New revolver shooter-Colt or Remington

Status
Not open for further replies.
To me a reproduction is a exact copy of an original item. A replica would be a reasonable facsimile.
2nd and 3rd gen Colts are reproductions of the original revolver, almost identical. A brass frame 51 navy in .44cal would be a replica, close but not a copy of an original.
It boils down to personal interpretation.

After looking at several on-line dictionaries, I see I have it ackbasswards. Both words can have the same meaning

Replica
A replica is a copy that is relatively indistinguishable from the original. Replicas are often used for historical purposes, such as being placed in a museum. Sometimes the original never existed. For example, Difference Engine No. 2, designed by Charles Babbage in the 19th century, was reconstructed from original drawings studied by Allan Bromley in the 1980s and is now on display at the Science Museum in London, England.

However, replicas have often been used illegally for forgery, counterfeits, fakes especially of money & coins, but also commercial merchandise such as designer label clothing, luxury bags & accessories, and last but not least: luxury watches. In arts or historic cars, the term "replica" is used for a non-original recreation, sometimes hiding its real identity.

One definition of "replica" has emerged that defines one as a copy of an original object, that can only be made by the original company (or corporate descendent) of the firm that made the original object-any other sort of copy of an original object would be called a "reproduction" instead.

Because of gun ownership restrictions in some locales, gun collectors often create non-functional legal replicas of illegal firearms. Such replicas are also preferred to real firearms when used as a prop in a stage performance, generally for safety reasons.

re·pro·duc·tion (rpr-dkshn)
n.
1. The act of reproducing or the condition or process of being reproduced.
2. Something reproduced, especially in the faithfulness of its resemblance to the form and elements of the original: a fine reproduction of a painting by Matisse


rep·li·ca (rpl-k)
n.
1. A copy or reproduction of a work of art, especially one made by the original artist.
2. A copy or reproduction, especially one on a scale smaller than the original.

replica
Noun
an exact copy [Italian, literally: a reply]
 
SG said:

Close would be a Reproduction...Looks like it, same caliber, same finnish and Metals...
Replica any variation thats close to what it is suppose to look like...

I agree because in practical usage, non-firing copies are almost always advertised as being a "replica", and reproductions are close copies that will actually fire.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top