My very big knife accident- in hindsight

Status
Not open for further replies.

Noah

Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
414
Location
Ohio
So.... never posted all this here, only on Spyderco forums, but I'm finally all better and here's my long story and a lot of hindsight on it. Hope everyone gets a reminder to be safe from this...

What I posted on 9/23, 2 days after it happened, on the Spyderco forums:

"I had just gotten a new Endura 4 FFG in blue and was very excited about it, I was playing around with it and fondling it like we all do when we open up a new knife. It's a universal symptom of our knife addiction.

Standing in my living room, I had just spun the handle into a reverse grip, when something distracted me, I think my dog barking outside. As I turned to check out the distraction, I gently brought my hand down without thinking about it...

I felt something "brush" the front of my jeans, and before I even looked I distinctly remember thinking to myself, "Oh that was the knife, I need to be more careful or I'll stick myself!" So I look down a my thigh, and there's the Endura stabbed into my thigh with blood squirted across the blade. still felt absolutely no pain. My hand is still on the knife, which of course I pull right out, in shocked slow motion.

At this point, I think I only gave myself maybe a small scrape, or at the very least something fixed by a few minutes of pressure and a big band aid, so I head downstairs to my basement restroom and (I can't believe I did this) rinse the blood of the blade while I hold a nearby rag to my leg, which still doesn't hurt.

I close the blade and slide it back onto my pocket, but when I look at my leg again, I finally take a good look at what I did to myself... I can clearly see an inch long cut, at least 3/4" of inch deep, with a soon foot by 6" blood stain in my jeans. Even though I just looked into my cut thigh muscles and a hollywood style spreading blood stain, my first thought is to move my phone from my right pocket to my left before it's drenched in blood. *facepalm*

It's only now that I have the "oh shoot!!' realization that I am drenched in blood and a band aid won't do the trick. As I head back up the stairs, maybe 1 minute after I stabbed myself, the pain starts- no sting, just a horrible aching cramp in the cut muscle that screams every time I try to use it. I'm limping terribly, soon I won't be able to walk at all.

A family member drives me to the local urgent care for 6 stitches and a few laughs. The walk from the car into the urgent care was the most painful experience of my entire life, and I've broken bones, jumped into a pool backwards and slammed my head on the deck, and been sent to the hospital by a broompole. I thought I was going to pass out after just a step or two.

When I wasn't trying to move, I still have that horrible "I just ran my muscle full speed into a doorknob" feeling that didn't go away til I forced a few Vikaden down when I finally made it home.

2 days of crippled misery and a ton of embarrassment later, I still can barely walk and hurt every time I move. The cut was right across the muscle in the middle front of my right thigh. I've had a lot of time to catch up on YouTube, forums, and some old movies, at least...



Lessons learned: Please, never ever stab yourself, for me? It hurts.

More "practical" lessons? A reverse grip is pretty dangerous to yourself if you don't know what you're doing. And you are distracted.

It took zero pressure for the tip of the Endura to go straight through jeans and the pocket beneath and then an inch into my leg.

It was over a minute before I felt any pain or was immobilized at all.

After maybe a minute, I've been pretty well impaired for days, just from one "small" stab.


So I repeat: DON'T DO THIS TO YOURSELF!!!



Take Care!"



What I didn't know then was that I had 2 months of crutches and physical therapy to look forward to. Thank God it's all over and I just have a wicked scar, a bit of unresponsive muscle, some scar tissue, and some soreness now. I still have bad dreams where my right leg won't work, it can really suck. I still EDC that knife, and have no fears using it whatsoever. Except... I still get a sick feeling and a weird flinch any time I think of that feeling of the metal thing sliding right into my leg. The thought still makes me literally flinch, even get a little light headed. And I never, ever put the knife in a reverse grip.


Knives are like guns- you can NEVER "let your guard down" with safety. You can dry fire a gun, but if you are going "do the same" with a knife, use something blunt or at least don't let yourself be totally distracted by a dog barking. That ingrained habit to turn and look out the front window for a visitor when the dog barks did NOT serve me well either...

Also, the 1.5 by 1.5+" cut right into the very middle of my right quad had a pretty interesting effect on me. I missed my femoral artery by an inch, I'm blessed to be alive. For you guys who carry a knife for defense, especially those into all of Michael Janich's stuff on stopping attackers using an EDC folder against muscle targets....


First off, with very little force behind it, the tip went right through my jeans straight to the bone. So yes, knives can penetrate without superman-punch strength. This was gentle, but went in quick.

I was not under any stress or adrenaline at the moment it happened, but even then I didn't feel ANY debilitating pain for a good minute, and I was able to walk for another 30 plus seconds after it happened. A squirt of blood followed the blade out as I pulled it from my leg. Then it was just pouring like I'd never seen before.

Once I got down the stairs, limping pretty bad, the pain suddenly started, and my entire thigh muscle just shut down. I was absolutely stopped and crippled. Worst pain I have ever felt.

I was out of it for another 2 months, which totally sucked. That was a learning experience. To be in constant pain, not able to walk, and totally defensively useless is very, very depressing. Just such a downer to have an injury like that that takes so long to get better.

Treat people with injuries like that with sympathy, trust me, it is very very depressing to feel so much "less" than I wanted to. No one really thinks about the emotional effects of a physical injury- but they are the worst part.

The healing process was very difficult, lots and lots of physical therapy and tries and failures. My first tries walking with the physical therapist, that first run I tried and the muscle tore again, setting down that stack of chairs when I thought I was fine and had been walking for weeks and tearing it apart again... Just slow and painful. And I'm an 18 year old in good physical shape.



So please, always be very careful with knives and don't let your guard down when you have the new knife happies! :neener:


It's so great to be all better! Hope you guys learned something.


Noah
 
Noah, thank you for having the courage to post that. You've learned the hard way and done it early. And I do mean learned. You've made an incredibly mature and well thought out analysis of the event and the results. Thank you for sharing with us.
 
Since it happened, I have been much more careful with sharp objects- I haven't even gotten a single cut or scrape from a knife since, actually. Knock on wood! :neener: If anything, I've appreciated them more- I've really gotten into sharpening and even recently made my first knife. Most people I know expected me to renounce knives, but if anything the opposite happened. I spent my time on the couch (well, some of it) watching videos. I also watched just about every John Wayne movie, if I remember correctly. Pain pills can make you fuzzy.

VERY Ironically, I spent a lot of time watching Michael Janich videos, and pledged that once I got better, I would learn to really use the knife for good, rather than evil against myself! :p

There's nothing quite like watching Michael Janich advocate for striking at the quad muscle while recovering from an all too similar accident.
 
Hang in there Brother. I'm lucky (knock on wood) nothing like what happened to you, just had minor cuts from not being safe. I hope for you to have a quick recovery, then you have to do a torture test on that Endura!.....safely I mean.
 
Kee-ripes! I laid my thumb open bad enough to need stitches here a few months ago, but nothing like that!
 
I can relate my friend... Bad deal.

When I was 13 years old, I had received a new knight ML for Christmas. It was one that came in the blister pack with the starter kit with it. I sat it in the floor as my father went to the rest room and began trying to open it with a case hammer head knife. I was sitting Indian style in the floor trying to cut down one side of the blister pack. My knife had came into contact with a staple that I did not see, so I foolishly tried to drive through it, bad move. The knife slipped through then directly into my knee right under the knee cap. I was young and panicked, I tried to stand up with the knife still in my knee, when I tried to straighten my leg I felt the bone grinding against the blade.

When I went to the ER, they put dye in my knee to confirm that I had stabbed into the socket, I had to have surgery repairing the damage from the knife wound and a surgery to clean out the inside of my knee. A few months of healing and crutches, following a week of peeing blue (the dye soaked into my system, try seeing that the first time while jacked up on morphine) and I was back good as new, with a valuable lesson learned.
 
Sam- I like the idea, but what T-Shirt based on our self inflicted injuries would we possibly want to wear in public? :neener:

Sell the knife? Well I've carried it every single day since I stabbed myself on September 21st, even when I was hobbling around in a knee brace and crutches! My physical therapist thought it was hilarious but brave that I still carried it, even during PT sessions. But hey, if you want to trade me a Caly 3.5 or maybe a PM2 or Manix, or pay above the price of a new Endura, you might be able to talk me into something! :neener:

It's actually my favorite knife I've ever owned (see my recent post at http://www.thehighroad.org/showpost.php?p=9286014&postcount=24 , writing that is what brought this back to mind...) and I know for darned sure that it'll work if I ever really, really need it to. That's not to say that you should perform a "cut test" of this variety with every new knife you get. :scrutiny: ;)


Pics? I have an ugly, poorly lit pic of the stitches somewhere. Also have a pic of the bloody jeans- that one's pretty special. It actually ruined my sock with blood too, and a few towels...

Another weird thing- I kept the jeans and actually tried to wash the blood out. Kinda backfired- the stain just faded out and tuned kinda green, and of course there's still a nice cut in the pants too. Looks more like a puke stain. Haven't worn them since, still sittin' in the closet...
 
Never did understand the "dull knives are dangerous" saying. The sharper my knives, the more often I get cut. For me, this is mostly losing parts of my fingerprints. Bit there was one time I was walking with a knife in my hand, arms hanging/swinging loosely when the tip of the knife hit a garbage can. Knife stopped moving; hand continued moving over the blade. And wow, let me tell you, I wish that knife had been dull.

Noah, thanks for sharing. Glad you're alright.
 
I think that saying still applies. Maybe more for cutting and chopping than piercing, but "if it's sharper, it's safer" I think is true overall. I had a lot more normal little cuts with duller knives. IMO, dull slip joints (or garbage $5 Chinese liner locks) are a downright public menace.


OH and bigger point with the saying- Ain't nobody done said that saying applies once your skin is already in contact with the blade!!!
 
I don't agree. If you do something that is dangerous with a dull knife, it's also a dangerous move with a sharp knife. Just because you can often get away with such a move if the knife is sharp enough doesn't make it safer.

IMO using a knife safely, it doesn't matter if it's sharp or dull. It is mostly about forethought to know where the point/blade is going to go if/when it slips or busts through. After that it's just a matter of paying attention, knowing which muscles to use, knowing which muscles to not use, and having enough coordination to be able to execute, correctly.
 
Is the knife ok?
:D

I did cut my index finger with a small fixed blade roughly three times in a minute trying to get it back in its belt sheath. It now sleeps with the fishes....
 
That's good information to share with everyone and we appreciate allowing others the opportunity to learn these lessons without having to do them on their own.
 
Last edited:
When I was about 12 my dad and I went up to New Hampshire, to an A-frame he was building in the winter. As we were unloading the pickup I grabbed the newly sharpened axe and jumped off the tailgate. As my feet hit the ground the momentum sunk the corner of the axe blade about an inch deep into my left thigh. Like you there was no pain, but no spurting blood.

My dad, a firefighter, just rinsed the wound out, put a piece of gauze over it, and duct taped it down.
 
Ouch! That's what I had wanted to be able to do, but when I looked down in the bathroom and caught a glimpse of bone and felt blood pooling in my sock, I sadly realized that staying low key wouldn't be an option. The pain getting back upstairs convinced me I really needed some serious help!
 
Man that sounds like a moment I had a few years back when I shut off the table saw and then stuck my left hand in to get a block of wood from the side of the blade. Next thing I knew my hand was in the blade and I realized I'd been cut but had no idea of the severity until I looked and saw I still had a index finger and thumb but they were filleted open. Blood everywhere! I was very lucky and it sounds like you were too to not hit anything major.

I'm glad you shared this and we can all use a reality check now and then.

Sometimes when I'm sharpening a knife on the Wicked Edge I'll want to walk away from it for a minute with the blade mounted but I never have - I finish it before taking any breaks even though I might work on it for an hour. We had cats and still have a small dog who can get on my desk via the chair and I would shudder to think of what that knife could do to them if they rubbed up against it. Got to think when you're around sharp knives.
 
So, you're saying Shakespeare knew what he was writing about?

No, ’tis not so deep as a well nor so wide as a church-door, but ’tis enough, ’twill serve. -- the fight scene from Romeo and Juliet, Act 3, Scene 1 (http://nfs.sparknotes.com/romeojuliet/page_144.html)

Glad things weren't any worse for you than they were. We all need to be fully in the moment when we're handling/using dangerous tools. Distraction is dangerous ... and can be deadly.
 
I remember, years ago, reading something while holding a never-used CS Recon Tanto. The back of my leg itched, so I scratched it.

I finished what I was reading, and set it down. Then I set down the RT, and was horrified to notice hair all over the blade. I grabbed the back of my leg, but I had been VERY lucky.

John
 
This is an excellent learning experience from a couple of points. The biggest thing to learn is, how bad a knife is for self defense. Terrible. There is no shock what so ever to the nervous system, zero stopping power. In that minute before your adversary even knows he's been mortally wounded, he's still slashing and stabbing at you, and can still kill you. Just as Noah felt no p[ain, neither will your attacker.

Blunt force trauma wins everyday over cuts and stabs. An attacker may kill you while he's bleeding out, but an attacker with the bones in his weapon hand broken and nerve endings smashed, that hand and arm is out of action.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top