Personally, I'm not a HUGE fan of the S&W M19, but I despise the thought of ANY quality firearm being thus (mis)treated (by the previous owner). I think your refinish job is attractive, functional, and unpretentious, much like the revolver itself. Nicely done.
I'd like to do that with a 6" M28 or a custom-barreled 5" model. I CRINGE at the thought of doing it to an actual M27, but if I could obtain one that was also similarly mistreated (ANOTHER cringe-provoking thought), I certainly wouldn't hesitate to try what you've done here.
I also notice that the model is of "pinned barrel" genre. As a matter of curiosity, does someone know what that means in terms of year of manufacture, durability, etc.?