Musings about the defensive pistol

Status
Not open for further replies.

mercop

Member.
Joined
Jan 12, 2003
Messages
663
Location
The hills of PA
Most people that have been involved in a shooting will tell you that their training was to the reality of a shooting what driving to work is to driving NASCAR. The mechanics are pretty much the same but that is where similarities end.

The vast majority of shooting competitions and informal shooting sessions use and audible cue to signal the shooter to draw and fire. This is very different from the street where shootings usually prompted by physical movement. Why do we still train this way? Sound may be a target identifier but alone should never cause you to fire. The first thing you need to be able to articulate for your defense is an immanent physical threat. There are many ways to simulate this on indoor and outdoor ranges. If the targets are not mechanical then attach a line to them and have a buddy yank on it moving the target. Teach yourself to respond to the preparatory and execution movements of someone drawing a weapon on you.

How many people that carry in the line of duty or have a CCW spend a day on the range shooting without holstering their pistol? The logical progression of carrying any tool for self defence is Selection-Carry-Deployment-Use. Too many folks get caught up in the selection phase trying to find the perfect pistol that will make them better. Some folks spend time learning to run the gun. Two hand shooting, one handed shooting, reloads etc. Very few take a legitimate inventory of their carry options and even less practice deployment under less than perfect circumstances. Their is a need for open hand skills that allow you to create time and distance where none exist. Time and time again we see students that shoot well melt down as soon as they have to draw from concealment even without added stressors. Hands down the most popular carry position is behind the strong side hip. When was the last time, if ever, you practiced drawing you gun from this position while seated in a vehicle with your concealment garment and seat belt buckled over it? You may want to before you need to.

There are a couple of invaluable things you can purchase beside ammo to increase your combat effectiveness with your pistol. The first in getting a Rings Manufacturing blue gun trainer of the gun you carry. It will allow you to practice drawing, weapon handling, room clearing, and weapons retention etc while enjoying total safety that is visibly verifiable by anyone. The second is to get an air soft copy of your gun if available. Even if it is one of the models that needs to be cocked it can offer great training value. Care must be taken to insure that the live gun is not in proximity to the training environment. With the help of a few like minded friends and some common sense scenarios you will soon see that under stress the fundamentals or marksmanship exit stage right as soon as the you know what hits the fan. Eye protection is the bare minimum when using air soft. The little plastic BBs can travel in excess of 300 per second, enough for a valuable pain penalty that discourages mistakes.

Your gun is not a talisman that can keep you safe. It is worthless without your dedication, awareness, determination and skill, and lots of luck.

If you like target shooting as I do, by all means keep doing it. Just set aside time to hone your other defensive skill sets that compliment your overall protection plan.
 
The operator of any handgun should understand a number of things about his chosen firearm.

#1. A handgun should always be a back-up firearm to a good rifle or a decent shotgun. Handguns were originally designed to be a close-range, personal defense firearm. Got it? Close range and defensive in its use. This is why people joke about their "assault pistols." There ain't no such animal to the person who understands rudimentary firearms.

#2. About 70% of all people who get shot with pistols survive being shot. Hmmm... 70% survive being shot. So that means that my handgun isn't quite as strong as I thought it might be. So that also means that I need to practice, practice and practice my shooting with my chosen handgun so that I can make it be as effective as I can. Without lots of practice, the effectiveness of my handgun drops down even more.

#3. What else makes a handgun more effective besides lots of practice? Multiple hits on target delivered quickly and at close range. In other words, the old "two to the chest and one to the head" shooting scenario IS a realistic shooting scenario to practice! So, if I do lots of practice and if I practice two to the chest and one to the head often, I will probably do pretty good in a shootout, God forbid, I ever get into one.

#4. Bigger bore pistols and pistols with power behind the projectile (magnums) seem to be more effective than smaller bore pistols. Smaller bore pistols that are used effectively and where the shots are well placed on the target are more effective than bigger bore pistols. So that means, a big bore pistol with a powerful bullet, as big as I can effectively use and carry, that hits the target with well placed shots is what I want the most. That means more practice with my chosen firearm...

#5. So my rifle or shotgun is my primary firearm. My pistol is the back-up to them and, if I am smart, I will carry a knife of some sort as a back-up to my shoulder-mounted firearm and my pistol too.

#6. FORETHOUGHT!!! If I can, I will look ahead to try to avoid trouble or to defeat it. If I have the option I should move to avoid a deadly confrontation when possible. If avoidance is not possible, then I will use plans, training and lots of practice to engage or meet trouble and then defeat it. This is where my previous "what if" planning comes together for me. What if... somebody forces their way into my house by kicking in the front door? The back door? Breaks out the picture window and tries to come through the opening? If I shoot at this angle in my house what could my bullets hit? A relative? A neighbor? The hillside across the street? Planning ahead of trouble is just as important as a lot of practice. Also remember to review your plans in your head or on paper to see if you need to update them or modify for them some reason. If your child comes down sick or is placed on a respirator, your options about moving around or running away from trouble suddenly get reduced. These factors involving you and your family need to be checked time and again for your peace of mind and security.
 
Interesting thread. I think a lot of people place importance on things that become irrelevant in a true defensive situation. The type of sights, type of (fill in the blank), type of caliber, or the ability to shoot 1" groups at 30 yards all become somewhat irrelevant when life and death come down to one scary moment.
 
I agree. There's too much talk about the toys, and not enough about how to use it.

Check any forum and you'll see the trend - make, model, caliber, finish, sights, a subsection for everything, and even the thoughtful inclusion of one (1) for actual use. It should be the other way around - discussion on situations, and ONE on what to carry. Not trying to be inflammatory, it's a general observation about much of life in America right now. It's all about the bling and not how to use it.

I was filling up my faded Cherokee and a nice white Corvette pulled in. I got to thinking, lots of people can drive a fast car, but not many can drive a car fast.

We should be like the Swiss, a range in every hamlet, and free ammo.
 
Agree mostly, but...

About 70% of all people who get shot with pistols survive being shot.

This is not really germane to the discussion. After all, we're not trying to kill an attacker, we're trying to stop him, and there are no dependable statistics about how many people, after being shot, stopped attacking. "Keep shooting until the lethal threat is gone" is a valid principle.

ability to shoot 1" groups at 30 yards all become somewhat irrelevant when life and death come down to one scary moment.


Maybe. But if you've practiced enough to shoot 1" groups with that pistol, my guess is that you're going to have the confidence in your abilities that IS one ingredient of surviving a gunfight.

We should be like the Swiss

I've got an awful lot of "shoulds" but they don't seem to change reality much. Besides, then we'd be Swiss--and there's nothing wrong with that.
 
Why is it that so many people will have the $500++ to spend on a new sight for the AR or $1000++ to spend on a new AR itself, or the $200 for a new light to replace the perfectly function light on their AR but they can't "afford" to pay $400 on a class to use that AR?

You can replace AR with whatever platform you like.

On mercop's original post I think it's funny in a sad sort of way that so many people will berate Airsoft as a training tool (only mall ninjas do that) but somehow think that standing at the line & making sure the footing is just so, their grip is perfect, etc. is all that is required of them to be prepared to win a fight with a gun.

ETA:
Loosedhorse, I'd say the 70% figure is important because there are a lot of people who view their handguns as super duper death rays that will bring instant incapacitation. It's just a quick reference point to show people that things aren't like they appear on the movies & TV. I would also say that it applies in that just because you get hit doesn't mean you should lay down & die. In the grand scheme staying alive & fighting is the most important part of the whole deal.
 
Don't you know that all men are born mechanics and shooters:) It is so funny that I will get shooters who have been at it for years with no training at all. They tell me how many guns they got rid of over the years because they could just not hit with it.

IMHO the average shooter could gain so much from having just one target analyzed along with some feedback from a good instructor. The better you are, the more fun it is, the more you do it.
 
mercop,

I have this problem myself. In training courses, you work from holsters. Work on moving targets. Work on moving while firing. I have yet to find a public range that will allow you, at minimum, to work from a holster behind the line. You're probably not going to find a range that allows you to shoot while moving unless you sign up for IDPA/IPSC type events (which, while its a sport, does offer very good opportunity and benefits not available on a static range)

About the only way to practice your Hackathorn rips (for those concealed carriers) and gaining muscle memory is dry-drawing and dry firing at home. Even the airsoft thing can be beneficial if you have a place to safely carry out your practice without upsetting bystanders. While none of these aids alone cover the full gamut of skills that come together in a dynamic incident, it can prepare you for a real-life encounter, every effort you make to become more trained means you're willing to improve.

Also I feel its vitally important to train so malfunction clearing is second nature and automatic. After taking several courses, I always carry at least one spare mag in case I get malfunctions that require a mag change (especially that double-feed) In real life, you don't have time to stare curiously at the gun and shake it, wondering what kind of malfunction you have. It needs to be automatic. At a range, I often lock the slide open, dump a round directly into the barrel through the ejection port, load a fresh mag, then rack the slide. Pull the trigger, it obviously goes "mooosh". Then go into drill clearing mode, and follow-up with the shot. You can do this with snap caps at home too, of course, just no bang. Yes, it's artificial since you know it's coming, but the motions are identical whether you're doing it in a house, on the Moon, or against an attacker.


#1. A handgun should always be a back-up firearm to a good rifle or a decent shotgun. Handguns were originally designed to be a close-range, personal defense firearm. Got it? Close range and defensive in its use. This is why people joke about their "assault pistols." There ain't no such animal to the person who understands rudimentary firearms.

Unfortunately a close-range, personal defense firearm is about all you have if you're a concealed permit carrier out and about in public life. Of course, one needs to train for your gamut of daily encounters. If you're a concealed permit carrier, you probably need to be as proficient with your sidearm as much as possible due to it being less accurate and weaker versus a long arm

IMHO the average shooter could gain so much from having just one target analyzed along with some feedback from a good instructor. The better you are, the more fun it is, the more you do it.

Better yet, when the instructor teaches you how to analyze your own target and why your 2nd shot was to the left, and the 4th shot was high and to the right, then you have the ability to critique yourself, and correct your own mistakes. I think it is a very powerful tool once you know why your shots missed your intended mark. It means you can correct your errors and improve.
 
Doing the combative pistol stuff with the blue gun and air soft will play huge dividends. Hard on any range to shoot someone jumping on top of you while you are on your back.

Next year along with Raven Concealment I am doing a Police Combatives camp that will have no live fire. You do not always need live rounds for a training benefit.
 
You do not always need live rounds for a training benefit.

I know I learned a lot more from rolling around on the mat with & without the Simunitions in ECQC than I did at the range. Not to say that the range portion was time wasted, but the FOF is where I realized the most gain. Last year I walked out of the class actually scared of my lack of close in skill. This year I was apprehensive going in, but I learned a lot over the last year even through replaying & just thinking about what I needed to do in a confrontation.
 
Close up?

We tend to talk of these big shoot outs with multiple bad guys? I have yet to see one? There might have been some, but I personally have not been privy to a big shoot out, any were I have lived.

So let us say they could happen, but not spend 20 hours a week practicing the how too.

I read somewhere, yesterday? That a friend got mugged, he was a power lifter, and when told to hand over his wallet, he grabbed an arm? Gun was produced, gone wallet.

If the above is about normal, right hand grabs left arm, that is the way it works when facing someone, hullo! If he is in the midst of a robbery attempt, no weapon shown yet? Take that power lifter arm, utilize the fist on the end of it, smack!
The gun is not always the only, or even the best solution.

If you see both hands... OK, you see one, other in pocket, grab hidden hand wrist, same SMACK! a couple more for good measure. Broken snitch, blood blocking throat, eyes not to clear either. Finish the job, leave to safe area, call Police. If, a big IF, the dynamics of the area call that a good move, your call.
 
well ill kindof step towards the other side
theres an old adage that you fight how you train
there are exceptions but a well practiced pattern is likely to be seen when stress otherwise inhibits clear thought
like an athlete who has practiced a move 1000's of times
he no longer thinks of the steps involved the move just comes out subconsciously
 
Excellent posts, everyone. I agree especially with mercop's evaluation of driving to work vs driving in a race. I've been to most of the courses West Coast Tactical offers, and I went to several SCCA and other driving schools when I was racing. The comparison is valid.
Knowing your equipment, and even knowing how to "use" it are very different from actually using in a high-stress environment.
Jim
 
Why is it that so many people will have the $500++ to spend on a new sight for the AR or $1000++ to spend on a new AR itself, or the $200 for a new light to replace the perfectly function light on their AR but they can't "afford" to pay $400 on a class to use that AR?

I carry a $200 used revolver in a $40 holster ;)
 
Old Guy
We tend to talk of these big shoot outs with multiple bad guys? I have yet to see one? There might have been some, but I personally have not been privy to a big shoot out, any were I have lived.

I agree this sometimes gets out of hand.

Here is a link
http://www.rangemaster.com/newsletter/2008-07_RM-Newsletter.pdf

to the data in the Rangemaster newsletter about student involved shootouts. The conclusion looks like you've got a high probability more than one assailant at 15 ft. or closer.


The gun is not always the only, or even the best solution.

I agree.
 
Beware the fella with one gun, he probably knows how to use it.

May ye be half an hour in hivin, before the divil knows your dead!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top