extremely happy. Its more accurate than I am and fun to shoot.
Yeah the Marlin is about $200 more than the Henry . The Marlin has a nice design and the Henry is plain jane. The Marlin comes in a 24" barrel, the Henry comes in 18 1/4 " barrel. I had a Marlin and somehow my father ended up with it , I still dont know how that happened but now I need another 22 lever action.
Bought my Marlin in '55. Bought a Henry about 8 or 9 years ago. Still have the Marlin. The action on the Henry was smoother than the Marlin. That was the Henry's finer point. The Marlin offers better (all steel) construction, easier take-down for cleaning, better in the accuracy department, at least for me. It is however 2x or so higher priced than the Henry. From past ownership experience, if I had neither, I'd exercise a little patience and save the extra bucks for the Marlin 39. You really can't knock either firearm, just depends upon what you are willing to part with money wise.
The Henry is a good inexpensive gun that will do the job for most people. It is not in the same league as the Marlin however. The Marlin is a gun that will passed down for generations.
I have a 39A but if I were to get a Henry it'd be the H001T, with the octagon barrel and Marble's sights. Actually I'd be going after that nice slide-action, assuming I had money to burn.
What turned me off on them though is that the manufacturer doesn't recommend taking them down at all (no instructions even included).
No question that the Marlin 39A is the better rifle. You pay for it, but it is in my opinion worth the extra money. You can find them used for a pretty fair price if you look.
The Browning BL-22 is also a great little rifle. I have been looking for a Winchester 9422 to keep my Marlin 39A company.
I had a Henry as my first .22 rifle in years. I now have a 39A which I truly love. My choice would be the 39A, but I'd recommend a Henry H001 to anyone looking for a lower cost .22 lever action rifle.
BTW, I bought my 39A used...and the price wasn't much more then a new Henry H001.
I have a 39A that I bought new a few years ago. This may be an unpopular thing to say, but the internals of the Marlin are very poorly finished. I would rank the outside appearance of the gun a 9/10, and the internals about a 3/10. There are lots of machining marks, and the action is fairly rough. I spent quite a few hours trying to smooth out the action, and I was able to make about a 30% improvement. (The internal finishing on my Kel-tec was far better than my Marlin.) The new ones also have a recoiling hammer arrangement, so it makes a real nice 'sproing' sound when you fire it.
The Henry, of course, has an alloy receiver. I don't have any experience with them. Personally, I'd recommend looking carefully at the Henry, Browning, and Winchester and then making a decision. Don't do like I did and assume that the Marlin looks just as nice on the inside as it does on the outside.
Make sure you work the action on them in the store to see if that is satisfactory. Of course, I may be a lot fussier than some about the definition of 'smooth', so it may not bother you at all.
I just bought the Henry H001 and love it. Shoots fine and just like the gun. I opted out of the golden boy though as I plan on also getting the Marlin 39A. The Henry is plenty for me and I am happy with it. Nicely made for me. But I think I'll just add the 39A a little later.
The Henry is a stamped and cast rifle that will be worn out in 20 years or so, and will have little value after a couple of years of use.
The Marlin 39-A is a forged and milled steel, American Walnut legend that will only be smoother and more accurate in 40 years and will have a higher value than when it was new.
Your great grand kids will be battling viciously to see who gets the Marlin long after you're gone.
Not many. The Marlin is a much better rifle, and if not abused or left to rust, it will be around in 100 years. There are some now that are.
I just think the Henry is a viable option for a fine plinker, even though I haven't bought one, won't get one, have two Marlins, and would strongly recommend the Marlin.
I love my Browning BL-22. I've had it since 1974 and it still looks new and drives tacks. If you're in the market for a 22 lever action I suggest you try out a BL-22 at your local gun store.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.